Limitations buck the trend – honoring collective defense requests is key to cyber-assurance.
Piret Pernik 14 {Piret Pernik is a Researcher of Strategy Branch of the NATO CCDCOE. Her main research areas are cyber security strategies and policies, horizon scanning and analysis of cyber threats, and the development of military cyber organizations. September 2014. “Improving Cyber Security: NATO and the EU.” https://icds.ee/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/Piret_Pernik_-_Improving_Cyber_Security.pdf}//JM
Development of the approaches of NATO and the EU The principal focus of NATO’s cyber defence approach has always been the protection of its own headquarters, agencies, and operations. The Alliance has been improving its cyber defence capabilities since 1990s. The first well-known cyber incident against NATO took place in 1999 during NATO’s operation “Allied Force” in Kosovo when hacker groups from Russia and Serbia disrupted NATO’s internal systems.14 Few years later, at the Prague Summit in 2002, cyber security appeared for the first time on NATO’s political agenda with NATO declaring to “strengthen our capabilities to defend against cyber attacks.”15 In the same year, the North Atlantic Council (NAC) approved a Cyber Defence Programme and as part of this, the NATO Computer Incident Response Capability (NCIRC) - NATO’s emergency team to prevent, detect and respond to cyber incidents - was created.16 The cyber attacks against Estonia in 2007 that disabled its governmental, media and financial websites and the Russia-Georgia war in 2008 that included military offence against Georgian military forces and cyber attacks against Georgian webpages17 helped NATO to realize how it was behind in cyber space. Subsequently, the Alliance’s focus broadened from the security of its own networks to that of its member states.18 In January 2008 NATO approved its first Policy on Cyber Defence stressing “the need for NATO and nations to protect key information systems […]; share best practices; and provide a capability to assist Allied nations, upon request, to counter a cyber attack.”19 In the same year, it established the Cyber Defence Management Authority (CDMA) to coordinate cyber defence, review capabilities and conduct appropriate security risk management across the Alliance. It also accredited the Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre for Excellence (CCD COE) with the main objectives to improve the interoperability of NATO and enhance cyber awareness, education, and training efforts. In 2009 cyber defence was rendered an integral part of NATO exercises. In 2010 the Lisbon Summit addressed cyber defence capabilities gaps including improvements to the NCIRC, and in the same year the Emerging Security Challenges Division was created within NATO International Staff with a mandate to analyse among other asymmetrical threats cyber threats. The Defence Policy and Planning Committee/Cyber Defence (from 2014 titled the Cyber Defence Committee) was also established to provide political-level guidance and oversight. In 2011 the Cyber Defence Management Board (CDMB, supplanted CDMA), which consists of NATO cyber experts at the political, military, operational, and technical levels was set up. Its purpose is to coordinate cyber defence activities throughout NATO and associated agencies, and to facilitate implementation of NATO’s cyber defence policies and capabilities.20 In June 2011 a revised Cyber Defence Policy was approved, confirming the resolve to protect NATO’s networks and assist member states in the event of cyber attack. It also commanded the establishment of two cyber Rapid Response Teams (RRTs) by the end of 2012 with a core of six professionals that can be deployed within 24 hours to a member state.21 Any NATO nation under cyber attack could request the team’s assistance through the CDMB22, the deployment must be approved by the North Atlantic Council (which may be politically challenging). The policy also defined minimum requirements to national networks critical to NATO’s core tasks and assistance to the Allies to achieve the minimum levels of security. Additionally, the Defence Policy and Planning Committee in Reinforced format (DPPC(R)) was set up to oversee the work of CDMB and manage the overall planning process, including cyber capabilities.23 In 2012 the NATO Communications and Information Agency (NCIA) was established.24