NATO promotes progressive gender values while sustaining masculine values of protection and sovereignty
Elsa Hedling 22, is an associate fellow at the Europe Programme, Swedish Institute of International Affairs (UI) and a PhD Candidate at Lund University., “Embodying Military Muscles and a Remasculinized West: Influencer Marketing, Fantasy, and “the Face of NATO”, Global Studies Quarterly (2022) 2, 1–12, 3-10-2022, https://academic.oup.com/isagsq/article/2/1/ksac010/6546420)/maze
We argue that influencer marketing, through engaging fantasy, provides a site where military organizations can cre- ate appeal among a wider audience by bridging incompati- ble notions of soldiering, gender, and geopolitics. Through the story of Lasse Matberg, the political project of NATO military buildup was positioned as simultaneously neces- sary, commonsensical, and pleasurable, and NATO could project gender-progressive values while safeguarding “tra- ditional,” muscular masculinity. Our findings add primar- ily to feminist International Relations (IR) research, which has critically analyzed how NATO communication efforts construct the organization as a cosmopolitan defender of gender justice and human rights, thereby legitimating its actions and existence (Kuus 2007; Wright 2019; Wright and Rosamond 2021). More broadly, feminist IR scholars have shown how notions of protection, territoriality, and sovereignty—all central to contemporary security politics— are deeply gendered. Gender relations and specific ideas of masculinity and femininity are, explicitly or implicitly, invoked in discourses about who and what must be pro- tected, from whom and by whom (Young 2003; Parashar, Tickner, and True 2018; Agius and Edenborg 2019; Strand and Kehl 2019). When seen in light of the above research, our findings show how NATO, through new communica- tion technologies, can engage and appeal to a wider audi- ence by combining a “pro-feminist,” cosmopolitan message with other meanings, associated with “traditional” masculin- ity or nationalist mythologies. These ambiguous enactments of gender and geopolitics are particularly significant in a time when liberal and cosmopolitan values, feminism, and gender equality are increasingly challenged by populist and “masculinist” discourses inside and outside NATO (Nicholas and Agius 2018).
In addition to the primary contribution, our findings are relevant to several other IR conversations. It contributes to the literature on war’s relation to pleasure and joy (Dawson 1994; Welland 2018), which has dealt primarily with mili- tary recruitment, marketing campaigns, or fictional repre- sentations of war. In contrast, we demonstrate how influ- encer marketing—through mundane and interactive visual storytelling centering on the soldier persona—offers a par- ticularly fertile genre for the production of fantasy. More generally, the article adds to visual IR scholarship by taking seriously the ways in which social media can create new pos- sibilities for conducting global politics (Bleiker 2015; Crilley 2021). The article also joins IR discussions of how social me- dia are used to engage with global publics as part of strategic communication, public, and digital diplomacy (Shepherd 2015; Leaver and Highfield 2018, Duncombe 2020; Hedling and Bremberg 2021).
The article proceeds as follows. Next, we introduce our analytical and methodological framework for studying visual storytelling and its geopolitical dimensions. Then we analyze the story of Lasse Matberg through the three layers outlined above. Moving from the composition of the story as told on Instagram, the role of digital media when used by military organizations, and the geopolitical context, we discuss how these three layers interrelate and coconstruct each other. In our conclusions, we reflect upon the wider theoretical and political implications of the analysis and identify pathways for future research.
Tracing Fantasy and Appeal in Visual Narratives of Social Media
Stories of soldiers, circulating in popular culture, war memorials, political speeches and strategic communication, enable civilian audiences to access, make sense of, and “know” war. Military and security organizations attempt to orchestrate such stories in ways that sustain morale within the ranks and foster public support for war preparations and deployments (e.g., Pin-Fat and Stern 2005; Achter 2010; Basham 2016; Cree and Caddick 2020). For wars to be sup- ported, soldiers must be thought of as virtuous and mili- tary sacrifices scripted as meaningful. This is arguably par- ticularly important as professional forces (rather than con- scripted forces) have become the norm in Europe and North America and few civilians have personal bonds to a service member—even less to one serving under NATO command. Still, stories of soldiers are rarely explicit in their motivation of warfare. Instead, war and war preparations are made possible and even desirable through stories that script the soldier as an aspirational war hero and create a deeper resonance with what Dawson (1994) describes as the “plea- sure culture of war.”
