Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Conceptualizations of utopia are complicit in the universalizing logics of Western progressivism – resolution demands a perpetually incomplete “pursuit of the ideal” that necessitates the repetitive elimination of indigeneity, the “primitive” and “anti-utopian” other, in service of colonial modernity’s emergence.

Hardy ’15 -- (Karl Joseph Hardy, 6-10-2015, "UNSETTLING HOPE: SETTLER COLONIALISM AND UTOPIANISM," Queen’s University, https://qspace.library.queensu.ca/bitstream/handle/1974/13154/Hardy_Karl_J_06095600_PhD.pdf;jsessionid=4D4185E83446511624E096AB43CCE454?sequence=1, accessed 12-30-2021)//nikki

The experience of contact between the European newcomers and Indigenous peoples was broadly diverse and was inflected by the respective metropoles’ own circumstances, especially in relation to their experiences of contact with non-Europeans. Consequently, there were a variety of disparate ways in which the European metropoles conducted their respective colonial endeavors.23 Ultimately, however, where Europeans sought to establish what were conceived of as decidedly modern and utopian colonies in the New World, Indigenous peoples and their land-based spiritual, epistemological, and ontological orientations were, broadly speaking, narratively represented as bygone, primitive, or pre-modern—as indicative of anti-utopia. It follows that such narratives contributed to justifications for attempts at subjugating or eliminating Indigenous peoples via dislocation (forced removal from traditional lands), annihilation (murder), and assimilation (strategies for bringing the Indigenous “up” or “forward” to the level of the European standard or incorporating them as new category of person in the case of the mestizo in Spanish colonies). While the pre-contact narratives of desirable social change of both Europeans and Indigenous peoples are an important consideration—among other things, they may facilitate an understanding of the bases for evolution and change resulting from contact— it is also crucial to recognize the imposition of such supremacist narratives immediately inspired corresponding Indigenous narratives of Indigenous resistances. Furthermore, contact between the Indigenous and the European impacted the self-conceptions of both. From 1492 to the present day, narratives created by both Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples living in what is now Canada and the US continue to necessarily involve substantial degrees of co-creation and enduring dynamism. To date there are relatively few direct, specific, substantive Indigenous scholarly engagements with discourses of utopia. However, the late historian John Mohawk (Seneca) offers one notable critical treatment in his Utopian Legacies: A History of Conquest and Oppression in the Western World.24 Here Mohawk offers a conceptual distinction between notions of “utopia” and what he refers to as the Western “pursuit of the ideal.”25 Mohawk understands utopianism, as he conceives it, to have existed “since antiquity in most if not all of the world’s cultures,” and to “propose that there has existed, now exists somewhere, or could exist in the future a perfect society, an existence in which all human needs are satisfied, all problems are solved, and everyone’s life is fulfilled.”26 Utopianism, Mohawk maintains, is related but distinguished from what he argues is “the pursuit of the ideal,” a “theme in Western culture” which “articulates all reasonable human beings who have access to an adequate base of information will pursue an identical concept of what is ideal or good.”27 Western utopianism, according to Mohawk, “is dominated by a certainty that an ideal world is possible, that such a world would be in the best interest of all human beings, and its conception and production will inevitably be the product of Western thought.”28 Consequently for Mohawk, Western utopianism historically operated and continues to operate as a self-aggrandizing and humanist ideology based in futureoriented notions of modernity and progress, which, crucially, never fully arrive— therefore providing a basis for its ongoing and continual renewal. In contrast, Mohawk writes of “many ancient societies, [where] utopias were envisioned as located in a distant past when human beings and nature existing harmoniously in blissful unity.”29 Moreover, as a consequence of the oppression imposed by Western utopianism, Mohawk’s brief discussion of the utopianism of Indigenous peoples of Turtle Island is based in notions of an idealized pre-colonial past, one that explicitly rejects notions of transcendental progress: …North American Indians were, with few exceptions, coerced or driven by military force from their ancestral lands. These Indians saw the fowl, fish, and animals of their homelands driven to near extinction; their people decimated by disease; and their land made off limits to them by a relentless invader. For them, utopia would be a place where all things lost would be restored and the material culture of their ancestors could be enjoyed.30 Mohawk’s articulation of this notion of Indigenous utopianism is decidedly a form of “paradise lost” that could be recognized as essentializing insofar as it is interpreted as a call to a “return” to an Indigenous cultural ideal. However, Mohawk later describes traditional Haudenosaunee stories … of the past depicting a time when people were clear about the desires of the spirits who created life on the earth, and found a sense of security and grace in that knowledge. Among the Iroquois myths is a story of human beings becoming forgetful of their obligations for the great good fortune of the gift of life; when this happened, unhappiness, misfortune, and anomie befell them. Therefore, ceremonies of thanksgiving are given by the people to the Creator of Life so they will always remember to be grateful. But, the story continues, someday in the future people will once again become forgetful, the earth itself will grow old, and life will change. Iroquois cosmology is in a sense utopian, but the utopia—the perfect world—is in a shrouded and very ancient past during which the relationship between human beings and the spirits who support life was very strong and cooperative, and even the animals and birds participated along with human beings in the continuous drama of life. As time passed, according to this myth, things changed and continue to change. Even before the European expansion and the end of the fifteenth century and long before the beginning of the Age of Extinction at the end of the seventeenth century, Iroquois storytellers described a perfect age in the distant past and urged the necessity of carrying on traditions to preserve as much of the relationships and knowledge of those times as possible in a present that was becoming ever more distant from that utopia.31 So, while Mohawk states “all societies have had their utopian dreams,” he is explicit in characterizing Western utopianism as progressive, universalizing, implicitly anthropocentric, and continually renewing a sense of modernity. At the same time, he offers a radically different understanding of an Indigenous utopianism that is traditional and embedded within a wider earth-based cosmology. Mohawk approaches these concerns as a historian and so his referencing of notions of “pluralism” as an alternative anti-colonial, quasi-utopian project is understandably brief. While he avoids a more direct and explicit evocation of what he might hold personally as an ideal or utopian vision, he does assert that “[to] the degree a people or nation can be taught to respect the principles of pluralism and tolerance, the prospects of militias committing slaughters and armies participating in wholesale ethnic cleansing are diminished.”32 The growing body of contemporary Indigenous critical theory reflects the development of varied concepts, discourses, and practices that are indicative of the diversity of their respective backgrounds and experiences.33 Therefore, I wish to recognize the dangers of appearing to collapse Indigenous narratives surrounding settler colonialism, Indigenous decolonization, or those otherwise concerned with proposing alternatives to the modern utopian tradition of white settlers. I wish to emphasize that Indigenous critical theories and their narrative proposals cannot be reduced to singular concepts, discourses, or practices that may have the effect of appearing to condense a vital diversity of thought and practice. Moreover, as I discuss below, Indigenous critical theorists and their narrative proposals ought not be reduced to mere alternatives or counters to those of the settler colonial societies they are now situated within. Just as there is danger in reducing the diversity of Indigenous thought to singular concepts, discourses, or practices, there is a similar problematic in a reductive understanding of Indigenous critical theories and narrative proposals as merely defensive or reactive in their inspiration and articulation.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.