Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Erdogan just screwed himself—electoral reform

Tremblay 22 — Pinar Tremblay Professor in the Economics department at California State Polytechnic University - Pomona (Brendan Tremblays mom lol) How Turkey’s election bill could backfire on Erdogan’s ruling party," Al-Monitor: The Pulse of the Middle East, 6-22-2019, https://www.al-monitor.com/originals/2022/03/how-turkeys-election-bill-could-backfire-erdogans-ruling-party, accessed 6-24-2022, WMK

Turkey’s ruling party and its de facto coalition partner revealed a long-awaited draft amendment to the country’s election law March 14. The bill is expected to become law in April with the alliance’s majority vote. According to Turkey’s constitution, electoral changes must come into effect at least one year before elections, meaning that it's too late for the bill to affect any snap elections before the general and presidential elections scheduled for 2023.

Erdogan has been talking about an overhaul in the election law since last year, promising “a very different” electoral system. A senior bureaucrat working for the Ministry of Interior told Al-Monitor on condition of anonymity, “Experts studied this bill over a year and there were different proposals, simulations run. They picked this version.”

The changes that the draft introduced in the country’s electoral system affect vote distribution, election monitoring and presidential privileges.

First, the draft lowers the country’s notoriously high threshold for a party to win parliamentary seats from 10% of the national vote to 7%.

According to Kemal Ozkiraz, founder and chairman of the Avrasya polling company, the move might motivate small parties to form coalitions of their own, apart from the major parties. Yet the change also allows the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) and its ally the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) to enter the parliament, as their vote shares are projected below 10%, Ozkiraz argued.

The bill is a reversal of the 2018 alliance system that allowed parties to form alliances in a bid to clear the 10% threshold together but remain distinct. The coalitions received a percentage of the overall vote and then the seats were distributed proportionally.

The bill aims to eliminate the alliance vote-sharing system. Each party will instead win seats based in a proportional system called the D'Hondt system. Accordingly, small parties with a vote share of 3-4% will not be able to win any seats.

Gokhan Ozbek, director of the independent 23 Derece YouTube news channel, calculated how the votes would have been distributed if the amendment had been in effect during Turkey’s 2018 general election. According to his findings, the AKP and its coalition partner would have gained 12 and four more seats, respectively.

Turkey’s pro-Kurdish People's Democratic Party (HDP), meanwhile, would also have won four more seats. Its gains would have cost the main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) 15 seats and its ally the Good or Iyi Party another five, meaning the Good Party would not have won any seats if the new law had been in effect in 2018.

However, Ozkiraz and Ozbek concurred that the AKP’s vote share, which had been some 42%, today ranges between 25% and 35%, so the new bill could backfire and hurt the ruling alliance.

Professor emeritus of public law Levent Koker told Al-Monitor, “On the basis of the 2018 vote distribution, the AKP-MHP coalition would gain the advantage with this law, but that advantage could turn into disadvantage in 2023 if the vote distribution is different. Small right-wing parties in the opposition coalition might enter the election as a part of a bigger party to overcome this hurdle.”

If the ruling alliance’s goal was to shock and awe in a bid to dismantle the opposition, so far it hasn’t worked. The mood among left-leaning politicians and political pundits in Ankara has been sanguine. The CHP’s leadership appeared unfazed, with its parliamentary leader Ozgur Ozel commenting in a televised interview, “The AKP will fall into the trap they are setting for us.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.