Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff’s attempt to ban LAW’s spectacularizes their violence whilst ignoring the way that warfare before remains entrenched in the same violence they critique.

Jones et al. 18 [Emily Jones is a Lecturer in Law at the University of Essex, and Sara Kendall, and Yoriko Otomo, (2018) Gender, War, and Technology: Peace and Armed Conflict in the Twenty-First Century. Australian Feminist Law Journal, 44 (1). pp. 1-8. ISSN 1320-0968.]/ISEE

Since the end of the last world war, the global economy has witnessed tremendous change. This was driven by developments in computing and (mechanical, genetic, electrical, chemical and materials) engineering, which we call ‘technology’ for the purposes of this issue. The resulting impact on social, behavioural and economic changes were shaped in large part by post war ideology that scalable inventions could make human life extend further, act faster, and work cheaper.4 With the evolution of proxy warfare during and after the Cold War (and resulting war-weariness among the populations of the Great Powers), the capacity for states to exercise their influence, both remotely and diffusely, has been driving the global military research agenda. The second half of the twentieth century thus saw the invention of the internet, the development of cybernetics/artificial intelligence and the creation of new materials (genetic, programmable) and laser weaponry. This century such technologies have evolved to produce the likes of drones (lethal autonomous weapons) and other military landbased autonomous and semi-autonomous robots.5 Not only has the transformation of armed conflict through such inventions impacted on targeting methods, but it has also materialised an apocalyptic vision of everyday surveillance warfare.6 This has provoked sustained global debate, both in international law and international policy fora. In a telling example from late 2017, a UC Berkeley-based computer scientist and the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots advocacy organisation used a United Nations platform to screen a dystopian futuristic film, ‘Slaughterbots’, to call greater state attention to the perils of autonomous weapons systems while lobbying for an international treaty to ban their use. 8 The event illustrates how overlapping communities – academics, humanitarian activists and state representatives – turn to legal forms as sites of potential regulation and redress for technological developments in armed conflict that are seen to threaten human well-being. It also invites critical reflection: about the relation between the human and the non-human (or indeed post-human); the broader political economies of armed conflict in which such weapons may be used; the role of legal architectures in constraining – and at times enabling – the use of force and methods of warfare; and on what other forms of suffering remain hidden from view when spectacular forms of violence determine political agendas. We think there is a pressing need for further examination of the interplay between these emerging inventions against existing international laws and the changing backdrop of contemporary armed conflict. Importantly, the role of gender in their creation, production and deployment is under-theorised: this special issue is an invitation to others to think with us. 9 The contributors to this issue undertake their analyses alongside, but not within, existing legal debates, which predominantly concern matters of procedure and classification. The articles here look outwards, at more amorphous but no less important forces on law and war: the interplay between rhetoric, images, ideology, and affect. What matters of concern appear within this constellation? 10 As the following articles illustrate, triangulating gender, war and technology as a field of inquiry produces a wide domain of analysis, with topics ranging from human enhancement technologies to autonomous weapons systems, surveillance and aerial bombardment, artificial intelligence and big data. The three terms themselves invite interpretation and debate. 11 ‘Gender’, for example, has been used in the context of international humanitarian law to signify vulnerability; women are treated as a group that may require further protection, where gender operates as a qualified identity that supplements the category of civilian.12 Yet some of the articles considered here adopt a more reflexive approach informed by feminist scholarship, considering issues of agency, difference, and intersectionality, and contesting gendered constructions that presuppose femininity, ethnicity, and passivity. Animated by concern about this and other technological inventions described earlier – and by the relative shortage of scholarly feminist perspectives on technology and conflict – this special issue emerged from out of an international workshop organised by Emily Jones in June 2016 at SOAS University of London that sought to address this gap.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.