From Geronnimo to Gernoimo EKIA settler memory frames the native as the eternal enemy. The projection of nativity onto the modern enemy of the US is a part of the collective settler memory that pursues the elimination of the other while reliving fetishized moments of settler colonial violence. This logic is embedded in engagements with foreign enemies deemed as threats by the US that become the racialized punching bag of the US’ settler colonial tendencies and a continuation of the US’ settler colonial project abroad.
Bruyneel 15[Kevin Bruyneels is a Professor of Politics at Babson College, “Codename Geronimo: settler memory and the production of American statism,” Settler Colonial Studies, 10.1080/2201473X.2015.1090528]
To see the way in which settler memory connects the dots from Geronimo to Bin Laden as it concerns American state practices I now examine the relationship between colonial and imperial statist violence as articulated in a book published in late 2011, in the wake of the Bin Laden assassination. The book’s title is Wanted Dead or Alive: Manhunts from Geronimo to Bin Laden. The book’s author is Benjamin Runkle, a Harvard trained political scientist who was a US Army captain in the Iraq War, worked as a speechwriter for the National Security Council during the W. Bush Administration and also worked as a staff member for the House Armed Services Committee. In 2014, he was program director for the Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs, and the organization’s motto is ‘Securing America, Strengthening Israel’. Runkle is thus both a product and an agent of US liberal colonialism and its imperial articulations, and he provides here an insider’s perspective on the production and purposes of American statism, expressed as much habitually as consciously. The book’s first sentence offers a call to contemporary memory: ‘It is both a cliché and an understatement to say that Tuesday, 11 September 2001, is a day that will forever be etched into the memory of all Americans who lived through it.’ 22 The historical chapters begin with the ‘Geronimo Campaign’ and then focus on the US military’s effort to ‘hunt’ down, in order, Emilio Aguinaldo of the Philippines in 1901 near the end of the Philippine-American war, Mexican Revolutionary General Pancho Villa from 1916–1917, Panamanian leader Manual Noriega in the late 1980s, Mohammed Farah Aideed of Somalia in the early 1990s, and then Saddam Hussein, Abu Musab Al-Zarqawi, and Osama Bin Laden in the early twenty-first century. As is clear, all eight of these targets of American state violence are racial and ethnic others to the white settler American somatic norm. As well, all eight stem from nations or regions shaped by colonialism and imperialism, and each in their particular way offered forms of resistance to US state imperatives, a number of whom were direct or indirect allies of the USA at some point in time. To draw these similarities is not to defend or easily analogize any of these figures in terms of their individual politics, practices, and ideologies, but to place their targeting in the context of the development of American statism that is premised upon colonialist and imperialist practices, institutions, and violence. The fact that Runkle starts this narrative with Geronimo is itself no coincidence. It speaks to the necessary power of history and memory in the production and legitimation of American liberal colonial statism and US imperialism. Runkle is as an advocate for the American state practice of what he calls ‘manhunts’, proposing that ‘strategic manhunts will be increasingly attractive to future policymakers’. As well, he bemoans the way in which ‘the individuals targeted by US forces are often sanitized and romanticized by history, while the “quiet professionals” who protect us are often forgotten’. 23 Runkle also argues that manhunts are ‘not assassinations,’ because the essence of the latter is its ‘treacherous nature, which includes the use of violent force during peacetime by covert personell. Conversely, strategic manhunts use at least some overt deployment of uniformed forces acting under an established chain of command.’ 24 Here Runkle’s perspective reflects and re-iterates American statist practices in their constitutive relationship to settler memory, from someone trained in an elite US educational institution, deployed in combat in the US military, and who worked in two of the three federal branches. From his insider’s viewpoint, Runkle’s perspective is helpful because he offers an acute assessment of US liberal colonial practices in at least two respects. First, I would argue that Runkle is correct that those who are deemed to be the outlaws to the American state do, at times, become transformed, ‘sanitized and romanticized,’ although not by history, but in and through the politics of collective memory. Interestingly, though, of the eight ‘manhunt’ targets discussed in his book, it is really only Geronimo who has gone through this mnemonic transformation to such a significant degree, and maybe to a lesser extent Pancho Villa. But by my reading the other figures are either forgotten for the most part (Aguinaldo), or are in no evident way romanticized (Noriega, Aideed, Hussein, bin Laden) in American political culture. It is really Geronimo alone who epitomizes this form of mnemonic transformation, and in that respect it is a distinctly settler form of memory, one which seeks to transform him into a heroic but tragic figure who represents both the development of and resistance to colonialism, but thereby also stands mnemonically as the tamed, defeated product of US settlement. In other words, Geronimo’s persistent place in settler memory stands as evidence of US occupation being a settled matter and how it became so, with the ‘manhunt’ form standing here as an historical event that legitimates and sutures the practices of organized statist military actions as key components of contemporary settler colonial assemblage. Secondly, while I disagree with Runkle’s parsing of assassination versus strategic manhunt in an ethical sense, politically he offers what I deem to be an accurate, insider’s understanding of the purposes and practices of American statism when he claims that strategic manhunts