Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Closing the window of escalation encourages adversaries -- their choice of grey-zone threats signals sensitivity to escalation.

Takahashi '19 [Sugio; 1/9/19; Chief of Policy Simulation at the National Institute of Defense Studies, MA in Political Science from Waseda University; "Development of gray-zone deterrence: concept building and lessons from Japan’s experience," The Pacific Review, Vol. 31, Issue 6, p. 787-810]

Third aspect of gray zone deterrence is that deterring states should never close the window for escalation. The main reason why the challengers use gray zone threats to change the status quo is that, first, they are discontent with the status quo and, second, they recognize their inferiority in conventional military challenge (Mazzar, 2015). The challenger may choose gray zone creeping expansion, rather than conventional military challenge, because the cost of conventional military challenge would easily exceed potential gain. Therefore, they may refrain from launching the challenge in the first place if they realize that their expansion has plausible risk of escalating to military conflict. The tripwire definitely has an effect that the challenger estimates higher possibility for escalation. If deterring states absolutely refrain from escalating countermeasures, the challenger side can continue gray zone creeping expansion eternally without taking any risk accompanied with escalation. In order to stop them, the deterring side needs to develop robust posture to win the possible war in the case of escalation, and make the challengers recognize the possibility of unfavorable military conflict. The critical role of military force, which cannot be substituted by other toolkit of statecraft, exists in this aspect of gray zone deterrence. And in this context, war-fighting capabilities still have an irreplaceable role to play.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.