Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Settler colonialism operates through a logic of constant deferral that locates indigeneity as “vanished”, or an atemporal relic of the past cast aside in service of a settler modernity – the 1AC’s commitment to progressive development as a method of redress for colonial violence is nothing more than a cacaphony of assimilative liberalism that drowns out “backwards” indigenous thought in favor of settler misappropriation.

Hardy ’15 -- (Karl Joseph Hardy, 6-10-2015, "UNSETTLING HOPE: SETTLER COLONIALISM AND UTOPIANISM," Queen’s University, https://qspace.library.queensu.ca/bitstream/handle/1974/13154/Hardy_Karl_J_06095600_PhD.pdf;jsessionid=4D4185E83446511624E096AB43CCE454?sequence=1, accessed 12-30-2021)//nikki

The work of contemporary Indigenous critical theorists evidences a collective refusal to be erased, a demand for attention to the ways in which many academic (and non-academic) concepts and discourses ignore the experiences and concerns of Indigenous peoples. It is vital, therefore, to first recognize and situate the manifesting of a body of Indigenous critical theory and Indigenous-led scholarly communities as existing within the academic infrastructure supported and regulated by the white settler nationstate. With this reality in mind, the proliferation of Indigenous studies programs and the work of Indigenous critical theorists, as such, may be generally observed as acts of resistance. Chickasaw critical theorist Jodi Byrd refers to what she terms the “deferral” of Indigenous peoples’ experiences and concerns within the prominent threads of critical theory within the (settler) academy.36 An attending to Indigenous concerns and experiences in discourses such as human rights, postcoloniality, or sustainability rarely occurs, if it can be said that it has ever occurred in a substantial or sustained way. These continual deferrals operate as a means by which the white settler academy, again itself understood here as an adjunct of the wider capitalist settler societies in which it is embedded, can avoid confronting the fundamental contradictions and violence underlying the very condition of settler colonial societies. As Byrd writes, “indigenous peoples are located outside of temporality and presence, even in the face of the very present and ongoing colonization of indigenous lands, resources, and lives.”37 According to Byrd, one of the more prominent means of such acts of deferral is the assignment of Indigenous peoples and their concerns and experiences to the past. This acts to relegate of Indigenous peoples to a state of invisibility and irrelevance in the contemporary world. Colonial narratives represent Indigenous peoples as having vanished or as having otherwise been passed by as part of a linear and teleological notion of human development. This allows for, and indeed perpetuates, deferrals from direct and sustained contention with the genocidal violence of settler colonialism by understanding colonization to have always-already taken place. Settler colonialism is therefore understood as complete, with Indigenous peoples and their nations, cultures, languages, knowledges, governance structures, and spiritualities viewed as mere remnants pushed to the margins, as contradictions that require (temporary) management. These narrative deferrals also often involve an imposed notion of “authentic” Indigeneity to have been fundamentally and irrevocably lost at some point in the past. The supposed loss of authenticity furthers a sense of the inevitability of Indigenous peoples’ assimilation into settler society. This to say that if Indigenous peoples ceased to be authentically Indigenous at some point in the past, then their capacity to be recognized by settler societies as fully human, and as Indigenous nations, rests primarily on their assimilation, the termination of the their Indigenous identities. Obviously, this operates, in part, as a means of deferring engagement with the enduring and ongoing genocidal character of settler colonialism. This includes, but is not limited to, the ongoing reservation and reserve system, the gendered and sexualized violence, and the mass settler state interventions into Indigenous communities (e.g. the removal of children from their families). Furthermore, the ongoing legacy of broken treaties between the erstwhile colonial metropoles, the settler nation-states that Byrd refers to as “breakaway settler colonialisms,” and Indigenous nations, requires the subsuming of Indigenous peoples within the settler nation-state, undermining Indigenous sovereignties and denying Indigenous nationhood.38 While it appears that, to date, the largest non-Indigenous audience for much of contemporary Indigenous critical theory has been in area studies and critical studies of race, gender, and sexuality, the work of Byrd in Transit of Empire offers a wide-ranging set of critical interventions, aimed at postcolonial and poststructural scholarship, as well as cultural studies. Byrd’s arguments focus on the construction of the notion of what she calls “Indian” and “Indianness,” which, in some ways mirror Anishinaabe writer and theorist Gerald Vizenor’s similar characterization of the “Indian” as an imposed nonIndigenous caricature. For Byrd the “Indian” …becomes a site through which U.S. empire orients and replicates itself by transforming those to be colonized into “Indians” through continual reiterations of pioneer logics, whether in the Pacific, the Caribbean, or the Middle East.39 Thus, for Byrd, “indigenous peoples must be central to any theorizations of the conditions of postcoloniality, empire and death-dealing regimes that arise out of indigenous lands.”40 Similarly, Byrd also situates the deferrals of Indigenous concerns in the proliferation of postructuralism, arguing that Indigenous peoples become an “absent referent” on which much contemporary postructural theory is constructed. She argues, “…the Indian is simultaneously, multiply, a colonial, imperial referent that continues to produce knowledge about the indigenous as “primitive” and “savage” otherness within postructuralist and postcolonial theory and philosophy.”41 According to Byrd, even in critical theories that interrogate hegemonic constructions of colonial modernity and which implicitly or explicitly acknowledge the dichotomization of modern versus pre-modern cultures or “civilizations,” there is a tendency to locate Indigenous peoples in the past—as though the pre-modern peoples were all killed or assimilated: vanished. Byrd argues …indigeniety as an ontological prior challenges postcolonial and critical theories because it serves as a significant parallax view—though certainly not the only one—along the baseline of colonialism through which to trouble the dialectical processes that underwrite colonialist hegemonies of racializations and normativities., subjectivities and subjectifications.42 The goals of the Transit of Empire are thus to critically intervene in existing nonIndigenous discourses with the intention of compelling attention to the contemporary presence and experiences of Indigenous peoples and a critical recognition of the effects of the naturalized deferrals of ongoing lived contemporary concerns of Indigenous peoples. Byrd is claiming that a caricatured Indian as subhuman is continuously redeployed as the means of the “transit” of American imperialism, but also that the Indian as pre-modern-and-vanished is deployed as the alternative to hegemonic notions of modernity in critical theory. Byrd also proposes a conceptualization of “cacophony” as means of understanding how liberal multiculturalism defers Indigenous concerns in part via “the noise of competing claims, recognitions, and remediations.”43 Here she is naming the “contradictorily hegemonic and horizontal struggles” within contemporary multicultural settler nation-states as another means of deferring the concerns of Indigenous peoples.44 Byrd’s argument is for an attending to the ways in which the efforts at rights and recognition from the nation-state has the consequences of pitting marginalized populations against one another in a competition that has the effect of further marginalizing and reinforcing the deferrals of Indigenous concerns. In doing so, Byrd’s Transit of Empire represents one of the foremost contemporary examples of contemporary Indigenous critical theory explicitly positioned as critical interventions within non-Indigenous discourses.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.