China is rising in LAWS BUT they are lagging behind in expertise.
Justin Haner & Denise.Garcia 19 Justin Haner is a doctoral candidate in the Department of Political Science at Northeastern University, specializing in International Relations,;Denise Garcia is a Northeastern University professor, International Panel for the Regulation of Autonomous Weapons member, and vicechair of the International Committee for Robot Arms Control, “The Artificial Intelligence Arms Race: Trends and World Leaders in Autonomous Weapons Development”, Global Policy Volume 10 . Issue 3 . September 2019, 9-26-2019, https://skrcmdo.com/assets/rmat/AI%20Arm%20trends.pdf)/maze
China is the clear rising contender in lethal AWS and AI development and has outlined in its ‘Next Generation Artificial Intelligence Development Plan’ that it intends to utilize AI on the battlefield in association with AWS (China State Council, 2017; Kania, 2017). With a combination of 70 per cent citizen trust in AI (the highest of the 24 countries surveyed) and the heavy pressure it can exert on companies to transfer technology to the state, it is unlikely to face significant internal resistance to AWS development (Ipsos, 2018). China’s capacity for weapons development is high with an estimated annual budget of $250 billion and projected spending of $4.5 billion on drone technology by 2021 (SIPRI, 2019; Statista, 2019). Most impressively, Chinese companies have tested swarming technology with over 1,000 synchronized drones (Kania, 2017). However, while some countries, such as South Korea, Israel, and Japan, seek AWS development to augment their soldiers and fill near-term gaps in security, China, with the world’s largest army, does not have this problem. This frees China to focus the bulk of its resources on long-term strategic investments in AI. China publicly plans to become the world leader in AI development by 2030 (China State Council, 2017). China’s controversial methods of intellectual property procurement have allowed them to make technological leaps forward in a non-linear fashion. With heavy ‘civil-military fusion’ investment, China’s State Council estimates their AI industries to be worth $22 billion by 2020, $59 billion by 2025, and $150 billion by 2030 (China State Council, 2017; Kania, 2017). By some metrics, China has already taken the lead in AI. Despite lagging in total publications, between 2011 and 2015 Chinese scientists published 41,000 papers on AI, almost double the United States during the same period (Baker, 2017). Further, Chinese investment and financing in AI projects between 2013 and 2018 is estimated to be 60 per cent of the entire worlds funding of such projects, again more than doubling United States investment during the same period (CAICT and Gartner, 2019). However, China does face a problem of top expertise flight as despite having over 18,000 talented AI developers, when it comes to those who rank among the world’s best, the United States and EU each have more than five times as many of the top experts (CISTP, 2019a).