Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Revising Article 5 requires absolute consensus---that’s impossible on cyber

Jordan ‘14 [Klara; September 4; Senior Fellow and Assistant Director of the Atlantic Council’s Cyber Statecraft Initiative, LL.M from the Law School at the University of Groningen, Masters in Interdisciplinary European Studies from the Institute of Advanced European Studies, Law Degree from Matej Bel University; National Interest, “Would NATO Go to War Over a Cyberattack?,” https://nationalinterest.org/print/feature/would-nato-go-war-over-cyberattack-11199]

Deliberations on thresholds triggering Article 5 could prove particularly thorny, given the transatlantic divide in views on what consequences are necessary to constitute an armed attack.

For example, the United States may be willing to consider a lower threshold than its less eager European allies for whom only grave uses of force are considered an armed attack. A state’s view of this threshold may well depend on whether it is the victim of an attack or a member called upon to fulfill its collective-defense obligation.

Additionally, Article 5 does not define the nature of that commitment. The treaty allows a member state to take whatever action it deems appropriate to assist an attacked ally—it decides how it will respond in collective defense. A member state may interpret its obligation to respond expansively or in a far more limited manner. So by viewing its Article 5 obligation in a limited way, a member could determine that it is not required to respond with kinetic force to assist an attacked ally, even in cases of destructive cyberevents.

Given the capability, doctrinal and policy divide between NATO members in the cyberarena, an ally might limit its response to entirely nonkinetic measures, such as rerouting Internet traffic through its national network, monitoring networks for future attacks, crisis-management support or diplomatic statements on behalf of the attacked ally.

On the other hand, if NATO determines a cyberattack amounts to an armed attack and invokes Article 5, and undertakes responsive action against an aggressor, member states are not limited to cyber-responses alone; they may also choose to employ kinetic force in the collective defense of the attacked member state. Adoption of this cyberpolicy provides NATO states a wider range of potential options with which they may respond in cases of destructive cyberattacks. NATO allies may respond with cyber- or kinetic tools, or a combination of both, a fact that may help to ensure an Alliance-wide response.

Regardless of the political weight presently attributed to NATO’s expected policy statement, law and policy are inextricably intertwined in the interpretation of Article 5, and the subtleties of its real-world application may make it difficult for the organization to offer the assurances certain allies are seeking with respect to their defense against cyberattacks. As a result, the policy could fall far short of its intended goals.

NATO states could, however, decide to make adoption of its new cyberpolicy a true game changer, to ensure that it becomes a useful framework for addressing the rapidly changing security challenges posed in the cyber-realm.

NATO nations might begin this process by reexamining the threshold requirement for Article 5 application in response to cyberattacks. States could agree, for example, that although some cyberevents may well cause consequential kinetic results (and some of a truly horrific nature), in the cyberworld, requiring kinetic consequences in order to trigger application of the collective-defense requirement does not fully reflect the types of serious crises cyberattacks can trigger.

They could determine, rather, that the appropriate Article 5 threshold in response to cyberevents might also be triggered by the far more likely consequences of large-scale economic disruption with corresponding national- and international-security implications.

This, of course, would require all twenty-eight members to reconsider their long-established views on what constitutes an armed attack under international law, and to achieve consensus on a far more forward-leaning approach. This would, no doubt, be a hugely difficult undertaking. Nevertheless, the development of international law is a continuous process, and states and international organizations should move to adapt it to help meet changing threats.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.