Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The 1ac’s invocation of article 5 is representative of the isopolitical relation that normative IR functions under which guarantees a world centered around America as the epicenter

Veracini 11 (Lorenzo Veracini s a historian and professor at Swinburne University of Technology’s Institute for Social Research. He is the editor in chief of Settler Colonial Studies and has been a key figure in the development of the field of settler colonialism. (2011) ISOPOLITICS, DEEP COLONIZING, SETTLER COLONIALISM, Interventions: International Journal of Postcolonial Studies, 13:2, 171-189, DOI: 10.1080/1369801X.2011.573215, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/1369801X.2011.573215) // JLHS AA

Isopolitical interstate associations are especially relevant to settler colonial phenomena. An isopolitical connection enables the seamless transfer of people and their rights between separate polities. In this context, subjects of one polity immediately acquire property rights and enjoy unrestricted political status as they move across jurisdictions. If settlers can be defined as founders of political orders (unlike migrants, who are appellants facing a political order that is already constituted), people who travel with an inherent capacity to possess real estate and father children endowed with political rights, colonizing metropole and settler locale are united in an isopolitical relation. Settlers are indeed subjects who, unlike migrants or other colonized people, can immediately exercise commercium and connubium, both necessary elements of all isopolitical arrangements (of course, not all settlers depart and arrive autonomously, or are immediately endowed with political rights; they can, however, be selectively co-opted at a later stage). Moreover, isopolities, one specific type of ‘interstate kinship’ (Elwyn 1993), and settler colonies are especially related: settler colonialism is inherently about the reproduction of ‘daughter’ colonies. The classical world envisaged a variety of possible relationships between separate political entities, including, for example, isopolity, sympolitical arrangements (when a common federal citizenship is instituted beside the local one), and symmachy (when a warring league is established, with a polity automatically engaging in war as an ally of another). Not all the isopolities of the classical world were colonies, but all colonies were isopolitical (for a discussion of isopolitical relations in the classical world, see Hammond 1951). We should recover this variety and utilize it as a conceptual toolbox in an attempt to escape the constraints of national teleologies and the nation-state. Moreover, even if these categories may look exotic and anachronistic, we should keep in mind that the colonizations practised by the Greeks and the Romans informed in fundamental ways the colonial imaginaries of the European expansion. The intensity of colonialism’s imaginative engagement with the ancients should not be underestimated. The question of how British settler nationalisms and metropolitan imperialisms have co-defined each other while operating concomitantly and in reciprocal tension in a variety of settings is the subject of an extensive scholarly literature, and an issue that is periodically approached (and yet rarely resolved).1 The settler nationalisms of the British Empire (and their respective sub-imperialisms) remain intractably ambivalent: their claims are routinely premised on their arising simultaneously from the settler locale and in relation to the originating metropole (see Berger 1970; Schreuder and Ward 2008). Reflecting on the long-term evolution of the relationship between Australian nationalism and Britishness, and convincingly reversing received nationalist and nationalizing assumptions, Neville Meaney concluded that ‘the history of nationalism in Australia was not one of thwarted Australianness but rather of thwarted Britishness’ (2001: 89). ‘Australians had two views of Britain and the Empire’, he noted; ‘while they overlapped’, they remained distinct. accommodate double allegiances, an isopolitical union allows one to be faithful to a relationship; one does not have to choose. At the same time, isopolitical ties also allow for the local settler claim and the metropolitan one potentially to enjoy equal status; as such, settler colonial formations fundamentally challenge the hierarchical relationship between core and periphery that is inherent in colonial and imperial relations. The distinction between ‘settlers’ and ‘colonists’ as distinct terms and their usage mirrors this shift. ‘Colonist’, ‘colonial’ and ‘creole’ identify people in the context of a hierarchical understanding of the relationship between metropole and settler locale; ‘settler’, on the contrary, expresses a marked degree of political autonomy. Settlers imagine a non-subordinate relationship between settler locale and metropole they operate isopolitically.4 (On the other hand, there is another fundamental distinction that separates ‘colonists’ and ‘settlers’: a ‘colonist’ is someone who may or may not be animated by animus returnandi his intention to stay in the settler locale remains unclear until the question of whether he is a bona fide settler