Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

There are strong anti-Western sentiments in Turkey because of opposition to US domination

SWP 22 — Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik (SWP"Deciphering Turkey’s Geopolitical Balancing and Anti-Westernism in Its Relations with Russia," May 20th, 2022. https://www.swp-berlin.org/en/publication/deciphering-turkeys-geopolitical-balancing-and-anti-westernism-in-its-relations-with-russia WMK

Anti-Imperialism, Anti-Westernism: Varieties of Discontent with the West

As a major driver of Turkey’s geopolitical balancing policy, anti-Westernism or dis­content with the West has come to mean different things during different times for Turkey. However, nuance is called for: Dis­content with the West and anti-Westernism are not necessarily interchangeable. Dis­content tends to be issue-based, whereas anti-Westernism describes a more comprehensive political and ideological stance. Yet an accumulation of discontents, as is the case in Turkey, feeds into and sustains the broader anti-Westernism at the elite and societal levels. This can make these two terms indistinguishable at times. Addition­ally, elites can exploit discontent on indi­vidual issues to serve wider anti-Western political and ideological outlooks. While there are similarities between the Turkish and Russian anti-Western narratives, their policy responses and geopolitical aspirations differ. And that prevents their respective anti-Westernism morphing into a shared vision of and stance on the global order.

There are basically two sides to Turkey’s discontent with the West: political and geo­political. In the political realm a whole series of political factors have driven wedges between Turkey and the West, and gener­ated mutual discontent, if not animosity: from Europe’s often identity-centric oppo­sition to Turkey’s EU membership to the personalisation of power and the authoritarian turn in Turkish domestic politics; from the West’s tepid response to the attempted coup of 2016 to the evisceration of the rule of law in the post-coup era.

Ankara’s geopolitical discontent with the West has multiple sources. Washington’s support for the PYD-dominated Syrian Kurds and Turkey’s disputes with the EU and European powers over the Eastern Mediter­ranean conflict are two major issues. The West, for its part, takes issue with Turkey’s military operations in Syria, its drilling activ­ities in disputed waters and its military posturing in the Eastern Mediterranean. Many in the West saw Turkey’s acquisition of the Russian S-400 air defence system as a manifestation of a new geopolitical identity premised on balancing, rather than merely a defence purchase. It is noteworthy that Tur­key has recently made moves to purchase military equipment from Western sources. Turkey reached out to the US to purchase 40 new F-16 fighter jets and modernisation kits for its existing fleets, and to France and Italy about a potential cooperation on the joint production of Eurosam SAMP/T defence systems. These initiatives are important and can be seen as Ankara’s indirect recognition of the limits of its bal­ancing policy, which included defence industry cooperation with Russia.

Fundamentally, the current anti-West­ern­ism of both Turkey and Russia is pri­marily US-centric. Both experience status anxiety concerning the US/Western-centric inter­national order. However, as indicated above, what matters – in terms of the im­plications of their anti-Westernism on their approaches towards the global order– is the difference in their policy responses and aspirations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.