Erdogan starts a diversionary war against Greece to regain popular support
Choulis et al. 21 — Ioannis Choulis Assistant Lecturer Department of Government, Marius Mehrl Postdoctoral Researcher at the Geschwister Scholl Institute of Political Science, University of Munich. Kostas Ifantis is Professor of International Relations, Department of International, European and Area Studies, Panteion University of Athens. (2021) Arms Racing, Military Build-Ups and Dispute Intensity: Evidence from the Greek-Turkish Rivalry, 1985-2020, Defence and Peace Economics, DOI: 10.1080/10242694.2021.1933312 WMK
Despite not being a top security priority, Greek-Turkish relations are still regarded as a serious external threat in Ankara (Gürsoy 2017:6). The Aegean dispute, especially contests over territorial waters and airspace, is present in every Turkish National Security Policy Document (Gürcanli 2014). Moreover, a series of surveys between 2017 and 2019 reveal that 43.2% of Turks consider Greece a threat to Turkey and 59.7% oppose mending the Greek-Turkish relations (Aydin et al. 2020:66–69). The importance of Greece in Turkish strategic considerations is also evident from the increased number of airspace violations throughout the last decade. Violations of the Greek-claimed airspace offer significant benefits to Ankara, both internationally and domestically. In the international arena, the continued Turkish objection to the status of the Aegean islands will be helpful for future negotiations or arbitration since they act as a proof of Turkish claims in the region. Additionally, airspace violations bring the issue of territory on the bilateral agenda to force Greece to acknowledge the dispute over the island status and engage with it. What’s more, airspace incursions serve as Ankara’s direct challenge to Greek sovereignty over the area and are seen as part of long-term planning to ‘Finlandize’ Greece and Cyprus (Williams 2010; Ifantis and Triantaphyllou 2018). Internationally, the airspace violations thus serve as a tool to project Turkish sovereignty claims on the contested territory. Domestically, the incursions may allow the ruling party to gain points with its constituents. Particularly in the last years, the AKP has become challenged electorally and had to accept the ultranationalist MHP as junior coalition partner (Ulgen 2018). Likewise, the Turkish economy has stagnated and inflation is soaring. In such times of domestic challenges, governments have an incentive for diversionary behaviour, and given the historic rivalry, Greece is a particularly likely target for Turkish acts of diversion (Mitchell and Prins 2004; Mitchell and Thyne 2010, Tir 2020). To that end, Mehrl and Choulis (2021) find that the number of Turkish incursions in the Greek-claimed airspace increases when leader approval ratings are low. Incursions into the contested airspace may thus also serve as acts of diversion for Ankara, benefitting its domestic position. Turkish incursions in the Greek claimed airspace also enable the Turkish armed forces to gather data on Greek air defences, such as response times, that may be useful for future military endeavours. Consequently, as long as the risk of an escalatory response is sufficiently low, the costs of Turkish airspace incursions, namely operational costs and potential accidents, are outweighed by the benefits.