Much has already been written about the relationship be- tween pleasure, desire, military power, and war. One influen- tial body of work has discussed how representations of war as an entertaining spectacle—or the soldiering body as inspira- tional and attractive—in media, popular culture, or by mili- tary organizations may produce a desire to enlist in, watch, or support war (Der Derian 2001; Pears 2021). Another body of literature has rather studied war as an emotional and indeed often pleasurable experience, for instance, by de- scribing pleasure attached to combat, synchronized move- ments, and marches as well as to the molding of a strong, capable, and desirable military body (Crane-Seeber 2016; Dyvik 2016; Welland 2018). The emergence of social and interactive media technology as a site for strategic commu- nication and storytelling more broadly has arguably enabled a third body of literature to merge war as a pleasurable ex- perience with war as an enjoyable spectacle, by showing how civilian audiences are called upon to actively engage with, “like,” and “share” strategic messages (Stahl 2010; Kuntsman and Stein 2015; Crilley 2016). We will come back to this body of work in our analysis but, for now, we want to establish that war and war preparations are enabled through desire, plea- sure, and appeal in a range of ways.
Therefore, our analysis of how NATO is ascribed mean- ing through the story of Lasse Matberg focuses not primar- ily on identifying explicit arguments about what NATO does and why it is necessary but rather on laying bare the ap- peal or fantasies that the visual narratives may evoke. Fol- lowing Freinstein and Gadinger (2019), and their reading of Glynos and Howarth (2007), we conceptualize this dy- namic through the notion of fantasmatic logics (as distinct from political logics). While political logics are descriptive as well as prescriptive and may be identified in statements such as “NATO is a guarantor of security in Europe against Russian aggression,” fantasmatic logics lack clear directions or antagonism. Instead, a fantasmatic logic bridges incon- sistent storylines enabling an “impossible union between incompatible elements” (Glynos and Howarth 2007, 147). For Glynos and Howarth, the fantasmatic provides a way to understand why certain practices and representations grip subjects, thus giving political projects energy through a promise of enjoyment or a “fullness-to-come” (Glynos and Howarth 2007,145–47). The function of fantasy, they argue, is not to give a false or misleading picture but to ensure that political controversy and potential conflicts remain in the background, allowing us to “have the cake and eat it” (Glynos and Howarth 2007,147). As an example, in military communication, language drawing on a political logic of compulsory conscription and service for the nation can be combined with images activating a fantasmatic desire for personal growth and adventure.
Attention to fantasmatic logics is crucial for understand- ing how strategic communication by military and security organizations may resonate with and appeal to audiences. In line with Freinstein and Gadinger, we here refer to “the performative dimension of presentation rather than recep- tion, to which we have no analytical access” (2019: 2). When we suggest that the story of Lasse Matberg produces ap- peal around the figure of the NATO soldier and NATO’s military buildup, we have in mind the promise or potential of pleasure (Glynos and Howarth 2007). The question of what the possible—and varying—target audiences are, and what promises Lasse Matberg may embody for individuals as well as larger audiences, is a concern to which we return throughout the analysis. Also, we have had no analytical ac- cess to intention (Shepherd 2015) or “real motives,” which is important to underline when studying representations that are described, not least by security organizations themselves, as strategic communication.
How, then, do we trace fantasmatic logics in the story of Lasse Matberg? Drawing on narrative methodology, we un- derstand military marketing and soldier self-representations on social media as storytelling practices (Bamberg 2012; Hedling 2020). In line with much narrative research, we view personal stories as relying on, reproducing, or chal- lenging broader narratives, such as those around nations, or NATO as a geopolitical actor (Somers and Gibson 1994). When analyzing how the story of Lasse Matberg produces appeal and attaches meaning to NATO, we pay attention to both visual and textual elements, with inspiration from lit- erature on visual culture and global politics. Loosely draw- ing on Hansen’s (2011, 2015) three-step model for visual analysis, we first explore the visual strategies used by Mat- berg to construct a public image of himself as NATO of- ficer and social media figure. To interpret these represen- tations, we engage with literature on military masculinities and entertainment. Next, we analyze how digital, social me- dia in general—and Instagram in particular—makes pos- sible a particular story of Lasse Matberg. In this step, we draw on research on digital Web 2.0 technologies, under- lining how the interactivity and intimacy of these platforms shape the narratives communicated by military and security organizations and contribute to their appeal. In the third step, we situate the story of Lasse Matberg within a wider geopolitical context, examining how international relations, and the role of NATO in world politics, are constituted in specifically gendered ways through this soldier story. This discussion engages literature on gender and geopolitics. Throughout the analysis, we identify tensions and incompat- ible elements, which seem to be bridged by, and contribute to narrate, certain fantasies about NATO. Our three-step ap- proach, and paying attention to how the three steps are in- terconnected through the fantasmatic, allows us to gain a more complex understanding of how the story of Lasse Mat- berg produces appeal around the NATO soldier and NATO buildup, not only through his visual representation but how his visual representations are consumed and circulated in a specific digital (second step) and geopolitical (third step) environment.