retag---5G cyber is the new battlefield, mutual cooperation between US-NATO with the Baltics key to combat China and Russia
Wierenga 22 (Louis Wierenga Junior Research Fellow, Johan Skytte Institute of Political Studies, University of Tartu | Lecturer in International Relations, Department of Political and Strategic Studies, Baltic Defence College. “Cybersecurity and Hybrid Threats in the Digital Baltic states: A state of the art”, https://www.baltdefcol.org/files/files/publications/Hybrid%20Threats_LIIA.pdf)LR
In light of power competition vis-à-vis cooperation with the US, NATO, and the EU, and small states standing up to larger powers with nefarious intentions, the drawback is that no entity is capable of defeating all cyberattacks; rather, in order to succeed in cyberspace, the key is learning how to adequately cope.24 When it comes to information warfare, and one of the reasons for which it is so dangerous, is that the antagonist need not win – they succeed if they are able to successfully cloud the issue.25 It is no secret that Russia has waged numerous information warfare campaigns in the Baltics and show no sign of giving up. Recommendations and policy developments Keep on the cusp of cyber hygiene and widely promote amongst citizens: General H.R. McMaster notes the importance of American efforts to conduct reconnaissance in cyberspace and preempt attacks.26 Strive to continuously be one step ahead of hackers. Although this is a daunting, if not (nearly) impossible task, it is one which would involve both governments and the general public. One aspect which has greatly contributed to the success of Estonia in becoming a world leader in cyber defence is investing in people.27 Promoting cyber hygiene is one aspect at which Estonia excels. Raising further awareness about media literacy to combat disinformation and misinformation also helps to win the battle against information warfare. McMaster also advocates for the US to learn from countries which were on the receiving end of Russian aggression.28 As one of the strengths which Estonia possesses is its investment in people, Estonia is a success story in cyber and IT education and training, ranging from kindergarteners to the elderly.29 In an increasingly multipolar world order, the rise of China presents a serious security challenge to Europe and the Transatlantic alliance and can be seen on a number of fronts. One of the most pressing, especially when it comes to cybersecurity, is 5G. If seen through the lens of ‘the West’, then a united front should consist of the US and NATO, plus PfP countries, along with the EU in cyber policy. When it comes to 5G, this is especially important. The Baltic states have taken strides to become leaders in 5G policy and can use this opportunity to take a leading role in a Western front in the battlegrounds for 5G policy. Keeping focus on both China and Russia as threats to the security of NATO and the EU: For valid reasons – both historical and contemporary – the Russian Federation is identified as the primary security threat to the 3 Baltic states. The most contemporary events in the neighborhood do not indicate any change in the consistency or persistence of the threat, nor its digital nature. Cyber and hybrid threats directed towards the Baltic states from the Russian Federation will not cease and military, government, and civilian entities need to continue with vigilance, adapt to the rapidly changing nature of cybersecurity and cyberwar, as well as anticipate future changes, staying ahead of the curve. However, despite the very valid concerns over Russian cyber activity, the Baltic states should not neglect such concerns as they relate to China. Indeed, as aforementioned, the Baltic states, especially Lithuania, have taken a firm stance towards China, in cyberspace and beyond, and should continue to use their growing digital prowess to expand their influence in the EU and NATO. Lithuania, under the leadership of Foreign Minister Gabrielius 63 Landsbergis, has increasingly stood up to China.30 Minister Landsbergis’s stance towards China led to him being named as one of Politico’s ‘most influential people in Europe’ – and the only one to make the list from any of the Baltic states.31 Latvia has called upon China to respect the rules of international cyberspace.32 It should be noted that this is certainly not the first time that leaders from the Baltic states have appeared on similar lists, granting small states representation on lists where the usual larger powers within Europe enjoy substantial representation. Such leadership should be emulated, and the digital advances made by the Baltic states provides an ideal way to achieve this, as many countries look to the Baltics as digital leaders. Demonstrating leadership to allies: If ever there was a time, as well as a concrete area for the Baltic states to showcase their strengths as small states, demonstrating leadership in the cyber and tech fields presents the perfect opportunity. Estonia has been the Baltic champion for cybersecurity and e-governance. Lithuania, and to a lesser extent Latvia have shown signs of catching up. Much like offline matters, the three Baltic states use opportunities to meet with US and EU leaders to highlight the dire security situation which the Transatlantic alliance faces from a resurgent Russia – they know from experience and contemporary matters. As the security of cyberspace is one of the acute questions of global politics this century33, cybersecurity and matters of digital warfare will be issues which merit pressing resolve, which is constantly changing. Being on the cutting edge will require countries to remain that way. While member of the United Nations Security Council for the first time, Estonia made cybersecurity a priority, along with the overall security of the region.34 As well, when a member of the UN Security Council, Estonia made it a point to align with the US and the UK to call Russia out over a cyberattack directed at Georgia.35 Latvia and Lithuania have also been active on such fronts. In 2021, Latvia signed an agreement with Poland which establishes a framework for cooperation between Latvia’s Military Information Technology Security 64 Incident Team (MilCERT) and Poland’s National Cyber Security Center.36 Latvia is also taking the opportunity to reach out to the United States to discuss cybersecurity in the region.37 Lithuania has, as aforementioned, developed their own cyber center the RCDC, which is a bilateral LithuanianUS initiative.38 Conclusion To conclude, the domain of cyberspace will be an arena for battle for the foreseeable future. All countries, governments, militaries will be faced with such threats, and the likelihood of businesses and private individuals being faced with such threats is high. The Baltic states are no strangers to such threats and have been leaders in facing up to them. Given the nature of threats faced and the manner in which the Baltics have faced up to them, it is safe to say that the Baltic states will continue to rise up to the challenges and keep up with the rapidly changing nature of cyber threats. However, the last point is the most persisting challenge any entity faces in cyberspace – the need to not only consistently keep up but remain steps ahead of adversaries. The bi- and multilateral agreements made as well as the leadership demonstrated, and the digital awareness can go a long way to not only meet contemporary and future challenges but serve as examples and demonstrate leadership. Cyber and hybrid threats are ominous, but on a positive note, the Baltic states have achieved many remarkable accomplishments in this field.