Settler Colonialism is the grounding force of the international – the understanding as colonialism as a domestic matter forgoes the way that Settler Colonialism was a project of domination in the name of civilizing the savage
Davis 20 (Making a settler colonial IR: Imagining the ‘international’ in early Australian International Relations, Alexander E. Davis is a postdoctoral research fellow at La Trobe University's Department of Politics, Media and Philosophy, Australia. Review of International Studies (2020), https://research-repository.uwa.edu.au/en/publications/59daafa6-b580-4b7f-8c24-f4599ccaf5f5) // JLHS AA
Sitting alongside themes of imperialism, internationalism, and realism in the study of Australian IR, was a stream of thought on race and empire that focused on settlement. For the history of international thought, this is significant. The control of territory by settlers is the foundational concern of the Australian state. This was therefore foundational to its international thought and its politics. The blurring of the international and the domestic, structured around racial categories and seeking to maintain and advance white supremacy, was a constitutive element of the founding of IR in Australia. This lines up closely with Vitalis’s findings in the US.105 Australia’s Others under IR’s gaze were primarily its nearest neighbours, its colonial projects, and those within: its own settlement, its immigration policy and its Indigenous population. Although dominated by a white man’s view of the world, there were contributions made by women throughout this period. Prior to Coral Bell’s taking up of a realist framework, though, these contributions were sometimes confined to subjects stereotyped as feminine. The settlement of the Northern Territory and the rest of Australia remained parts of Australian IR through the Austral-Asiatic Bulletin’s time as its primary publication outlet. The study of imperial affairs, based on the development of societies, was slowly shifting into the study of international affairs. At this moment in Australian IR, the two sat alongside one another: with articles on events in China and Japan placed next to discussion of the colonial development of Northern Australia and New Guinea. Imperialism and racial development politics sat alongside analysis of great power conflict in East Asia. The Second World War led to another reshaping of Australia’s international thought. The first IR department in the country was placed within Pacific Studies, which was intended to focus on both East Asia and Australia’s colonial projects. Still, race as an explicit subject of IR in Australia shifted, and the explicit maintenance of racial hierarchies moved into racialised psychological and cultural explanations of the irrationality of the postcolonial societies. This erasure made it more difficult to analyse race and racism, allowing them to continue unchecked. In terms of our disciplinary historiography, it led to the exclusion of empire and settlement as insufficiently international to be analysed. We might be tempted to think that, because settlement and land tenure are not viewed as ‘international’ today, we can simply erase them from our disciplinary memory. To do so is anachronistic. Colonial settlement was thought of as international affairs. It was a common topic, discussed thoroughly and regularly. Forgetting this effectively produces the excision of Australia’s settler colonial history from its international affairs. The connection between land, sovereignty, and settlement remains foundational to the international system. That a series of colonial questions of settlement sat alongside Australia’s early studies of its relationship with East Asia reflects the transition from a broadly colonial system to an international system. This transition was not simple or straightforward. It is not even complete. Australia has not decolonised. Neglecting this transition closes our eyes to the contemporary politics of race and hierarchy that postcolonial scholars of IR have repeatedly and forcefully emphasised. Australia’s contemporary international affairs, questions about its defence, Australia’s positioning inside or outside Asia, its relationship with Pacific island neighbours, its strategic culture, fears about foreign ownership of land, all look very different if we place them in this context. If we accept that settler colonial ideologies were a key element of the founding of Australian IR, a claim for which there is ample evidence, IR in Australia needs urgent critical reflection. Australian settlement means the dehumanisation and the genocide of existing populations. This continues today. Settler colonial Australian IR justified and argued for this, presenting it as natural and desirable. As Vitalis put it in the US context, ‘the history of ideas, institutions, and practices has a constitutive role in their present forms and functions’. 106 While Australian IR forgets its settler history, policies of dispossession and intervention, and the ‘civilising mission’, continue at home and abroad.107 Australian foreign policy, often wrapped in liberal idealism, normalises and affirms settler colonialism. We would need to engage deeply with Indigenous perspectives about Australia and the world to understand this in the present. Sadly, few, if any, such voices are in dialogue with IR in Australia. I can only conclude that the rot is particularly deep. Forgetting this history cleanses our thought of colonial violence and the settlement of Australia, making it impossible to reckon with. Addressing these issues requires more than a mild and unthreatening ‘diversification’ of the discipline’s voices, but a thorough and conscious effort to decolonise, which challenges our foundational assumptions.