“The” can determine specifics
Supreme Court of Michigan 21. “Ricks v. State”; July 8, 2021; Lexis //BY
In its review of the threshold-eligibility requirements in MCL 691.1755(1), the Court of Appeals aptly recognized that the Legislature repeatedly used the word [**440] "the" in front of "crimes," "charges," and "judgment of conviction" in MCL 691.1755(1)(a) to (c) in setting forth when a plaintiff is eligible for compensation under the WICA. On the other hand, the Legislature uses the word "another" before "criminal offense" in MCL 691.1755(1)(b) and [***27] "conviction" in MCL 691.1755(4)—other subsections of MCL 691.1755 that explain when a plaintiff is not eligible for compensation. We have previously defined "the" as a "definite article . . . (used, especially before a noun, with a specifying or particularizing effect, as opposed to the indefinite or generalizing force of the indefinite article a or an)."20Link to the text of the note As an adjective, "another" is defined as "different or distinct from the one first considered"; "some other"; or "being one more in addition to one or more of the same kind."21Link to the text of the note Accordingly, the Legislature's use of "the" before "crimes," "charges," and "judgment of conviction" throughout MCL 691.1755(1)(a) to (c) means those provisions refer to the specific crimes and charges leading to a plaintiff's wrongful conviction and imprisonment that gave rise to a WICA claim. The Legislature's use of "another" before "criminal offense" in MCL 691.1755(1)(b) and "conviction" in MCL 691.1755(4) [*413] means those provisions refer to some other offense or conviction that is different or distinct from the wrongful conviction and imprisonment, and which therefore does not warrant compensation under the WICA. Thus, MCL 691.1755 reflects the overall structure of the WICA in only providing compensation for the specific crimes, charges, or convictions [***28] that the plaintiff was wrongfully convicted of and imprisoned for, and which ultimately form the basis of the WICA claim—not "another" crime, charge, or conviction.