LAWS reduces the risk of human casualties during war by removing humans from the warzone – makes wars less escalatory
Müller 16 (Vincent C., Professor of Philosophy at Eindhoven University of Technology, University Fellow at the University of Leeds, Turing Fellow at the Alan Turing Institute, President of the European Association for Cognitive Systems, PhD Phil with Cognitive Science, Linguistics, and History, and chair of the euRobotics topics group on 'ethical, legal and socio-economic issues’, (PDF), 2016 “Autonomous killer robots are probably good news," ResearchGate,
Are killer robots good for us? Assuming there is no particular ethical problem with humanitarian law or responsibil-ity, the remaining question is whether the consequences of LAWS are good overall, in the long run—do they reduce or increase human well-being? If utility is reduced by the existence and use of these weapons we should not allow them. There are two sub-ordinate questions here. Do LAWS increase or decrease the suffering and loss of war? Do LAWS make war more or less likely? 3.3.1. Reducing the human cost of war There are a number of points that suggest LAWS would reduce the human cost of war. • Robots reduce war crimes and crimes in war: they do not rape, do not get angry or afraid, they do not intentionally commit war crimes—unless pro-grammed to do so. They follow orders more closely. • “One of the great arguments for armed robots is they can fire second,” Jo-seph W. Dyer, cited in (Markoff 2010) • Drones are excellent data-collectors, so perpetrators of war crimes are more likely to be caught. This also makes war crimes less likely • Fewer deaths, injuries and traumas of combatants • Fewer deaths, injuries and traumas of non-combatants • Thus less damage to future generations 3.3.2. Making war worse There are a couple of points that suggest LAWS would make wars worse: • LAWS have limited judgment and common sense, which will lead to errors and to carrying out orders that violate the law of war. • Killing is made easier if the command can be passed on to an autonomous system, so proportionality is under threat. 3.3.3. Making war more likely There are some points that suggest LAWS would make wars more likely: Autonomous Killer Robots Are Probably Good News 12/16 • With LAWS, a war can be expected to result in less death and injury to the soldiers on the side that has them available (but only slightly, if compared to remote-controlled systems). • They make wars less bad, generally, and thus wars are more likely to be cho-sen as a means. • They make a particular military action easier to decide for a military com-mander (see Krishnan 2009). • Fewer losses of soldiers’ lives reduce the political hurdle for wars and esp. military action short of war. • Finally, they make it easier to maintain a ‘low level’ war for some time, espe-cially if it is an asymmetric war. 3.3.4. Utility, fairness and arms races The reasons why LAWS make a war more likely apply equally to remote-controlled weapons; in fact they apply to any weapon that acts at a distance. Such weapons have always resulted in relative safety for the first users: Goliath probably thought David’s sling unfair; the Lateran Council of 1139, Canon 29, banned use of the large cross-bow [ballista] and archery against fellow Christians. The criticism that LAWS lower the risk for attackers and thus make wars and other killings more likely is thus correct, but applies to any weapon that the one side has, but the other does not: In other words, it is the result of an on-going arms race. As soon as the other side has acquired the new weapon, the risk of war goes down again. This is not to say that I think LAWS are part of an unstoppable arms race. Some weapons systems have been banned (anti-personnel mines, chemical weapons) and with nuclear weapons the arms race is highly controlled. We can stop developing these weapons—the question is whether it is right to do so, given that they seem to save lives. Let us note that the reasons why LAWS make wars less bad do not apply to all weapons at a distance. This is so especially for weapons of mass destruction or weap-ons with poor accuracy—and thus with poor compliance to the humanitarian law requirements of distinction and proportionality. If killer robots become cheap and easy to obtain or make, then the consequences would certainly be bad – as in any case of a weapon becoming more widely available (see Müller 2015) – so we would do well to prevent this spread. 3.3.5. Utility Overall So, what is the overall utility count? As usual with utility in the long run, this is very hard to say but it seems quite clear that LAWS would do something to reduce the human cost of war. Some reduction is extremely valuable, given how serious the suf- Autonomous Killer Robots Are Probably Good News 13/16 fering of war is. Further, while LAWS do raise the probability of wars in the short run, there is no reason to think they will do so in the long run. The overall utility calcula-tion depends on the balance of how much less bad wars become and how much more likely they become. How bad the short run raise in probability will turn out depends mainly on which the first parties to acquire them are. Given current military spend-ing, we know who these are: USA, China, Russia. It also depends on how big the dif-ference to remote-controlled systems is, which currently looks minimal. If they do not substantially increase the probability of war, then killer robots are good news for hu-manity.