Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The settler state is structured by the erasure of indigenous political difference through spatiotemporal exclusion – the aff’s reliance on state-centric fiat as the basis for debate is a reification of eliminatory violence.

Strakosch and Macoun ’12 -- Elizabeth Strakosch is a senior lecturer in public policy and governance at the University of Queensland, and her work focuses on Indigenous policy, colonialism, political relationships, bureaucracy and new public management. Her research explores the connections between political relationships and policy systems in Australia and other settler contexts. contexts. Alissa Macoun is a Lecturer in the School of Justice at Queensland University of Technology. She is interested in the politics of race and contemporary colonialism. (Elizabeth Strakosch and Alissa Macoun, 8-14-2012, "The vanishing endpoint of settler https://d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/30618693/Arena_Journal_Vanishing_Endpoint-with-cover-page-v2.pdf?Expires=1641292909&Signature=ChuVXBZ8Rm1bur5JH2dQc5JWgaB7MbFAPs1cNeI35Eh1XzeGWPa2rtYC2dUiBrNmekVJBkim0VJNQ7YbXkuur3yBbhPhZix1z0n7k9n1JqxPcxK6tucFsuicP6kp9dPeEF23gClX26-9QbmukrpidEVgb6x4ysdi8c0JcSd1GQYnOTHpYngupZDn3NV-s1GCe5so8pVOrrOaPKVg5LXydJJkIb9tYKnZV1TGPophuk21rXLXZczrr6~GcwSYxIZw9uWVt8MNgCV6zh9H5edp~CWh-gA6cuCny-bACDvjQB~F7eluH5ooNGx-J7u4YPQsh3m-uIeMR8zhhZDQwxa81g__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA, accessed 1-4-2022)//nikki

The elimination of Indigenous political difference Settler colonialism is a powerful contemporary force that continues to structure the Australian state’s relationship with Indigenous peoples and to obscure this structuring. It is distinct from postcolonialism, which refers to those large sections of the world that have undergone decolonization by European powers and now face highly mediated global systems of imperial control.8 Colonial theorizing has been dominated by scholars from post-colonial contexts, and this has led to ‘an oddly monolithic, and surprisingly unexamined, notion of colonialism’ that operates problematically in relation to Australia.9 Post-colonial concepts of colonialism assume a moment of transformative restructuring which has not occurred in settler colonies such as Australia, Canada and New Zealand. This locates ‘real’ colonialism in the past, and assumes that now policy must deal with the ‘legacies’, ‘heritage’ or ‘reverberative after math’ of colonialism in today’s world — a language that is powerfully present in Australian policy analysis.10 Patrick Wolfe identifies settler colonialism as operating through the ‘logic of elimination’. Settlers aim to replace Indigenous peoples on their land, not to simply exploit natural resources or extract surplus value from Indigenous labour.11 This means that ‘all the Indigenous person needs to do to get in the way of the settler colonial project is to stay at home’.12 Elimination can be physical, but need not be. It can also involve eliminating officially recognized Aboriginal people through ‘blood quotas’, or assimilating them into white society in ways that sever connections to their Aboriginality.13 This conception of elimination resonates with Indigenous observations about the particular disregard that Aboriginal peoples have been subject to in Australia. Norm Sheehan claims that (contra post-colonial theory) Aborigines have not been positioned as ‘the other’ but as ‘the non-other’.14 Irene Watson points to the continual ‘negation of Aboriginal identity’.15 Lyndon Murphy identifies all Australian social policy as ‘terra nullius social policy’ because ‘it operates from a premise of nonrecognition’.16 However, while many agree upon the operation of this eliminatory logic, its object is less clear.17 Is it Indigenous people, Indigenous culture or Indigenous connections to land? The reason that identifying the structural target of the settlercolonial logic of elimination is difficult may simply be that this target shifts. At different historical points, Australian policy-makers have defined different targets of elimination and mobilized the appro - priate policy strategies. While independent Aboriginal existence clearly poses some sort of problem for settler-colonial society, mem - bers of that society have always contested the level and aspects of Indigenous existence that it can tolerate and successfully absorb.18 Recognizing that this logic is always in operation, and is always directed at some aspect of Indigenous existence, seems to capture an important dimension of settler-colonial policy-making. Govern - ments since the 1800s have used the language of ‘the Aboriginal Problem’.19 While the definitions of the specific nature of this problem rapidly change, there is an underlying recognition that the existence and character of Aboriginal people constitute some sort of ongoing political difficulty