a determination that only a settler society would demand forces the issue. A colonist could indeed be someone bent on accumulating money and returning home, someone who is not fully committed to the local settler project.) In this context, Edward Gibbon Wakefield, for example, espoused a ‘colonial’ conception. In ‘A View on the Art of Colonization’ he noted: speaking generally, colonies and colonists are in fact, as well as in the estimation of the British gentry, inferior, low, unworthy of much respect, properly disliked and despised by people of honour here, who happen to be acquainted with the state of society in the colonies. (Wakefield 1968: 837) Wakefield thus envisaged a hierarchically integrated system with the colonizing metropole on top, and the settler colonial locales as its subordinate elements (however, he was convinced that the settler locales could be made to look very much like the metropole and that this could be done immediately in this sense he proposed that their relationship with the colonizing core be only marginally subordinate). Of course, ‘colonist’ and ‘settler’ as distinct even if often partially overlapping categories interacted in a very dynamic context, and their usage and respective meanings underwent important shifts. As James Belich has recently and persuasively documented, ‘settler’ became progressively more important (on ‘settlerism’, the ideology of the ‘settler revolution’, see Belich (2009: 15365); on shifting patterns of perception, see Grant (2005)). The debates that propelled and accompanied the ‘settler revolution’ during the second half of the nineteenth century comprehensively reinterpreted the relationship between core and periphery. In this context, the settler locale 4 Greene (2002) also emphasizes this distinction: ‘my use of the term settlers is deliberate’, he notes, ‘it has long been employed in the historical analysis of other nations that arose out of the British Empire (Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and South Africa), because it avoids the dependency implications associated with the word colonists (metropolitans always considered colonists to be a category of others)’ (251). On the contradiction between Jeffersonian settlerism and the Hamiltonian ‘creole complex’, see Goudie (2009was redefined as a site for possible political regeneration. J. S. Mill, for example, thought that the colonies he meant the settler colonies could be sites for unprecedented experimentation (see Bell 2010). Belich is right in using a terminology that emphasizes rupture and discontinuity. This was a revolutionary reconceptualization: whereas according to a colonial paradigm the settler locale is appropriate only as far as it resembles the metropole, according to the settler colonial one the settler locale is appropriate primarily because it is dissimilar to it. A colonial relationship was thus reconfigured into a settler colonial one and the imagination became isopolitical. The global settler ‘revolution’, in fact, entailed a global isopolitical turn. And yet, this revolution was grounded in another. The American one had terminated a sympolitical project and defeated a centralizing metropolitan effort to ensure sustained metropolitan ascendancy over its dependencies. Thus, as well as breaking up the first British Empire, the American Revolution could also be seen as actually reconstituting a new one in an alternative form. Not for nothing has Eliga H. Gould defined the second British Empire as a non-unitary collection of polities, ‘a consortium of realms and provinces’. He linked this diversity with the outcome of the Revolution: parliament, he noted, never again attempted to tax in a direct manner the settlers of the empire (Gould 1999: 482). The independence of the North American colonies thus led to a consolidation of (settler) isopolitical forms within the British Empire; that isopolitical ties could grow and consolidate both inside and outside the United States should be emphasized (Belich 2005). The American Revolution could then be seen as an earlier isopolitical moment in a consolidating and expanding settler colonial world. The isopolitical entity that nineteenth-century debates over emigration and ‘systematic’ colonization dealt with is generally referred to as ‘Greater Britain’ (even if, as mentioned, isopolitical imaginings involved the expanding United States as well; see, for example, Kramer 2002; Bell 2007; Belich 2009, esp. 465501). Isopolitics are relevant to these debates. Influential historian J. R. Seeley, for example, was explicitly in favour of isopolitical relationships: in his opinion, the British Empire should do ‘what the United States does so easily, that is hold together in a federal union countries very remote from each other’ (quoted in Gould 1999: 487, n. 50). Froude would argue in very similar terms (see Bell 2009). Seeley’s Expansion of England actually had an educational purpose; it aimed to describe an ‘ethnological unity’ comprising the colonies of settlement, the Caribbean, but not India because it had been ‘conquered’ (Seeley 1931). It was Seeley that popularized ‘Greater Britain’, but the term had originally been invented by Charles Dilke (2005). Seeley was based in Cambridge; E. A. Freeman (a bit later) lectured at