Usage of LAWs avoid exposing soldiers to unnecessary harms
Reisen 2/28 [Erich Reisen (writer for The Blog of the American Philosophical Association (APA) which shares a variety of perspectives from a broad array of APA members, to highlight the activities being undertaken by the APA, as well as provide a forum where the APA leadership and membership can communicate with one another more effectively), 2-28-2022, "The Moral Case for the Development of Autonomous Weapon Systems," Blog of the APA, https://blog.apaonline.org/2022/02/28/the-moral-case-for-the-development-of-autonomous-weapon-systems/] // st
In a 2010 paper, Bradley J. Strawser offers a convincing argument in favor of the use of remotely piloted but uninhabited aerial vehicles (i.e., drones) provided the war being fought is a just one. On his view, drones are just another in a long list of weapons that remove soldiers further from harm’s way. The use of spears, guns, tanks, planes, and drones are all justified, according to Strawser, by the Principle of Unnecessary Risk (PUR). PUR says (roughly) that a state and its agents should avoid exposing their soldiers to unnecessary lethal risk. Regardless of the weaponry wielded by the enemy, if the war is just, then governments, armies, and commanders ought to provide their soldiers with whatever weapon(s) will most shield them from unnecessary lethal risk while still being able to get the job done. Applying PUR to drones gives us the following conditional: “For any just action taken by a given military, if it is possible for the military to use [drones] in place of inhabited aerial vehicles without a significant loss of capability, then the military has an ethical obligation to do so” (2010, p. 346). Worrying that such a principle might be used to argue in favor of AWS, Strawser tells us that this “fails to appreciate that PUR, although a strong at first view moral principle, can be overridden by a strong enough countervailing normative reasons,” and he finds the “principled objections [to AWS] to be sufficiently strong such that they override the moral demands of PUR” (ibid., p. 350). One might further point out that drones already provide a lot of coverage when it comes to lethal risk: Can it really get any safer than bombing the enemy from a bunker in Nevada? And would the additional coverage that (perhaps) comes from taking humans further out of the loop be enough to outweigh the objections to AWS?¶ I think Strawser unfairly stacks the deck against AWS by focusing on lethal risk. Lethal risk is not the only type of risk that soldiers must deal with. Depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, and feelings of guilt have a severe and negative impact on the well-being of our soldiers. Due to this, I suggest the following extension of PUR (EPUR): The state and its agents should avoid exposing their own soldiers to unnecessary moral, psychological, and lethal risk. If we have some technology that could reduce such risk, while remaining as effective as alternatives, we ought to use it. Moreover, if a military technology might seriously reduce the moral, psychological, and lethal risk of soldiers in the future if only we were to develop it, then we have strong reasons to spend some time and money doing so.¶ I contend that a state and its agents would avoid exposing their own troops to unnecessary moral, psychological, and lethal risk by deploying AWS, and that there is no other feasible way of achieving these decreased levels of risk. Therefore, a state and its agents are obligated to deploy technologically sophisticated AWS. A technologically sophisticated autonomous weapon is one that matches the average performance of human-in-the-loop systems (e.g., drones) when it comes to acting in accordance with the laws of war (e.g., distinctness, surrender, proportionality). In other words, if we were to create AWS that can reliably adhere to the laws of war, we would have strong moral reasons to use them. Utilizing such systems would reduce psychological risk by reducing the number of humans on the ground (or in Nevada) making life and death decisions. Fewer pilots and soldiers means less psychological harm.