The US and NATO have historically victimized women as a justification for their western imperialism, furthering their hegemonic masculine protectionist logic.
Katharine Am Wright, 9-19-2017, "Telling NATO’s story of Afghanistan: Gender and the alliance’s digital diplomacy," SAGE Journals, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1750635217730588
The gendered underpinnings of NATO’s approach to public diplomacy are nothing new. For example, in the 1960s, NATO produced a propaganda movie called The Atlantic Decade, warning of the dangers of Soviet expansion and specifically targeting women, with the narrator introducing Turkey by saying ‘here too women have been liberated’ (Risso, 2009: 509). Today, NATO’s approach to public (and now digital) diplomacy continues to be underpinned by narratives, whether they concern individuals, states or the alliance itself. As Wibben (2010: 43) argues, narratives are political, they enable and limit representation and these representations shape our world and the possibilities within it, challenging the link between ‘experience, meaning, and knowledge’. A narrative approach is therefore a useful means to challenge traditional conceptions of security concerned with creating meaning and imposing value in what is viewed as an ‘anarchic world’ because it makes ‘explicit the operation and production of particular kind[s] of meaning, and … draw[s] out the implications this understanding has for human existence’ (Polkinghorne, 1988: 16, quoted in Wibben 2010: 44). A deconstructive approach necessitates consideration of the way they are ‘read, understood and located institutionally’ because, for example, the existence of narratives of women in the third world does not necessarily equate to a challenge to established hegemonic histories and their subjectivities (Mohanty, 1991, quoted in Cooke, 1996: 292). The mediatization of war means that the ‘delocalized world’ of TV, newspapers and the internet is where battles over ‘legitimacy, effectiveness and consequences are fought’ (Behnke, 2002: 198). Therefore, understanding NATO’s engagement with digital diplomacy and the narratives that underpin it is important, yet NATO’s public diplomacy efforts have been left on the margins of scholarly analysis of the alliance. This is significant given that, as Ringsmose and Borgesen (2011: 524) argue, in a world of international cooperation and international media, national narratives are not formed in a vacuum. It also leaves work on the use of strategic narratives by both governments (Jakobsen and Ringsmose, 2015; Ringsmose and Børgesen, 2011) and militaries (Crilley, 2015; 2016) separated from the wider regional security context. The use of digital platforms by governments and military actors is on one level an attempt to engage the media and at its most successful this can contribute to the formation of successful strategic narratives, which turns the media into a ‘conveyor belt transmitting elite cues to the public’ (Jakobsen and Ringsmose, 2015: 217). However, it can also be viewed as a means to circumnavigate the traditional dissemination of information through the media in order to engage directly with consumers (Crilley, 2016: 55). The remit of NATO’s Public Diplomacy Division supports both of these purposes, with the division tasked with complementing information activities within each member state and addressing issues related to the public perception of the alliance (Public Diplomacy Divison, 2006: 333). The recalibration of NATO’s public diplomacy to engage with digital platforms came in part as a result of the NATO-led ISAF mission in Afghanistan and the Taliban’s ability to grab both the Afghan and international media’s attention with civilian casualty numbers (Betz, 2011: 622). To address this issue, NATO created a specific media centre hosted in Afghanistan, the web-based NATO TV platform, and appointed Michael Stopford as Deputy Assistant Secretary General for Strategic Communication. Stopford had been credited with bolstering Coca-Cola’s image and reputation in his previous role as an executive for the company (Castle, 2008). This resulted in a change in NATO’s approach to public diplomacy through a shift to direct engagement with publics through digital platforms. The alliance now has a significant digital presence across multiple social media platforms: for example, NATO TV (now hosted on YouTube) features short explanatory clips on NATO, NATO’s military capabilities and short documentary style stories, including on Afghanistan. NATO TV provides a useful insight into NATO’s approach to digital diplomacy, and while the primary video featured on the channel is one detailing what NATO is and why it exists, the three most viewed videos across the site are on ballistic missile defence, female prisoners in a prison in Herat and the food scene in Kabul (NATO, 2017). This demonstrates that NATO’s digital diplomacy strategy is not just concerned with selling NATO and NATO’s ‘hard power’ but has utilized more contextualized narratives to inform outreach initiatives. It also draws attention to the way gendered narratives are utilized to support NATO’s digital diplomacy strategy. The prominence given to women’s stories on the YouTube challenge has been the subject of critique, which concerned the alliance’s apparent ‘failure’ to explicitly link a video showing Afghan women voting in the 2015 presidential election to the alliance’s (‘hard power’) actions to support this (Seib, 2014: 98). However, this analysis misrepresents the purpose of NATO’s public diplomacy, where in respect of public information campaigns the intention is not to sell ‘hard power’, nor to engage in promoting the alliance to individuals already supportive of its agenda but rather to permeate a wider audience.1 In relation to public diplomacy campaigns linked to NATO enlargement in Central Europe, this was also evident, with discussions of NATO framed ‘around the notions of rights, peace, culture, and values’, rather than defence (Kuus, 2007: 271). As NATO’s Head of Communication has stated, the intention of such content is for individuals to be drawn to it