The development discourse inherent in the 1AC’s political project is a weapon of epistemic genocide used to dehumanize and antagonize indigenous communities while valorizing expropriation and instrumentalization -- utopianism is the tool through which the settler replaces the native via the construction of stolen lands as a “blank slate” upon which an ideal society can be built.
Hardy ’15 -- (Karl Joseph Hardy, 6-10-2015, "UNSETTLING HOPE: SETTLER COLONIALISM AND UTOPIANISM," Queen’s University, https://qspace.library.queensu.ca/bitstream/handle/1974/13154/Hardy_Karl_J_06095600_PhD.pdf;jsessionid=4D4185E83446511624E096AB43CCE454?sequence=1, accessed 12-30-2021)//nikki
This dissertation begins with the first body chapter concerned with contemporary Indigenous critical theory, tracing several key theoretical concepts to establish the critical framework used to intervene in utopian discourses. Primarily I am concerned with demonstrating how Indigenous scholars have endeavored to establish what Robert Warrior (Osage) has termed Indigenous “intellectual sovereignty,” while, importantly, avoiding notions of a romanticized, fossilized authentic Indigeniety. In particular, I draw on Byrd’s work to highlight the potentialities associated with Indigenous studies’ engagement with postcolonial, poststructural and cultural studies, such that Indigenous critical theory is both potentially enriched by and a contributor to critical theories. Following Lina Sunseri, I locate the contemporary assertions of Indigenous nationhood as an affirmation of Indigenous peoplehood apart from the development discourses of modernity, progress, and rationality that were used to dehumanize and disenfranchise. Indigenous communities. I also engage with concepts drawn from Indigenous literary studies, including the work of Grace L. Dillon (Anishinaabe) to locate what she terms “Indigenous Futurisms” and “Indigenous Science Fiction.” It is from this basis in Indigenous critical theory and literary studies that I turn in the second chapter to a close reading of More’s Utopia. Here I develop the notion of utopian settler modernity and trace the pre-figurations of white settler colonialism, including the emergent valourization of labour and instrumental rationalization of landas-resource, as well as the (proto)racialization of human difference as one of the means utilized by More to conceptualize turning Abya Yala into the Modus Novus, the remaking of the New World into a “no place,” a blank slate available for projecting notions of the ideal commonwealth. Ultimately, I argue that Utopia serves as a clear touchstone for colonialist discourses that, in many ways, persist to this day even amongst the most ostensibly radical utopian fiction. I then turn to emergent discussions in utopian studies regarding notions of the “postcolonial utopia” and utopianism from outside the West. I engage with prominent conceptualizations of utopia and utopian theory, including that of educative desire in the work of Miguel Abensour, Ernst Bloch, and Ruth Levitas. Here I am concerned with gaps in utopian studies discourse that has heretofore neglected Indigenous peoples and appears predisposed towards the sort of “add-and-stir” inclusion that Hall’s re-articulation explicitly seeks to avoid. I raise the question of the efficacy of notions of postcolonial utopias to describe Indigenous peoples’ desires for making a better world and, ultimately, raise the issue of the appropriateness of “utopian” language and discourses given their clear relationship with colonialism. In the fourth chapter I survey recent examples of utopian literature created by white settler authors, noting the apparent evidence of desire for indigeneity. I develop the notion of settler ecotopianism to describe the utopian narratives of white settlers that generally involve the instrumental appropriation of Indigenous culture as means of escape from the alienation experienced by the urban industrial white settler society. I engage with a variety of utopian texts ranging from Edward Bellamy’s Looking Backward to Ernest Callenbach’s Ecotopia to the novels of Ursula K. Le Guin, Kim Stanley Robinson, and Starhawk. My central focus in this chapter is the simultaneous desire for an indigenous future combined with the naturalized evasion of decolonial concerns. I then turn to a discussion of contemporary Indigenous sf (speculative fiction) as a means of exploring the re-articulation of utopia in light of the concerns and experiences of Indigenous peoples. I draw on the work of both Byrd and Dillon to demonstrate the emergent scholarship on Indigenous sf as distinct from but also in some ways congruent with the category of “postcolonial.” Ultimately, I argue the decolonial Indigenous Futurisms articulated in the Indigenous sf of Leslie Marmon Silko, Daniel Heath Justice, and others ought be understood as simultaneously proffering an immanent critique of the modern utopian tradition, while utilizing aspects of its conventions to do so. I also discuss how the mixed identities of some authors, including Nalo Hopkinson and Zainab Amadahy provide for a rich basis for transgenre narratives that simultaneously engage Indigenous and postcolonial themes, alongside, for example, ecological and feminist concerns. Ultimately, I argue that today’s social dreaming is increasingly subjected to dynamic, educative, and intersectional critical analyses that evokes Byrd’s notion of “cacophony,” and portends further complexity, humility, and relationality for the human and the other-than-human alike.