Consensus ensures any Article V invocation will trigger infighting and delays
Dunivan 15 – Lieutenant Colonel in the US Army and Assistant Professor at U.S. Army Command and General Staff College (Jim, “Challenges, Capability and Will: Is NATO Relevant in the Twenty-first Century?” School of Advanced Military Studies at United States Army Command and General Staff College, 5-23-15, https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/AD1001278.pdf) //nt-sg
That being said, consensus in and of itself is one of the primary challenges to the continued relevance of the Alliance. Consensus within NATO constitutes compromise among the membership for action. While the idea of consensus has always served as a fundamental and valued principle within the Alliance, it is worth noting that compromise, by its very definition of agreement through concessions or adjustment, is rarely an optimum solution. Additionally, in their report to the Secretary General to inform the development of the 2010 NATO Strategic Concept, the Group of Experts put forth that:
there is an inherent tension between a multimember organization that works by consensus and a military/political Alliance operating in a fluid and fast-paced security environment...However, the need to achieve agreement...can prove arduous, sometimes leading to delays that serve no constructive purpose. In addition, the Alliance needs to prepare for situations where rapid (indeed almost instantaneous) decision-making may be required.
While the Group of Experts was correct to identify this challenge, there has been little to no apparent progress in streamlining the overall process of collaborative decision making for the Alliance. One member of the European Union Military Staff, another organization that has membership size and consensus issues, commented that it is hard to create a shared vision when you have twenty-eight members sitting around the table. This combination of real or perceived less than optimal solutions derived from a cumbersome and obstacle-laden process presents challenges to the reliability and credibility of NATO as a relevant force of action.