LAWs are key to counter-terrorism
Iyengar and Miller 16 [SS Iyengar (Professor at the School of Computing and Information Sciences) and Jerry Miller (Lab member at Florida International University and a part of the US Air Force for over two decades), 8-6-2016, "Robots to counter terrorism: a brave new world?," Deccan Herald, https://www.deccanherald.com/content/562497/robots-counter-terrorism-brave-world.html] // st
As early as 2009, organisations began calling for a pre-emptive ban on killer robots, when the International Committee for Robot Arms Control (ICRAC), founded by roboticists, ethicists, and others, issued a call to stop AI research that could lead to development of killer robots. Five years later, the European Parliament passed a resolution calling for a ban after more than 20 Nobel Peace Laureates issued a statement in favour of banning the robot. In the Third Convention on Conventional Weapons (CCW) held in Geneva from April 11 to 15, 2015, two high-ranking UN experts issued a report to the Human Rights Council calling for a moratorium on autonomous killer robots. By July 2015, the Future of Life Institute issued an open letter which more than 1,000 AI experts signed supporting a prohibition. Today, there is an active Human Rights Watch campaign to ban the development and use of these technologies. But are they fighting to turn back time? In 1863, English author Samuel Butler published an article, “Darwin among the machines,” arguing that “the machines will hold the real supremacy over the world and its inhabitants,” and further arguing that as a precaution, humans should return to the “primeval condition of the race.” Earlier, the Luddites ravaged English factories, destroying machines they feared were threatening their jobs. In the 17th century, during a period of intense seclusion, the Japanese went so far as to outlaw the use of firearms, which had been introduced into the country as early as 1270 from China, only to resume their use during the conflicts of the mid-1800s. Over the past few days, events in the United States demonstrate the short-sightedness of these actions while illustrating the benefits of the use of robots for law enforcement. After an intensive 45-minute shootout in Dallas, Texas, USA, two police officers lay dead and three others would die within hours from massive injuries received at the outset. An assassin was targeting police officers and terrorising a major US city. Police began negotiating with the sniper to no avail. After two-hours of intensive negotiations, the Dallas chief of police gave an order to neutralise the suspect by any means without risking more officer’s lives. The plan was ingenious. The SWAT team called upon the RemotecAndrox Mark V A-1 robot, manufactured by Northrup Gruman, to deliver a pound of high explosive C-4 directly against a wall on the second floor of the building behind which the sniper was cowered. The robot delivered its payload, completing its mission with only minor damage after the explosive charge ripped a hole in the wall, fragmenting the sniper. This ended the standoff and officially introduced robots as an anti-terrorist weapon. Robots can be mounted with a variety of sensors and tools for law enforcement. The A-1 generally carries a flashbang, a device that emits a bright light and loud sound to stun criminals. These robots can also place an explosive near a bomb in order to disarm it through the explosive discharge. But there are far more uses for the robot, as outlined on Northrup Grumman’s Remotec website based upon an assortment of accessories available. The robot can be affixed with a modified 12 gauge shotgun, which can also be used as a breaching tool; a gas can dispenser mount; a window breaker, a cable cutter; a variety of drills and saws, as well as real time x-ray machines, or mounts for the weapons launcher. Innovative new uses Interestingly, Northrup Grumman lists the Remotec Androx Mark V A-1 robot as, “ready to handle any situation at a moment’s notice.” Thankfully it was ready when called upon. Police departments across the United States, and around the world, are procuring the next generation of robots to make law enforcement safer, as criminals and terrorist employ innovative new uses for common items, such as passenger aircraft and explosives. One of the largest robots currently in the field is the BatCat—a 39,000-pound remote controlled vehicle used to lift cars, and tear into buildings, or barricaded areas. The BatCat (Bomb Assault Tactical Control Assessment Tool) is built upon Caterpillar’s Telehandler base and comes equipped with claw, forklift, and/or bucket in order to make a dynamic entry or respond to improvised explosive devices on vehicles. On the small end is the Recon Robotics Throwbot, which can run slightly ahead of a clearing team to provide valuable intelligence and pictures of potential threats. Weighing just 1.2 pounds, Throwbot can be thrown up to 120 feet (36m) in front of a police team. Directed by an operator receiving audio and video, Throwbot can also transmit infrared optical data of its surroundings. Autonomous and semi-autonomous robots are already involved in a multitude of missions against terrorists and criminals alike. Our safety, as well as that of the men and women who serve us in law enforcement, depends even more on the tools available to outwit the evil that surrounds us. While we accept the fact that technology must advance, we also must accept that all technologies can be used for both good and evil. We are a long way from autonomous robots using artificial intelligence to destroy humankind. At Florida International University (FIU) Discovery Lab, we are exploring robots for many real-time applications.