are historically persistent, institutionalized, overt state functions, not rogue, covert, or atypical operations. ‘Strategic manhunts’ and operations of their ilk are not the exceptions to the functioning of statism. They are the statist rule for a liberal political community built upon colonial conquest and maintained through settler violence, law and memory. I would include the execution of the Dakota 38 and the massacre at Wounded Knee as two other such examples – two among many we can locate – that need to be remembered not as rogue exceptions to liberal statist practice, but rather as the rule of liberal colonial statism and US political development. They are not outside or at odds with statism, they are statism in practice. With regards to the invocation of Geronimo’s name, then, it is not a minor matter that Runkle’s narrative begins with Geronimo the historical person and ends with the killing of Bin Laden under the codename Geronimo. Rather, it points to the necessary role of settler memory in iterating and legitimating the purpose of statism in a liberal colonial context such as the USA. To invoke the name ‘Geronimo’ is to first call forth the violence of and resistance to colonial conquest and in American lore the settler victory over Indigenous peoples, and then to connect it mnemonically to the colonialist and imperialist practices of contemporary American statism. And the role of settler memory here is more powerful, more constitutive of settler ideology, by the likelihood that the association of Geronimo with Bin Laden, while not random, was likely more a product of the work of habitmemory than recollection-memory. As deployed here, settler memory habitually reminds the American population that the cold, violent state remains the vengeful defender of yore, and that the work of statist dispossession – of land, of life, of identity – goes on, and must do so. In this regard, ‘Geronimo EKIA’ is a prime example of a settler mnemonic that turns violent statist practices into unifying gestures linking past conquests to those of the present, and back again. We can see efforts to make this wider linkage clear in more radical political critiques that were articulated in the aftermath of the Bin Laden assassination. These critiques did not speak in language of multiculturalism or recognition, but rather in the discourse of colonialism. For example, on the show Democracy Now, Anishinaabe writer and activist Winona LaDuke offered her analysis, stating: The reality is that the military is full of native nomenclature. You’ve got Black Hawk helicopters, Apache Longbow helicopters. You’ve got Tomahawk missiles. The term used when you leave a military base in a foreign country is to go ‘off the reservation, into Indian Country’. So what is that messaging that is passed on? It is basically the continuation of the wars against Indigenous people.25 And Suzan Harjo, in an interview separate from her appearance at the Senate hearing, offered a similar reading to LaDuke’s, arguing that the use of Geronimo’s name shows ‘how deeply embedded the “Indian as enemy” is in the collective mind of America’. 26 I agree with their assessments, but would also add that what we see here, as we can with the many other examples of these forms of identity appropriation, is that the work of settler memory is fundamental to the reproduction and legitimation of settler colonial assemblage through a relationship to the past that is not about forgetting. It is a powerful form of national remembering. Conclusion In the contemporary era, I would include politics itself as among the facets of existence that settler colonialism colonizes. That is, settler colonial assemblage defines and seeks to bound that which is legitimately subject for debate and contestation as it concerns the distribution and role of power, identity, interest and institutions. Before one can even ask the question of settler colonial violence, dispossession, and appropriation, the question may be rendered moot, outside the bounds of legitimate, or realistic, politics. In this light, my suggestion here is that the response to such appropriations as that of Geronimo’s name should not be to ask the White House for an apology, and thus concede the status of this statist institution. Instead, the association should be embraced, in one key respect. To embrace the association is not to stand in alliance with Osama Bin Laden or Al Qaeda at all or the US military, but rather to re-assert the fact that Geronimo was, indeed, an enemy of American statism and settler colonialism. It is to maintain the political posture of friend versus enemy, and to render as important and necessary the status and actions of what political theorist Joel Olson called the zealot or fanatic as an important political category that holds out the possibility for more radical transformation of the political order.27 It is to say that the use of Geronimo’s name is not simply the sign of an absence of respect or sensitivity for Indigenous people, but is more evidence of the active presence of settler colonial assemblage in the specific form of US liberal colonialism. In sum, in critiquing the problem with the Codename Geronimo case, we should seek to avoid either reproducing a politics of recognition and multicultural discourse or diagnosing it as a sign of collective amnesia, as if only people knew all the ‘facts’ of history things would be fine, or better. Rather, in this regard, LaDuke and Harjo get it right I believe in emphasizing the persistent posture of American warfare against Indigenous people. While this is a difficult framework to ponder, it is the appropriate one for a decolonizing, unsettling politics which insists on drawing clear lines for and against settler colonialism. In this sense, the unsettling response here is to put settler memory front and center as an active contemporary practice, in which Geronimo’s name is utilized by the US military because the invocation of his legend habitually calls forth – possibly unlike any single figure in US-Indigenous history – the appropriative violence of settler colonial conquest that fundamentally shapes, as an active verb in the twenty-first century, the political development and status of American liberal colonialism.