Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO represents an ambitious war machine whilst simultaneously posturing itself as a progressive entity

Cynthia Cockburn 11, British academic, feminist, and peace activist., “Snagged on the Contradiction: NATO UNSC Resolution 1325, and Feminist Responses”, 2012 Women in Action, 11-24-2011 , https://www.isiswomen.org/phocadownload/print/isispub/wia/wia2012/WIA2012_07TalkingPointsCynthiaCockBurn.pdf)/maze

NATO and The Woman Question The big challenge lies in getting the new instrument implemented, getting governments to commit to it and translating it into action for peace making initiatives and peace-keeping operations. That task has engaged many women and women’s organisations in a great deal of sustained efforts from that day to this.5 They had to ‘get their hands dirty’, negotiating not only with member governments but also with state militaries, for they are the ones who ‘man’ the aforesaid ‘peace keeping operations’. Who else but they, can ensure that women’s concerns are addressed by the UN ‘blue beret’ units who work among the distressed populations in conflict and post-conflict situations? Up to a point, implementing Resolution 1325 could mean relatively unproblematic and even creative encounters with the ‘civil-military’ functionaries of relatively benign state armies like those of the Netherlands, a country which sees its army more as a peace keeping force rather than a war-fighting army.6 However, many of the armies of Western Europe (and increasingly of Eastern Europe and even further afield) are marshalled within, and often commanded by the structures of the North Atlantic Alliance, by NATO. In our No-to-NATO movement we have developed a strong, sustained and carefully argued critique of the Alliance. It may speak the dainty language of ‘security’, but its actions show that it is an ambitious, expansionist and belligerent war-machine, primarily serving the economic and strategic interests of the more powerful among its member states.7

NATO has adopted Resolution 1325 with an energy that could easily pass for enthusiasm. A glance at its website will show 47 documents relating to the topic.8 A multi-media exhibition has been mounted about NATO’s contributions to the implementation of the Resolution (September 2010). There are pleasing photos of young women in army fatigues carrying babies, waving to children. NATO even celebrates International Women’s Day. Apparently standing shoulder to shoulder with the women’s movement, Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen asked, on 8 March 2010, “Would a world in which women enjoyed rights equal to those of men be safer and more stable? It is difficult to say, but ultimately a lasting peace in many of the world’s most troubled areas may depend upon the answer.”9 The Alliance was, it is true, rather slow off the mark at first in grasping the merits of Resolution 1325. They made their first move in 2007, seven years after it came into effect, and in doing so, they addressed action on ‘women, peace and security (WPS)’ from the start, as a joint policy initiative between NATO and the Euro-Atlantic Partnership Council. In other words the 28 NATO member states didn’t put a go on it alone. They decided, on their own reasons, to include the 22 ‘Partnership for Peace’ states. Otherwise, this would not be, they said, “a true partnership policy on an issue of global interest.”10 They set up an informal ‘ad hoc group’ to make progress on the matter. It was the following summer, 2008, that the North Atlantic Council ‘tasked’ the NATO Strategic Command to provide guidance on implementing Resolution 1325. In other words, this was the point when the big political boys asked the big military boys to put their minds on women. The result was a Bi-Strategic Command guidelines to be ‘taken forward’ by the NATO civil and military authorities. All these member and ‘partner’ nations were urged to adopt National Action Plans on the Resolution. The Alliance envisioned Resolution 1325 policy on WPS as ‘an integral part of NATO’s corporate identity, in the way it plans and conducts its everyday business, and the way it organises its civilian and military structures’. It should also be fully integrated into ‘all aspects of NATO-led operations’ (my emphasis).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.