Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The U.S. is an alt-cause to gunboat diplomacy.

1AC author: Patrick C. R. Terry 19, dean of the faculty of law at the University of Public Administration in Kehl, Germany, “The Return of Gunboat Diplomacy: How the West has Undermined the Ban on the Use of Force,” Harvard National Security Journal Volume 10, https://harvardnsj.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/13/2019/02/Return-of-Gunboat-Diplomacy.pdf

Although incompatible with Article 51 and not supported by sufficient state practice, a tendency is discernible whereby the United States and some of its allies, such as the U.K., Australia, and Israel are attempting to establish preventive self defense as yet another legal recourse to the use of force. The disadvantages and dangers of this strategy are manifold. The main weakness of “forcible counter-proliferation” is its ability to undermine stability in international relations and the rule of law.278 Its supporters seem to believe that it is possible to restrict the legality of such actions to cases where the United States or close allies deem them necessary—which is unrealistic and incompatible with sovereign equality.279 Once preventive self-defense is legal, there is no reason why India could not decide that it is necessary to preventively strike Pakistan, which possesses nu- clear weapons (or vice versa). Extended to other WMD, there are many more volatile situations which would seemingly justify the use of force280 and today’s ally is often tomorrow’s “rogue state,” and vice versa (Iran and Iraq being prime examples).281 Many western proponents of preventive self-defense also seem to believe that a state viewed by the United States and its allies as “rogue” is universally recognized as such, which is not the case.282 To others, the rule of law seems to be equivalent to U.S. rule, a view often confirmed when U.S. actions are claimed to have created new international law without any analysis of the practice or views of other states.283 It is, however, unlikely that other powerful states, such as China, Russia, or India will accept this U.S.-centric view. In conclusion, “preventive” selfdefense is not lawful, nor should it be. Nevertheless, many western states seek to undermine its ban.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.