Russian cyber probes produce a European SOI
David Takacs 17, Associate Fellow at Slovak Security Policy Institute. "Ukraine‘s deterrence failure: Lessons for the Baltic States." DOI 10.1515/jobs-2017-0001
Russia and its revisionist behaviour present the Baltic States with a multitude of threats, making deterrence a top priority in the Baltic Region. Not only does Moscow wish to extend its sphere of influence to include what it describes as ‘near abroad’, it must carefully protect its own model of ‘sovereign democracy’ at home. Prior to Russian involvement, Ukraine was getting close to signing an association agreement with the European Union (EU) and it was feared that ‘democratic change in brotherly Ukraine could spread to Russia’. Transforming Ukraine to a western democracy was seen as a threat to the Russian regime and was thus stymied at its source (Snegovaya, 2014). However, the Baltic States have already been fully integrated into NATO and the (EU) and have been stable democracies for over two decades now. So what is the nature of the threat that Russia presents to the Baltic States?
Putin is using hybrid tactics as a means of achieving his objectives of a politically restructured Europe. These include massive pro-Russian propaganda and misinformation campaigns, using economic levers, intimidation, or the employment of cyber warfare elements. In Ukraine in 2014, Russia has once again demonstrated its resolve to use both military and non-military means to create and fuel conflicts in pursuit of its wider geopolitical interests. The Kremlin is busily trying to regain its sphere of influence over nations that were formerly part of the Soviet Union, and the Baltic States’ governments are continuously being reminded to stay alert. In addition, NATO frontier allies face much more significant threats due to their proximity to the potential aggressor (Grygiel and Mitchell, 2016, p. 166). Thus, what NATO needs most to deter Russia is ‘to demonstrate robust political solidarity’ within the alliance (NATO Parliamentary Assembly Report, 2015, pp. 4-6). There has been a significant increase in Russian probing activities to gauge NATO’s commitment to the Baltic States over the past two years. Grygiel and Mitchell (2016, p. 43) define Russian probing as a ‘lowmintensity and low-risk test aimed at gauging the opposing state´s power and will to maintain security and influence over a region’. In case of the Baltic States, probing is aimed at the US and the strongest European countries, their power and their will to back up their most exposed allies. As mentioned by Grygiel and Mitchell (2016, p. 122), ‘there is a strong correlation between the existence of alliances in a given region and the effectiveness of deterrence against a threatening power’. Building on the allies’ fear of abandonment and US fear of entrapment in local conflicts, Russia is aiming to hinder their relationships which could ultimately provide Moscow with more room for probing and manoeuvring in the Baltic Region.
Hybrid or conventional?