Oxford; this was in fact a coherent if not coordinated effort aimed at rethinking the very nature of empire. Freeman toured the United States in 18812, and referred to ‘brethren in a higher brotherhood, born of one ancient stock, speaking one ancient tongue, sharers under different forms in one ancient freedom’ (quoted in Armitage 1999: 437). Sharing ‘under different forms in one ancient freedom’ is a key trait of this type of discourse, a formulation that ultimately amounts to a description of isopolitical ties, where specific entitlements are transferred to different settings and flexibly accommodate changing political circumstances. Albert Venn Dicey, one of the founders of the London School of Economics, eventually explicitly called in 1897 for the establishment of an ‘isopolity’ of the English race (he interpreted it as ‘common citizenship’ ‘isopolity’ was probably only explicitly mentioned at the end of decades of sustained debate because in many ways it had previously gone without saying). Uniting Britain and its settler dominions and the United States, this entity was to be a response to global geopolitical shifts. While Dicey specifically argued that an isopolity should be merely formalized in order to mirror already existing conditions, he was clearly imagining a community of white men: he excluded indigenous peoples from the working of its proposed isopolity, and suggested that an isopolitical move could be effectively used against the migration to the United States of a variety of undesirables (Dicey 1897: 4634, 466). While this framing is a reminder that settler colonial formations are equally exclusive of indigenous and exogenous alterities, his proposal did not ultimately meet with political support. Nation-states were on the rise, but what is remarkable in this context is that in proposing a union between Greater Britain and the United States Dicey was actually taking for granted the sustained isopolitical union of Britain and its settler colonies. Even if the national paradigm was eventually asserted, the long-lasting resilience of isopolitical sensibilities as they applied transnationally to Greater Britain (and the United States) should be emphasized (see, for examples, Gorman 2002; Lake 2003; Lake and Reynolds 2008). Winston Churchill eventually wrote an isopolitical History of the English-Speaking Peoples (see Armitage 1999: 429). The empire proper was then dissolving in the context of a model of decolonization that focused on Westphalian sovereign independence for former colonial possessions; the Commonwealth, despite the protestations and recalcitrance of its settler constituents, had been reorganized in ways that were now including formerly colonized Others (and enlisting them for the Cold War effort), but the ‘empire of racial identity’ was still showing a stubborn imaginative resilience. Isopolity (and indeed simmachy these are times of automatic intervention in foreign theatres) retains contemporary relevance. The ‘special relationship’ between Israel and the United States, for example, is premised on the seamless transfer of people and their rights across jurisdictions and is underpinned by an extraordinary imaginary engagement that is in turn sustained by a shared settler colonial sensitivity (Veracini 2007). Isopolitics should not be seen as solely restricted to the past. Recovering the isopolitical character of settler colonial imaginaries is also important because a focus on the tension between ‘colonial’ subordination and ‘independent’ national sovereignty can make settler colonialism disappear. Both in Canadian and US historiographies, for example, a focus on the fundamental rupture represented by American independence has contributed to making an appraisal of settler colonial phenomena especially difficult (it is probably no coincidence that settler colonialism as a transnational interpretative category is an Australasian contribution). In the United States it resulted in an emphasis on accomplished sovereign national independence; in Canada, on the contrary, it produced an emphasis on a sustained relationship and institutional connection with Britain. A focus on the anticolonial struggle against the British occupiers traditionally prevented ‘colonialism’ from entering the analytical field in the United States, while in Canada ‘colonialism’ did not enter the analytical field because it was by definition something done by someone else. Even the historiographical revisions introduced since the late 1960s did not focus on settler colonialism: in the United States the main argument was that, although it had been previously denied, US foreign and internal engagements were actually imperialist (see Kaplan and Pease (1993), which reflected authoritatively on two decades of historiographical revision); in Canada the argument was that British imperialism was actually Canadian imperialism (see Berger (1970), which authoritatively initiated two decades of historiographical revision). The dialectical opposition between rupture and institutional continuity thus prevented an engagement with settler colonialism as an interpretative category. Without an appraisal of isopolitical relationships, settler colonialism can disappear from view.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.