Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their ban reifies the violent dichotomy between humans and machines that prevents solvency---the aff prevents the appropriation of technology for feminist end points

Jones, 21 [Emily Jones is a Lecturer in Law at the University of Essex, 2018, Human Rights Clinic at the University of Essex, accessed on 6-21-2022, “A Posthuman-Xenofeminist Analysis of the Discourse on Autonomous Weapons Systems and Other Killing Machines” http://repository.essex.ac.uk/21540/7/E.%20Jones%2C%20posthumanxenofeminist%20autonomous%20weapons.pdf]/ISEE

Despite current trends in military technologies and the ways in which machines are already helping to make life/death decisions, neither algorithmic ‘independence’, nor AI which decides to kill, nor any type of superhuman soldier would be covered under a pre-emptive ban of autonomous weapons. On the other hand, a posthuman approach to autonomous weapons would recognise the connections between the human and the machine. Such an approach would not fixate on autonomy but would instead work to break down the false dichotomies between autonomy-automation and human-machine, instead focusing on the ethical implications of killer systems across these lines.147 As noted above, whilst xenofeminism and posthuman feminism understand the dangers as well as the potentials of technology, xenofeminism in particular does not account for the power of militarism and the militarism-capitalism assemblage. It seems, therefore, that the risks of the technologymilitarism-capitalism assemblage need to be further read into xenofeminism to ensure that it stays true to its own aims of using and appropriating technology to construct an intersectional feminist future. Braidotti’s posthumanism pays attention to death and modes of dying while promoting an affirmative posthuman era in the face of the necropolitical.148 In contrast to the necropolitical politics of death itself,149 Braidotti proposes ‘a politics of life itself’150 which chooses to tackle the obstacles of the posthuman condition as they come. She thus states: It is a constant challenge for us to rise to the occasion, to be ‘worthy of our times’, while resisting them, and thus to practise amor fati affirmatively. It is quite demanding to catch the wave of life’s intensities in a secular manner and ride on it, exposing the boundaries or limits as we transgress them... Death is the ultimate transposition, though it is not final, as zoe carries on, relentlessly.151 It seems hard, however, to read autonomous weapons in the affirmative when weapons technologies kill people in ever more removed and de-personalised ways. Autonomous weapons, are/will be the child of the military economy. As Braidotti notes, however, to analyse in the affirmative is not to deny the horror of our times. Affirmation ‘proposes a different way of dealing with’ such horrors.152 I propose that xenofeminism provides an affirmative blueprint for embracing the current times. I have noted how xenofeminist method works to appropriate technology and existing political structures, bending them to feminist aims. 153 While the current form of xenofeminism does not fully account for the links between technology and militarism, this does not mean that xenofeminism cannot accommodate such concerns. Xenofeminist method is an affirmative approach in that it notes the contradictions and risks in the posthuman condition and works to deconstruct them. Thus, taking an affirmative posthuman-xenofeminist perspective, one which understands the ways in which the human and the machine are deeply interconnected, I wish to use xenofeminist method – the appropriation of technology for feminist aims – to propose a posthuman-xenofeminist discourse on autonomous weapons. While the XFM does not explicitly address the threat to life technology could pose, the wish to define and use technology for feminist aims, I have already suggested, inherently includes the wish to ensure that technology remains ethical. Taking this further, it is important to note that anti-militarism is a key part of the feminist project as exemplified by the Women’s Peace Conference of 1915, to the feminist activism of Greenham Common to the ways in which Haraway, in her early foundational works, highlighted anti-militarism as a key feminist project.154 While there are many feminists who do not promote an anti-violence stance, choosing to fight as part of their feminism, for example, this does not preclude an anti-militarism stance in the realm of military technologies.155 Neither does an anti-militarism stance in this area wish to judge those who engage in fighting as part of their feminist project as ‘not feminists’, nor to associate feminism inherently with peace. Rather, in noting the history of anti-militarism within the international feminist project, I wish to suggest that there is a need to promote an ethics of anti-militarism at the international structural level. This is precisely because of the ways in which militarism structures the global order, working to structure technological innovation and development alongside forces such as capitalism, colonialism and other power structures. Such a stance must therefore be contrasted to more contextual scenarios, where fighting may indeed be the best form of feminist response. In this sense, anti-militarism must be distinguished from an anti-violence position, with anti-militarism aiming to challenge the industrial, technologically crafted, capitalist driven military complex and with an antiviolence position calling more broadly for peace and non-violence. It thus follows, given the links between militarism, technological advancements and capitalism, that xenofeminism, as a project