and that ‘government, rather than citizens, is expected to “do something about it”’.20 Using this approach it is possible to identify patterns in policymaking without searching for the definitive structural target of the logic of elimination. Patrick Wolfe identifies the Indigenous connection to land as particularly threatening to settler-colonial society,21 and others have also traced recurring policy attempts to sever these connections.22 This is because in Western polities land is simultaneously a physical commercial resource and a marker of the boundaries of sovereign authority; land is also territory. Sovereignty is understood to mean supreme and indivisible authority over all within a territory.23 Therefore, the existence of independent or unknown Indigenous polities within territorial boundaries automatically exposes colonial sovereignty, and hence the contemporary settler-colonial project itself, as incomplete. However, we identify another aspect of Aboriginal existence regularly targeted for elimination, at once more limited and more expansive: Indigenous political difference.24 Indigenous people continue to be framed as a political problem, even in instances when they are permanently dispossessed of their traditional lands. Indigenous political difference that cannot be contained or expressed within the confines of the settler state cannot be tolerated by the settler-colonial project, even if this project can absorb some elements of Indigenous society, culture and even land ownership. There are a number of ways to eliminate Indigenous political difference: by physically eliminating Indigenous people; by severing their physical connections to lands that lie at the heart of their political systems; by breaking down families and communities; by drawing Indigenous polities into the state and reforming them; and by entering into explicit, contractual exchanges (such as treaties) which publicly erase the political distinctions between colonizer and colonized. Patrick Wolfe argues that, overall, ‘settler colonialism is an inclusive, land-centered project that coordinates a comprehensive range of agencies, from the metropolitan centre to the frontier encampment, with a view to eliminating indigenous societies’.25 However, identifying the target of the logic of elimination as political difference allows a more nuanced understanding of contem porary Australian Indigenous policy-making. A number of settler-colonial policy strategies, such as self-determination, work by investing resources in Indigenous peoples and cultures. There is a tendency among analysts towards identifying these in clusive policies as somehow less colonial than obviously assimilatory strategies such as the Northern Territory Intervention. In the years before the Intervention, for example, Wolfe claimed that settler colonialism in Australian seemed ‘mercifully’ to be in abeyance (although not thereby a thing of the past).26 Alternatively, we would argue that self-determination policies can constitute ‘the most successful practices’ of settler-colonial political assimilation.27 By separating Indigenous culture and community from Indigenous political existence, and supporting and absorbing the former while erasing the latter, self-determination and more radical liberal strategies, such as treaty-making, work towards the com - pletion of settler colonialism.28 By achieving definitive ‘reconciliation’ and permanently resolving questions of sovereign authority in the settler state’s favour, such strategies seek to erase the political differences of Indigenous peoples and pursue the (perhaps impossible) project of fully consummating settler ownership and legitimacy. However, we commonly understand these to be decolonizing political projects, and focus our critical attention on more easily identifiable colonial ‘re-eruptions’ such as the Northern Territory Intervention. If settler colonialism truly is a structure not an event, identifying Indigenous political difference as the target of the logic of elimination allows us to trace its presence throughout all phases of contemporary Australian Indigenous policy-making. Emphasizing this analytical shift from Indigenous society to Indigenous political difference partly comes from our attempt to extend the debate on settler colonialism into political theory and policy analysis. Mainstream Australian political scholars have generally avoided the productive (if sometimes acrimonious) internal debate around their own implication in Indigenous–settler politics that has occurred in other fields, such as anthropology.29 Here, we rearticulate settler-colonial concepts in the terms of our own discipline of political studies — sovereignty, polity, policymaking, liberalism and consent — as an invitation to other political scholars to consider the ramifications of the settler-colonial model.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.