Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Banning LAWs increases the risk of hacking because it undermines research that helps cyber defense against hacking

Messinger 15 [Eric Messinger (the Assistant Managing Editor of Just Security and Research Associate at the Center on Law and Security), 1-15-2015, "Is it Possible to Ban Autonomous Weapons in Cyberwar?," Just Security, https://www.justsecurity.org/19119/ban-autonomous-weapons-cyberwar/]

Of course, those familiar with the debate over AWS in kinetic warfare have already heard arguments about potential upsides for efficacy. Yet the nature of the cyber battleground, and especially cyber defense, will provide strong incentives to employ autonomous offensive cyber systems. The cyber theater consists in whole or in part of computerized systems, where the speed of movement is not constrained by the physical limitations of feet and engines and rockets, and where the scope and scale of combat may proceed beyond the ability of human observers to comprehend in real-time. As Dorothy Denning argues, “[a]t the speed of cyber, placing humans in the loop at every step is neither practical nor desirable.” As a result, in direct analogy to defense systems such as anti-missile systems, [m]ost anti-malware and intrusion prevention systems have both manual and automated components. Humans determine what goes into the signature database, and they install and configure the security software. The processes of signature distribution, malicious code and packet detection, and initial response are automated, but humans may be involved in determining the final response. Effective cyber defenses, in short, will have to rely upon automatic routines. Further, to date, the technological development and practical adoption of autonomous weapons systems for defense has progressed further than that of autonomous offensive systems.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.