Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

And, the aff produces reluctance to invoke Article V early in a crisis. That “wait-and-see” posture complicates crisis escalation management later.

Murauskaite et al. ’19 [Egle Murauskaite, David Quinn, Catarina P. Thomson, Devin H. Ellis, Jonathan Wilkenfeld, Erik Gartzke; Senior Non-resident Fellow with the ICONS Project at the University of Maryland; 5/10/19; “Extended Deterrence Dilemmas in the Grey Zone: Trans-Atlantic Insights on Baltic Security Challenges”; https://content.sciendo.com/view/journals/jobs/5/2/article-p5.xml; Journal on Baltic Security, Vol. 5, Issue 2]

The first exercise was conducted in fall of 2016, in support of U.S. SOCEUR, and involved 29 expert respondents. The scenario vignette explored a series of suspicious Russia-linked incidents against Latvia: a cyberattack against the energy grid, an explosion in a Russian-language middle school, and staged protests in Riga. As Baltic, American, and Western European experts addressed these crises, several important findings emerged. The first was that both Latvia and its neighbour Lithuania delayed asking for Western assistance as long as possible – U.S. and/or NATO assistance in handling Russian interference was likely seen as the ultimate trump card to be called upon only at the darkest hour (which any individual grey zone crisis hardly qualified as, though their cumulative impact was approaching the threshold). The problem was that it significantly complicated escalation management, depriving allied decision-makers of a series of tools that could help de-escalate the conflict early and giving rise to more possibilities for the adversary to sow discord and ambiguity among the allies. The second important insight was that the EU played a significantly more important role than NATO in managing the grey zone crises – turning to NATO resources was seen as too escalatory a step. The third significant insight was that although the experts agreed at the outset on the importance for NATO and the EU to maintain a united front, during any particular crisis there was a tendency to conduct bilateral talks with Russia, trying to resolve the situation without involving the target state (i.e. Latvia) directly – which inevitably backfired.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.