aiming to appropriate technology for feminist aims, must have regard for antimilitarism. A xenofeminist appropriation of technology must therefore include the desire to ensure that the technology of the now and future cannot be used either for military gains or for the taking of human or nonhuman life.156 Xenofeminist method provides an affirmative method for dealing with the current times and the issue of military technologies. Drawing on the will to appropriate technology for feminist aims and to create the future from the present, manipulating, hacking and coding the system, it seems that the appropriation of technology includes ensuring that technology can only be developed in ethical ways. Technology is dependent on a set of programming choices which will shape machine intelligence as technology advances. What choices are made now, what programming choices are made in these current times, could structure the entire future of technology and machine intelligence. There is a need for feminist posthuman perspectives and xenofeminist infiltrations now. The xenofeminists know well that it matters who makes those programming choices. As Haraway puts it, ‘it matters which figures figure figures, which systems systematize systems’.157 Noting that ‘technology isn’t inherently progressive’, the xenofeminists call for an intervention in these choices.158 While intelligent machines could indeed be the end of humanity, such machines may not make such choices. It is important to get the now right in the hope of working towards a future where the machine-human can work together ethically. As Haraway notes, ‘the machine is use, our processes, an aspect of our embodiment. We can be responsible for machines: they do not dominate or threaten us. We are responsible for boundaries; we are they’.159 The XFM advocates the infiltration of multiple discourses.160 I propose this could include law. I have argued that the discourse on autonomous weapons needs to be made posthuman, emphasising the links between the machine and the human and the ways in which seeing the autonomous weapon as the machinic other is a fallacy. Xenofeminist method calls for the appropriation of technology to promote, in Braidotti’s terms, affirmative aims: constructing the future from the now. While many of the groups calling for a legal ban of autonomous weapons may be overlooking some of the nuances in the debate and definitions, their larger goal – to seek legal frameworks to regulate these systems – is an aim which can remain useful. After all, legal regulation is a core manner in which profit-making tech creators may be forced to shape their innovations in ethical ways. In other words, a xenofeminist method may include not only the appropriation of technology itself but also the frameworks which regulate it. These frameworks are key in structuring future developments of technology, and thus work to appropriate technology through structuring the creation of technology from the outset. In line with xenofeminist method, therefore, I propose that a legal framework is needed to ensure that feminist ethics of anti-militarism, justice and intersectionality remain central to technological innovation. A feminist posthuman understanding of technology is required here: to ensure that the dark sides of technology are evaded whilst technology’s positive, subjectivity challenging and capitalism destroying potential is maintained. There is a need to focus on the regulation of all technologies, given the real possibility that killer machines may be created in multiple ways. There have been steps in other contexts towards creating broader ethical regulations for technology. This can be seen in the example of the European Parliament resolution of 16 February 2017, which makes recommendations to the Commission on Civil Law Rules on Robotics.161 The resolution is well thought out, considering a variety of issues around the legal regulation of technology and noting issues around liability, care robots, autonomous vehicles and privacy issues.162 The resolution calls for the urgent need to regulate technologies.163 While the resolution opens up debate on these issues, it is non-binding and seeks to regulate non-military technologies, thus upholding a false binary between military and civil technologies despite the clear cross-overs. As noted above, many civil technologies are originally created for military purposes, and there also remains a risk that civil intelligent technologies may decide to kill or may be easily adapted to make them kill.164 In addition, the resolution does not consider human enhancement technologies despite emerging developments in this area. This trend towards focusing on the immediate present and towards categorising military and non-military technologies separately is repeated throughout legal and policy attempts to regulate these technologies. There is an urgent need for a posthumanxenofeminist infiltration of the discussions around the legal regulation of technology, working to promote a future-facing feminist posthuman perspective which understands the cross-overs between civil and military technologies, the human and the machine, and autonomy and automation. While technology may be largely controlled at present by a capitalist elite with strong ties to militarism, this does not mean this technology will inevitably remain in their hands and under their control. By ensuring that basic ethical principles are applied now, through the application of laws to regulate programming choices and technological innovation in the present, technology can be shaped, working towards a post capitalist, fairer, more ethical and just, feminist world.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.