Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The plan’s criteria are useless, gutting norms and causing escalation

Titiriga Remus 13 Assistant professor Inha Law School, 100 Inharo, Nam-gu Incheon 402-751, Korea. "Cyber-attacks and International law of armed conflicts; a “jus ad bellum” perspective." https://media.neliti.com/media/publications/28802-EN-cyber-attacks-and-international-law-of-armed-conflicts-a-jus-ad-bellum-perspecti.pdf

The opposing side argues that the reference to ‘inherent’ right of self-defense preserves ancient customary law, which allowed the anticipatory action.33 Proponents of a broad reading of self-defense invoke the 1837 Caroline incident and suggest that in the nuclear era States cannot be expected to wait for a ‘first strike’. However the majority of scholars reject the precedent value of the Caroline incident based on the fact that it precedes the actual interdiction for the use of force. 34They warn of the risk of escalation that results from accepting anticipatory actions. We think that the latter reason should prevail in the case of cyber-attack and as such, anticipatory self defense should be clearly banned. ii) Interceptive self defense If an armed attack is incipient or is on the verge of beginning, the intended victim may not wait powerlessly for the inevitable blow. The attack can be legitimately intercepted. In fact interceptive (different from anticipatory) self-defense seems to be acceptable under the Charter.35 The theme of interceptive self-defense is pertinent to a computer attack when the intrusion into a computer network has been discovered, although it is not yet lethal to persons or destructive of property (using Schmitt’s analysis). The issue is to determine whether the intrusion may reasonably be seen as a first step of an unavoidable and developing ‘armed attack’. This is a very difficult matter of evaluating and interpreting information available at the time of action (including warnings, intelligence reports and other data). 4. New Horizons and Challenges In the following section we will lance a debate about possible use of cyber means as self-defense or over the boundaries of the classical international paradigm (armed force or armed attack). There are numerous theoretical and practical challenges to be relived in this exploratory topic. 4.1 Computer Attacks as Means of Self Defense If a preceding armed attack (or a computer attack qualified as ‘armed attack’ –according to Schmitt’s analysis) occurred, the possibility to use the computer attacks as legitimate defense seem obvious (legitimate defense allows the use of all military means against an aggression therefore the cyber means should be included). However there are two substantive constraints for the right of self-defense: the criteria of necessity and proportionality. In the Nicaragua case, the International Court of Justice acknowledged the ‘inherent’ right of self-defense as part of customary law. The Court recognized the two criteria, ‘necessity’ and ‘proportionality’, as additional requirements under Article 51.36 i) ‘Necessity’ ‘Necessity’ means that no alternative way of redress may be available and the target should be a military one, in agreement with the rules of International humanitarian law (“jus in bello”). Likewise, ‘necessity’ requires that the timing between the armed attack and the recourse to self-defense to be reasonably short, taking into account the need to carry out investigations and/or negotiations, or to make military preparations (this is an upper time limit while the above discussed interceptive self-defense concerned the lower time limit). ii) ‘Proportionality’ ‘Proportionality’, on the other hand, supposes that the use of self-defense will be weighed against initial armed attack(s), not only in terms of gravity/intensity, but also in terms of duration, location, and range of selected targets. And here lays a real problem for cyber-attack qualifying as self-defense. Computer attacks are naturally uncertain as to the outcome they produce, making difficult to estimate deliberate and collateral damage. In fact the consequences of a cyber-attack may be both direct and indirect, and in some cases the indirect consequences can be higher than direct consequences.37 As result it is very difficult to fulfill the criteria of proportionality in case of a self-defense by way of cyber-attacks. The risk of escalation should prevent this use of cyber-attacks in the present international framework. An eventual solution may be revealed by technological breakthroughs that will allow controlling the outcome of cyber-attacks. But this kind of technological evolution is far from being assured yet. 4.2 Difficulties on the Boundaries of Classical Paradigm: Cyber Means Not Qualifying as “Armed Force” or “Armed Attack” Much more appealing might be an analysis of the use of cyber-attacks in response to an initial act (a computer network attack) not achieving the threshold of “armed attack” (Schmitt’s criteria). i) Computer network attacks not achieving the threshold of “armed attack” If an initial (cyber) attack does not reach the threshold of an”armed attack” there is no right of selfdefense. We should examine the case of a computer attack used in retaliation short of the right to selfdefense. This situation is not purely hypothetical since there are plans to use computer attacks as counter offensive instruments. For example Col. Charles W. Williamson 38 argued that an Air Force-controlled ‘botnet’ could be a cost-effective mean to protect military networks. He envisioned collecting computers that would otherwise be discarded and remove their hard drives by making them available to launch attacks against foreign-based computers targeting American military facilities. To prevent collateral damage this ‘botnet’ would have built-in filters preventing US military and government computers from being targeted. We think that Schmitt’s threshold of an “armed attack” by cyber means (and the corresponding right to self-defense) is not attained in the example above. At this point we are considering a non-military ‘retaliation’. However this kind of action brings up tremendous risks for cyber escalation linked to the obvious indiscriminate nature of computer attacks. All those affected by this computer retaliation may react with devastating (deliberate and collateral) effects to networks. This outcome could, by aggregation and escalation, finally trigger a classical armed conflict. The dangers are too high to consider this kind of action. i) The exception of espionage and the challenge of multi-purpose nature of cyber means If there is no destructive outcome (lacking the threshold in Schmitt’s analysis) the cyber means could be covered by the espionage exception in interstate relations. These are harmful actions (not illegal from the point of view of armed conflict) that each state use constantly. Nevertheless some problems related to the nature of cyber means remain unclear. Cyber means are by nature multi-purpose tools (‘weapons’). The methods used for computer network exploitation are similar to those used for computer network attack, but configured for different objectives. For example the Wall Street Journal claimed 39 that some agents from China and Russia, along with several other countries, had infiltrated computer systems charged with managing electricity in the US. They left behind software which could be used to control or disable electric grids of the country. Security experts stated that while the incident showed gaps in the US security infrastructure in time of conflict, such an attack could have catastrophic effects. In this case, a cyber-activity (intelligence-gathering) can easily become, if undetected, the ground for a future cyber-attack. In situations like this, the only solution for the offended State is to use its own cyber exploitation or cyber defense instruments while the use of computer attacks in retaliation would be the least reasonable choice (even less reasonable than in the above example of cyber retaliation to a previous computer attack not qualifying as “armed attack”). This is another example where classical armed conflict framework seems unable to cover certain cyber means characteristics.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.