Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alternative is to reject the affirmative and engage in feminist security studies – this requires shifting our focus from security cooperation to building communities of care that recognize NATO is incompatible with feminist movements.

Kumskova and Scheyer 19 [Victoria Scheyer (Master’s Degree in Human Rights from Columbia University and has previously worked for several non-profit and academic research centres, where she conducted in-depth gender analysis across the security spectrum) and Marina Kumskova (Master’s Degree in International Peace. Studies at the University for Peace mandated by the United Nations. She has previously worked with think tanks and research institutes on various research projects on feminist politics, gender analysis and migration.) “FEMINIST FOREIGN POLICY: A FINE LINE BETWEEN ‘ADDING WOMEN’ AND PURSUING A FEMINIST AGENDA.” Journal of International Affairs, vol. 72, no. 2, 2019, pp. 62–63. JSTOR, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26760832. Accessed 28 Jun. 2022.] // st

Safety and Wellbeing In traditional foreign policy approaches, security is given high priority. Concepts such as national or human security represent understandings of governments on what to target or how to achieve security. Feminists have criticized both concepts because these approaches ignore or overlook the gendered dimension of security.35 Feminist security studies emphasize and elaborate the importance of asking questions such as “security for who, by whom?”36 It is the questioning of the militarized security that is not able to protect women, children, civilians, migrants, among others, neither in times of conflict nor in times of peace.37 Feminist security studies emphasize the need to rethink traditional concepts of security. Putting the security issues of all intersectional groups and individuals at the center of security, the usefulness of the military industrial complex will have to be questioned.38 Buying tanks or fighter jets are not preventing children from dying of hunger, stopping preventable diseases from spreading, or averting gender based violence. Instead, this form of security often perpetuates these situations.39 In an ever-changing society featuring dynamically evolving conflicts, Sylvester emphasizes that there is a need to always review, reframe, and reflect on current approaches of security and avoid the formulation of universal, timeless, and fixed security concepts.40 With this in mind, we refrain from unpacking the concept of security, and we support feminist ideas of shifting the focus from security toward the peace, safety, and wellbeing of the gendered individual. Wellbeing, in this vein, includes physical safety in addition to the social and political security of people and the fulfillment of basic social needs. We argue that the way problems are framed inherently influences the way solutions are found. While defining security not through the absence of violence but through the foundations of peace, world leaders can commit to peace through, for example, renaming the United Nations Security Council into the United Nations Peace Council. Feminist Foreign Policy demands shifting toward a positive peace model and away from security. Empathic Communities The third indicator we have identified is based on the building of empathic communities. We differentiate between alliances based on military or defense strategies and communities based on empathy and friendship. Alliances such as the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), or even the current structure of the United Nations Security Council (UNSC), serve the goal of engaging in alliances to advance militarized security and national interests. These coalitions further capitalize on the fundamental values of neo-realism in international politics and represent the hegemonic security model. Because these alliances always come with implicit assumptions such as the presence of an enemy, a threat, and power conflict, violent escalation often proves inevitable. Feminism claims that there are more reasons for building communities, which are not about military and power, but rather about common goals such as peace, mutually beneficial trade agreements, or agreements on disarmament. Those can eventually build trust and dependencies so that attacks and war would seem illogical. Communities such as the Group of Friends of 1325, the Informal Expert Group on Women, Peace, and Security, and Friends of Gender Parity are built on agreements that open dialogue builds trust and empathy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.