Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO says no---internal politics

Zandee et al. 21. Dick Zandee is Senior Research Fellow and Head of the Security Unit of the Research department of the Clingendael Institute. Prior to his work at Clingendael, he was Head of the Planning & Policy Unit of the European Defence Agency; “Countering hybrid threats”; October 2021; Clingindael Institute; https://www.clingendael.org/pub/2021/countering-hybrid-threats/ //BY

Since the beginning of EU-NATO cooperation, there have been obstacles that have hindered the optimalisation of cooperation, leading to sub-optimal outcomes. Some obstacles are age-old, others have emerged over time as a result of the changing security environment.

The first and most important obstacle to further cooperation is the organisations’ difference in member states. Although there is quite some overlap – 21 states are both a member of the EU and NATO – there are also EU countries that are not a NATO member and vice versa. The differences in membership are especially an obstacle when it comes to sharing more sensitive security-related information. It is common that some states only want to share information with either the EU or NATO, but not with both. Bruno Lété of the German Marshall Fund of the United States describes this as follows: “(…) the EU and NATO nevertheless remain two separate bodies, and each uphold restrictive information-sharing procedures that prevent the emergence of a culture of shared situational awareness or cyber threat assessment.”

In practice, this problem is sometimes solved through sharing information only between EU and NATO staff, explicitly mentioning that information cannot be shared with representatives from member states. In such situations, NATO and EU staff are able to cooperate on the basis of this information, while at the same time individual member states do not receive the classified information. This way of information sharing has enabled the EU and NATO to circumvent certain (political) obstacles. So far, this construction has worked for EU and NATO staff, but if joint EU-NATO follow-up action would be required, the involvement of member states cannot be avoided and political obstacles would then still prevail. Moreover, the absence of a secure communication system sometimes also makes this very difficult. Even if there is a willingness among EU and NATO staff to share sensitive or classified information, there is no quick and easy communication system to share this information. Moreover, the EU’s and NATO’s standards and practices in securing information also diverge, which further complicate matters. Therefore, this possibility of circumventing the (political) obstacles is no sustainable solution for the long term.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.