Utopian narratives are a methodological tool of settler modernity that forwards progressive rationality as a means of rationalizing and reconstituting the genocidal project of the New World -- indigeneity is constructed as the constitutive “other” to the unified social desire built around Western progressive rationality
Hardy ’15 -- (Karl Joseph Hardy, 6-10-2015, "UNSETTLING HOPE: SETTLER COLONIALISM AND UTOPIANISM," Queen’s University, https://qspace.library.queensu.ca/bitstream/handle/1974/13154/Hardy_Karl_J_06095600_PhD.pdf;jsessionid=4D4185E83446511624E096AB43CCE454?sequence=1, accessed 12-30-2021)//nikki
There is a claim, repeated often in utopian studies discourse, which holds that the past thirty plus years of neoliberal globalization have contributed to a growing sense of pessimism, which accounts for an alleged dystopian turn. That is, the content of what Lyman Tower Sargent terms “social dreaming” is said to have turned nightmarish.14 The potential for utopia is thought to be increasingly unavailable. Instead, it is argued that dissatisfaction with the trajectories of a globalizing society has resulted in the popularity of cautionary, pessimistic expressions of “what ought not be” understood here as dystopia, literally “the bad place.” While recognition of the prevalence of dystopian expressions of warning may appear reasonable and substantially accurate, it must also be recognized that any notion of social dreaming is not monolithic or singular. Utopias, conceived of as social dreaming or expressions of desire for a better way of being, are here understood to be fundamentally social. As such, they are plural, enabled or constrained by context. Moreover, the historical specificities of culture, place, and of existing hierarchical social stratifications each have a substantive impact on who comes to be included, collapsed within, or entirely excluded from the implicit “we” or, alternatively, “they” embedded in each expression of utopia, or dystopia for that matter. It follows that the content and character of utopias are educated, and co-emergent with the location and processes of socialization. Similarly, the ability to realize desires for a better way of being is also educated. And, perhaps more crucially, the selfconfidence of an individual or group of individuals to realize desires for a better way of being is also educated. Given existing social inequalities, elites are clearly positioned to anticipate utopia, to demonstrate willful striving towards the potential concrete realization of their utopian propositions, in contrast to those in subordinate social positions. This notion of the education of desire emerges from the work of Miguel Abensour and Levitas, and may be considered alongside and, in many ways, as drawing upon Ernst Bloch’s related concept of docta spes, or the education of hope. Using the above example of the alleged dystopian turn, it is certainly the case that there are those who do not, in fact, maintain dystopian outlooks on the merits of neoliberal globalization. To the contrary, for some, the contemporary condition may represent the substantial realization of utopia, an “end of history,” which only requires refinement rather than wholesale reconstitution. However, accepting the premise of pervasive dystopianism at the current trajectory of global society, it is also necessary to acknowledge a variety of existing bases for such dystopianism. These may be antithetical to one another, fundamentally troubling the potential for a revitalization of utopianism. Conceived of as social dreaming or expressions of (social) desire for a better way of being, utopias as proposals appear doomed to an inevitable failure. It seems impossible to construct a unified “we,” without stepping outside of history and neglecting the realities of difference. Utopia, or more accurately, eutopia (“the good place”) for some appears to be inescapably dystopian, or, minimally, less-than-eutopia, for others. Recognition of this apparently inexorable condition, however, is the basis of Levitas’ re-conceptualization of utopia as method. Here utopia operates as an educative heuristic, as an enduringly and emphatically dialogical, processual, provisional, and critically-self-reflexive “imaginary reconstitution of society.” Proposals for a better way of being effect an estrangement from the here and now, allowing for a remove that facilitates critical “archaeologies” of the historical present. Simultaneously, the “architectural” construction, the alternative proposal to the here and now, is subject to judgment. Whether described as social dreaming or expressions of desire for a better way of being, the social dimension to utopia as method may facilitate critical understandings of power, of hierarchies of difference, of relationships of domination and oppression: it may constructively educate desire.15 Clearly, scholarly conceptualizations of utopianism as a transhistorical and intercultural meta-category facilitate comparative study. Equally clear is the existence of social dreaming, expressions of desire for a better way of being, or “texts both in the West and outside it that pre-date More’s Utopia that describe a non-existent society identifiably better than the contemporary society.”16 However, I agree with Krishan Kumar’s contention that “utopia proper” ought be differentiated as “the modern utopia that was invented in Europe in the sixteenth century.”17 More’s Utopia, published in 1516, invented the word “utopia,” (often translated as “no place” or “the good place [which is] no place”) and the etymology is itself reflective of a historically- and culturally-bounded conceptualization and expression of desire.18 The notion of a “no place” as a transcendental “good place,” apart from the immanent sphere of existence, reveals a culturally-specific epistemology and ontology. Moreover, Utopia is indeed a profoundly settler colonial text. Put another way, Utopia articulated a narrative—a distinctively utopian narrative—which operated in a variety of ways to rationalize to the genocidal project of the settler colonization of the socalled New World. Following Kumar and others, I also situate utopia as a decidedly modern phenomenon, or, more precisely, as co-constituitive with the creation of early modern narratives, in particular conceptions of a utopian settler modernity. The condition of white supremacist settler colonialism that characterizes what is now understood as Canada and the US was prefigured, in part, by the narrative proposal put forth in More’s Utopia. Furthermore, the utopian traditions of the white settlers of Canada and the US have been, and largely continue to be marked by the naturalization of white settler colonialism within their imaginary reconstitutions of society. The social dreaming of white settlers of Canada and the US has most often implicitly, but at many times explicitly, excluded Indigenous peoples and racialized non-Natives from their proposals for a better way of being. Thus, utopia as a distinct cultural and historical phenomenon has operated to educate the social dreaming of the peoples who have come to live within the white settler colonial societies of Canada and the US. The potential of unsettling utopia, or put another way, centering Indigenous decolonization and ending white supremacy in proposals for a better way of being, requires addressing the contributions that utopia has made to inspire and sustain the naturalized condition of white supremacist settler colonialism in what is now Canada and the United States.