Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Prefer the critique’s impact. There’s a cognitive bias to downplay settler violence.

King 20, PhD, professor in the Liberal Studies department at Grand Valley State University (Sarah, “What We’re Talking about When We’re Talking about Water: Race, Imperial Politics, and Ruination in Flint, Michigan,” in The Wonder of Water, UMich Libraries)//BB

For many North Americans, reflecting on and analysing their role as settlers in colonial nations2 – and about their relationship to place in this context – is a fundamental challenge. The liberal discourse of equality often denies that racism is a systemic or everyday problem, promoting instead a “‘national story’ of benevolence and generosity” (Srivastava 2005, 35). Srivastava suggests that Canadians operate within “contemporary national discourses of tolerance, multiculturalism and nonracism” that mask ongoing racialized conflicts (35). Addressing the racialized structure of society is profoundly challenging because Canadian and American moral identity is so tied up in a vision of equality, a vision that, like all national visions, “requires not only sameness and communion but also forgetting difference and oppression” (Benedict Anderson, in Srivastava 2005, 39). This vision of sameness and nonracism is fundamental to the vision that the Canadian government sought to uphold in Esgenoôpetitj, and that the Michigan government used to frame its emergency manager laws. Confronting the racism inherent in North American relationships with Indigenous peoples requires confronting fundamental questions about the history and legitimacy of the colonial states of Canada and the US. Taiaiake Alfred, an Indigenist academic, argues that most Settlers are in denial. They know that the foundations of their countries are corrupt, and they know that their countries are “colonial” in historical terms, but they still refuse to see and accept the fact that there can be no rhetorical transcendence and retelling of the past to make it right without making fundamental changes to their government, society, and the way they live ... To deny the truth is an essential cultural and psychological process in Settler society. (2005, 107) Many settlers know Canada/the US as their only home, and wonder, as some of the people I interviewed in Burnt Church did, why they must pay for the sins of their forefathers. But the problems inherent in settler relationships with Indigenous peoples are not only historical; they exist in individual, social, and political lives in the present. The fundamental discomfort of reflection on race and racism makes it difficult for many to reflect upon their shared position in the colonial present.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.