Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Foreign Affairs and Domestic Politics are intrinsically linked — the AFF is viewed as Western Powers constraining Turkey

Ülgen 22 — Sinan Ülgen is a visiting scholar at Carnegie Europe in Brussels, where his research focuses on Turkish foreign policy, nuclear policy, cyberpolicy, and transatlantic relations. Horizons: Journal of International Relations and Sustainable Development , WINTER 2022, No. 20, A Cyber Odyssey: Quantum of Hope (WINTER 2022), pp. 220-229 WMK

The third point of departure relates to the nexus between domestic politics and foreign policy. For a long time, foreign policy in Turkey was viewed as being almost hermetically sealed from domestic political considerations. Foreign policy decisionmaking had been under the prevailing influence of the Foreign Ministry, which was staffed almost exclusively by professional career diplomats. The military was also an influential actor in areas of strategic relevance. The political leadership had the final say, sure, but it was essentially swayed by the calculations, assessments, and recommendations of these two powerful, professional institutions. Under the AKP, the balance of power shifted to politicians—to the detriment of the institutional players. In many ways, Turkey lurched from one extreme to the other. In the olden days, the body politic was heavily influenced by institutional thinking, with little interest in the domestic impact of their calculus. In the new Turkey, the body politic wanted no institutional pressure. Foreign-policy-making disassociated itself from the “weight” of these institutions and increasingly became guided and even led by domestic political concerns.

The shift away from a parliamentary system and back to a presidential one as a result of a April 2017 constitutional referendum accentuated these negative changes and further usurped the institutional underpinnings of Turkish foreign policy. Decisionmaking became opaquer and increasingly driven by a close set of presidential advisors.

As a result, Turkish foreign policy became less predictable, changing its agenda in accordance with fastmoving domestic objectives. This shift was accentuated by a change in the foreign policy rhetoric as well. The highly-polarizing and combative language of Turkish domestic politics began to permeate the country’s foreign policy discourse. The public speeches of the Turkish leadership had made foreign countries and leaders just as much of a target as domestic opposition figures.

Unsurprisingly, the end result of these radical departures from the traditional tenets of Turkish foreign policy proved to be detrimental to Turkey’s aspirations to project its prestige, influence, and power in its neighborhood(s). In fact, Ankara became more isolated and its relations with established partners in the West became increasingly antagonistic.

All this finally compelled the current leadership to recalibrate its approach to Turkish foreign policy. The rhetoric towards the United States and the EU became less incriminating and combative. Ankara has also undertaken de-escalation measures in the Eastern Mediterranean. Diplomatic openings were initiated with a view to improving bilateral relations with the region’s countries including Israel, Egypt, and the UAE—even some type of normalization with Armenia appears to be on the horizon. It is the form and longevity of this recalibration that will determine the future trajectory of Turkey’s diplomacy.

Looking to the Next Decade

Turkey’s foreign policy inclinations in the next decade will essentially be determined by how its political leadership will decide to conceptualize the country’s role as a rising power. A major element of continuity in Turkey’s international relations will therefore be its self-perception of its new role. Regardless of whether Turkey ends up with a different constellation of political leadership after the critical 2023 elections, Ankara’s self-assessment of being a rising power in a multipolar world will be a permanent fixture of Turkey’s future diplomacy

As briefly examined in this essay, this identity has been interpreted over the past decade in a way that encouraged unilateralism. Turkish policymakers intended to demonstrate both domestically and to outside actors that the country had acquired the capability to conduct an independent foreign policy. The tensions inherent to this type of accentuated unilateralism further complicated policymaking and undermined the traditional alliances of a country already exposed to the many instabilities stemming from the Middle East. But these tensions also played an important role in nurturing a domestic narrative about Turkey’s indomitable rise and the negative reactions of outside powers that wanted to constrain and contain Turkey’s foreign policy activism and autonomy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.