Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO is ineffective at gender mainstreaming

Jody M Prescott, 10-30-2013, "NATO Gender Mainstreaming," Taylor & Francis, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/03071847.2013.847722

As currently constructed, however, NATO gender mainstreaming has two significant flaws that will likely prevent its effective institutionalisation for some time to come. The first of these is the apparent overtasking and underresourcing of the personnel held most responsible for incorporating a gender perspective into NATO military operations: the gender advisors. The second flaw is its current approach to the conduct of operations, characterised by an emphasis on international human rights law, which, as it applies outside contexts of armed conflict, tends to neglect the importance of factoring gender into kinetic military operations. As such, NATO should devote greater numbers of qualified personnel to gender mainstreaming and its members’ forces should adopt a holistic approach in incorporating a kinetic appreciation of gender into their doctrine and education, training and exercises, information gathering and intelligence analysis, and planning and operations in order to truly effect gender mainstreaming. Directive 40-1 and the Roles of the Gender Advisors The NATO gender-mainstreaming programme suggests a three-tiered advisory hierarchy. In static headquarters, Gender Advisors provide advice and expertise on gender matters. In field headquarters, Gender Field Advisors perform this function, while in subordinate tactical units, Gender Focal Points receive the mission as another assigned task. Whilst comprehensive in the sense that the programme sets out a staffing mechanism that would appear to provide for gender expertise at the different levels of command, the directive’s implementation is likely to be marred by certain flaws in its provisions regarding training, the terms of reference of the gender advisor as a staff officer, and the large number of specific and complex tasks gender advisors would be expected to accomplish. As to the training to be undertaken by gender advisors, Directive 40-1 identifies both mandatory and recommended courses and posits a learning programme consisting of online ‘advanced distributed learning’ courses with classroom instruction. Although it is intended that advisors participate in operational planning groups as part of their wider role, the directive only ‘recommends’ courses in this area, rather than making them mandatory. 14 However, experience suggests that not only should these operational planning courses be required so that advisors in static and field headquarters can participate in actual planning with a sufficient degree of expertise and credibility as staff officers in this function, there should also be a requirement that trainee advisors actually participate in a number of exercises, if not operations, as full-time members of operational planning groups before being certified as Gender Advisors or Gender Field Advisors. Directive 40-1 states that the roles and responsibilities of the Gender Advisor and Gender Field Advisor will be set out by a standard operating procedure, and that ordinarily they are expected to report directly to the commander, because such access would highlight to the rest of the staff the importance of the gender advisors and their multidisciplinary function. Depending on the nature of the operation, and the size of the headquarters, however, such access might be infrequent at best. To be accepted by the rest of the staff asspecial staff advisors who add value, the Gender Advisors and Gender Field Advisors will likely find themselves attending many different meetings and working group sessions over the course of a typical day – meetings in which they might have no substantive role to play but which they cannot afford to miss because they will otherwise not be seen as part of the team. Furthermore, the directive, quite properly, requires gender advisors to establish a technical chain among superior and subordinate gender advisors within the command structure.15 The directive does not, however, set out what the responsibilities and obligations of superior and subordinate gender advisors are in relation to each other. This could become problematic when contingents from different troop-contributing nations begin implementing their own versions of gender mainstreaming in accordance with their respective national action plans and guidance.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.