not because it is about NATO, but because of the issue it addresses (Inside Agency, 2014). In applying feminist analysis it is possible to see how gendered narratives are instrumentalized by the alliance to support (in this case) a tacit association of NATO with women’s rights. This in turn reinforces the secondary justification underpinning the war in Afghanistan, that the action was taken in order to liberate Afghan women (Shepherd, 2006). The (continued) instrumentalization of (Afghan) women Afghan women have been central to Western involvement in Afghanistan, far predating the 2001 intervention. Efforts to ‘modernize’ women’s status in Afghanistan go as far back as the early 20th century (Kabeer and Khan, 2014: 5). However, the Western approach to Afghan women has been far from consistent, underscoring its instrumentality. For example, during the rise to power of the Soviet-backed regime in Kabul and the subsequent Soviet occupation (1979–1989) efforts were made to emancipate women (Kabeerand Khan, 2014: 1). At this time, the US conveniently left women’s rights off the agenda in formulating its opposition to Soviet actions, although the US was drawing upon women’s rights to oppose other regimes at the time (Enloe, 1989: 57). The selective and instrumental use of women’s rights in US foreign policy was reinforced when the US-backed mujahidin came to power in Afghanistan in 1992 and ushered in one of the worst periods of human rights abuses the country had seen. The subsequent overthrow of the mujahidin in 1994 by the Taliban led to severe restrictions on women’s rights, including to movement, work and education (Kabeer and Khan, 2014: 2). As Kandiyoti (2007: 505) argues, women’s rights have ‘become implicated in the geopolitical manoeuvrings of powerful global actors’ and this makes the invocation of the ‘principled politics solidarity’, which has emerged in the War on Terror, extremely problematic. The discourse surrounding the US-led intervention in Afghanistan in 2001, and subsequent NATO-led ISAF operation has been noticeably gendered. As Messerschmidt (2016: 167) identifies, Bush and Obama drew on a masculinist protection logic in their articulations of the War on Terror, which constructed a particular gendered villain–victim–hero discourse in order to gain support for their actions both globally and regionally. Their speeches constructed the hero–villain relationship as unequally gendered, with the hero – the US – occupying a hegemonic masculinized position as ‘civilized, virtuous, just and peaceful’, while the subordinate masculinized villain – the Taliban – was ‘uncivilized, cruel, unjust, and violent’. In contrast, all ‘other’ people in the world were feminized, framed as ‘passively dependent, innocent, uniformed, vulnerable and unable to protect themselves’ (Messerschmidt, 2016: 169). Feminine subordination in the masculinist protection model is not submission, rather it is undertaken willingly, with adoration expressed for the protector (Young, 2003b: 3). This saw Afghan women framed as victims and, as such, in need of rescue, along with the rest of the world. In November 2001, Laura Bush made history when she became the first First Lady to give the President’s radio address, shortly after the start of the US-led Operation Enduring Freedom intervention in Afghanistan. She drew heavily on the experiences of Afghan women in making her case in support of the intervention: Civilized people throughout the world are speaking out in horror – not only because our hearts break for the women and children in Afghanistan, but also because in Afghanistan we see the world the terrorists would like to impose on the rest of us. (Bush, 2001) The address invoked the emancipation of Afghan women as supplementary to the primary justification that the intervention was a necessary defensive action to protect American people following the attacks of 9/11 and was framed around the masculinist protection logic. As Cooke (2002: 485–486) points out, the rationale presented was that to defend our universal civilisation we must rescue the women. To rescue these women we must attack these men; These women are to be rescued not because they are more ‘ours’ than ‘theirs’ but rather because they will have become more ‘ours’ through the rescue mission. Following the 2001 intervention in Afghanistan, women became beneficial not just in rhetoric but in both doctrine and practice to population centric counter-insurgency (Dyvik, 2013: 412). This was most visible in the military’s use of Female Engagement Teams (FETs) intended to engage local populations. FETs both mirrored essentalized notions of women as peaceful and instrumentalized gender as a ‘new strategic asset’, enabling women to engage in the post-9/11 masculinist protectionist narrative (Pratt, 2013: 778). The gendering of counterinsurgency also served to demonstrate that the US was ‘no longer fighting its new battles with outmoded methods’ (Mcbride and Wibben, 2012: 200). FETs were a new initiative but, as one member of a FET later reflected, ‘we were tourists, unable to solve problems with units that changed every 12 months. Everything was temporary, except Afghanistan’ (Pope, 2016). The preoccupation of the Western interveners with ‘rescuing’ Afghan women has both imperialist undertones and political implications (Khan, 2013: 105). The centrality of Afghan women to the NATO-led ISAF mission in Afghanistan has pervaded every element of the intervention, with public diplomacy and strategic communication no exception. This is exemplified in a classified CIA document released through Wikileaks (CIA [Wikileaks], 2010) which notes: Afghan women could serve as ideal messengers in humanizing the ISAF role in combating the Taliban because of women’s ability to speak personally and credibly about their experiences under the Taliban, their aspirations for the future, and their fears of a Taliban victory. Outreach initiatives that create media opportunities for Afghan women to share their stories with French, German, and other European women could help to overcome pervasive scepticism among women in Western Europe toward the ISAF.