LAWS break the boundaries between militarism and hegemonic masculinity.
De Carvalho, 18 [Juliana Santos de Carvalho is a research associate at the Public International Law and Policy Group, Spring Issue 2018, accessed on 6-21-2022, Amsterdam Law Review, “A Male Future? An Analysis on the Gendered Discourses Regarding Lethal Autonomous Weapons”, https://amsterdamlawforum.org/articles/10.37974/ALF.320/galley/450/download/]/ISEE
The current examination of the inter-relations between gendered discourses and robotic warfare is focused on their ability to mutually shape and influence each other. To comprehend such relation between gendered discourses and robotic warfare, there is a need to first understand some key-theoretical concepts from which feminist literature on war and militarism stems, namely the idea of hegemonic masculinity and its interplay with militarisation/militarism. To understand hegemonic masculinity, the concept of gender performativity is pivotal. Pursuant to the theoretical prepositions of philosopher and gender theorist Judith Butler, gender does not follow from sex or “nature”. Rather, it is performatively and socially produced, as well as enforced by „the regulatory practices of gender coherence‟. Masculine and feminine attributes are socially constructed within frames of masculine domination, which in turn operate through regulated processes of repetition that consolidate and perpetuate gender hierarchy. Within this context, “hegemonic masculinity” is a constructed and idealised notion of certain attributes socially linked to the male gender, which subordinates and marginalises all other practices that do not conform to such ideal. Scholar Frank J. Barrett explains that the current hegemonic ideal of masculinity in Western societies is that of the independent, risk-taking, aggressive, heterosexual and rational man. As a result, a hierarchy is created not only between women and men, but also between the men who are coherent with hegemonic masculinity ideals and those who are not. In this regard, current hegemonic masculinity language applied to the military can actually demean and criticise robotic warfare. As these novel military technologies require no physical strength, no courage to “be in the battlefield” and no risk for the individual soldier, it alleviates the “dirty work of war”, and therefore can be considered as coward and feminine. A very telling example of this is the case of the “Nintendo Medal”, as explained by professor in women and gender studies Lorraine Bayard de Volo. In this instance, Leon Panetta, U.S Secretary of Defence in 2013, had proposed the Distinguished Warfare Medal to laud robotic pilots for “extraordinary achievements”. However, the medal was met with a huge backlash from the overall military community, as they argued that medals of honour should not be endowed to coward “button-pushers”. This is particularly interesting when one analyses the role of “sacrifice” to the “formation of the soldier-citizen as an archetype of heroic masculinity”. As explained by gender studies scholar Bianca Baggiarini, military sacrifice publicises the death, injury and suffering of soldiers that put themselves in harm’s way for the „greater good of the national community and subsequently the life of the body politic‟. Soldier’s lives then become gendered, as their value is located in the public sphere – often seen as the „male‟ realm, in contrast to the private, family and domestic domain associated with feminine roles. This does not mean to say that such sacrificial effort is expected only from male-bodied soldiers: this is an overarching gendering of the commitment of soldiers – male and female – to take risks for the national good, which grounds itself in the masculinised domain of the public to validate such endeavour. Drone war, for its turn, can distance the military enterprise from “public sacrifice”, and potentially “emasculate” military heroism.