Terrorists acquiring LAWs seems fictional in the squo because government LAWs are serving as modes of deterrence. But the plan ensures terrorists are the only actors who can use LAWS.
Scharre 17 [Paul Scharre (The vice president and director of studies at the Center for a New American Security. From 2009-2012, Scharre led the Defense Department's working group that resulted in the DoD policy directive on autonomy in weapons) , 12-22-17, "Why You Shouldn’t Fear “Slaughterbots”," IEEE Spectrum, https://spectrum.ieee.org/why-you-shouldnt-fear-slaughterbots] // st
Killer drones in the hands of terrorists massacring innocents. Robotic weapons of mass destruction breeding chaos and fear. A video created by advocates of a ban on autonomous weapons would have you believe this dystopian future is right around the corner if we don't act now. The short video, called “Slaughterbots," was released last month coinciding with United Nations meetings on autonomous weapons. The UN meetings ended inconclusively, but the video is getting traction. It's gotten over 2 million views and has sparked dozens of news stories. As a piece of propaganda, it works great. As a substantive argument for a ban on autonomous weapons, the video fails miserably.¶ Obviously, a world in which terrorists can unleash swarms of killer drones on innocent civilians would be terrible, but is the future the video depicts realistic? The movie's slick production quality helps to gloss over its leaps of logic. It immerses the viewer in a dystopian nightmare, but let's be clear: It's very much science fiction.¶ The central premise of “Slaughterbots" is that in the future militaries will build autonomous microdrones with shaped charges that can fly up to someone's head and detonate an explosive, killing the person. In the film, these “slaughterbots" quickly fall into the hands of terrorists, resulting in mass killings worldwide.¶ The basic concept is grounded in technical reality. In the real world, the Islamic State has used off-the-shelf quadcopters equipped with small explosives to attack Iraqi troops, killing or wounding dozens of Iraqi soldiers. Today's terrorist drones are largely remotely controlled, but hobbyist drones are becoming increasingly autonomous. The latest models can navigate to a fixed target on their own, avoid obstacles, and autonomously track and follow moving objects. A small drone equipped with facial recognition technology could potentially be used to autonomously search for and kill specific individuals, as “Slaughterbots" envisions. It took me just a few minutes of searching online to find the resources necessary to download and train a free neural network to do facial recognition. So while no one has yet cobbled the technology together in the way the video depicts, all of the components are real.¶ I want to make something very clear: There is nothing we can do to keep that underlying technology out of the hands of would-be terrorists. This is upsetting, but it's very important to understand. Just like how terrorists can and do use cars to ram crowds of civilians, the underlying technology to turn hobbyist drones into crude autonomous weapons is already too ubiquitous to stop. This is a genuine problem, and the best response is to focus on defensive measures to counter drones along with surveillance to catch would-be terrorists ahead of time.¶ “There is nothing we can do to keep that underlying technology out of the hands of would-be terrorists. Just like how terrorists can and do use cars to ram crowds of civilians, the underlying technology to turn hobbyist drones into crude autonomous weapons is already too ubiquitous to stop."¶ The “Slaughterbots" video takes this problem and blows it out of proportion, however, suggesting that drones would be used by terrorists as robotic weapons of mass destruction, killing thousands of people at a time. Fortunately, this nightmare scenario is about as likely to happen as HAL 9000 locking you out of the pod bay doors. The technology shown in the video is plausible, but basically everything else is a bunch of malarkey. The video assumes the following:¶ Governments will mass-produce lethal microdrones to use them as weapons of mass destruction;¶ There are no effective defenses against lethal microdrones;¶ Governments are incapable of keeping military-grade weapons out of the hands of terrorists;¶ Terrorists are capable of launching large-scale coordinated attacks.¶ These assumptions range from questionable, at best, to completely fanciful.¶ Of course, the video is fictional, and defense planners do often use fictionalized scenarios to help policymakers think through plausible events that may occur. As a defense analyst at a think tank and in my prior job as a strategic planner at the Pentagon, I used fictional scenarios to help inform choices about what technologies the United States military should invest in. To be useful, however, these scenarios need to at least be plausible. They need to be something that could happen. The scenario depicted in the “Slaughterbots" video fails to account for political and strategic realities about how governments use military technology.¶ First, there is no evidence that governments are planning to mass-produce small drones to kill civilians in large numbers. In my forthcoming book, Army of None: Autonomous Weapons and the Future of War, I examine next-generation weapons being built in defense labs around the world. Russia, China, and the United States are all racing ahead on autonomy and artificial intelligence. But the types of weapons they are building are generally aimed at fighting other militaries. They are “counter-force" weapons, not “counter-value" weapons that would target civilians. Counter-force autonomous weapons raise their own sets of concerns, but they aren't designed for mass targeting of civilians, nor could they be easily repurposed to do so.¶ Second, in the video, we're told the drones can defeat “any countermeasure." TV pundits scream, “We can't defend ourselves." This isn't fiction; it's farce. Every military technology has a countermeasure, and countermeasures against small drones aren't even hypothetical. The U.S. government is actively working on ways to shoot down, jam, fry, hack, ensnare, or otherwise defeat small drones. The microdrones in the video could be defeated by something as simple as chicken wire. The video shows heavier-payload drones blasting holes through walls so that other drones can get inside, but the solution is simply layered defenses. Military analysts look at the cost-exchange ratio between offense and defense, and in this case, the costs heavily favor static defenders.¶ In a world where terrorists launch occasional small-scale attacks using DIY drones, people are unlikely to absorb the inconveniences of building robust defenses, just like people don't wear body armor to protect against the unlikely event of being caught in a mass shooting. But if an enemy country built hundreds of thousands of drones to wipe out a city, you bet there'd be a run on chicken wire. The video takes a plausible problem—terrorist attacks with drones—and scales it up without factoring in how others would respond. If lethal microdrones were built en masse, defenses and countermeasures would be a national priority, and in this case the countermeasures are simple. Any weapon that can be defeated by a net isn't a weapon of mass destruction.