Thus, the alternative is to reject the aff and embrace feminist failure. This is a politics that requires a gendered thinking of the political to open discursive space for feminist interventions to unsettle the comfortability of the 1AC.
Stern and Zalewski 09
(Maria, lecturer and researcher at the Department of Peace and Development research at Gotberg university, AND MARYSIA ZALEWSKI, Director of Centre for Gender Studies at university of Aberdeen. “Feminist fatigue(s): reflections on feminism and familiar fables of militarization” Review of International Studies (2009), 35, 611–630, Cambridge journals, JKS)
In this article we pick up on the contradictory threads running through the account above to re-consider the work of feminist scholarship in the study of international politics through the specific example of familiar feminist fables of militarisation. The rest of the article will proceed as follows. First, we will explain why we think it matters to have a discussion about feminism framed by its location within the disciplinary boundaries of the academic study of international politics. We then move to explain what we mean by the performative predicament of sexgender and the attached weariness inflecting feminist narratives; we then give readings of how this predicament plays out in what we call familiar feminist fables of militarisation. Finally, we return to the question of feminism’s failure, working with the idea of failure as being part of the process of intervening politically.7 In an associated move, we consider the grammar of temporality that haunts representations of feminism. We argue that this grammar or logic of temporality glues feminism to a generational trajectory of activity always seemingly en route to proffering a solution to gender – unsurprisingly beckoning an unavoidable failing to ever arrive. We work with the spectre of feminist failure – which we suggest is one of the dominant motifs of feminism within contemporary IR theory – to accomplish two tasks. One is to interrogate the implications of the performative production of sexgender through feminism, which, although well discussed in feminist theory more generally, has not been adequately attended to in the field of International Relations. We link the discussion of feminism’s reproduction of sexgender to the ongoing implicit and explicit expectation that a central task of feminism is to produce effective and productive knowledge in a conventionally recognisably temporal and political manner.9 Feminism’s ‘failure’ to ever ‘fully arrive’ is suggestive of unfulfilled expectations in this context. Our overall concern has to do with the multiple violences that persistently prevail in the construction of theories of international politics – and which can be traced through reading the production of feminist failure in IR, as demonstrated through our familiar narratives of militarisation. We ultimately suggest that failure to resolve the predicaments that feminist International Relations scholarship appears to face may be alternatively presented as a specific political and pedagogical stance which offers potential aporetic room for ‘thinking otherwise’ about the production of knowledge. In conclusion we reflect on the atmosphere of feminist anxiety, or melancholia, that the article infers, culminating with the suggestion that failure and disenchantment are perhaps necessary to re-imagine the possibilities of unrecognisable interventions that lie at the heart of feminist political imaginations. Feminism/International Relations We are not offering a conventional audit of feminist work in International Relations in this article;14 rather, our focus is primarily on one thread of the discursive production of feminism within the discipline of International Relations. traditional forms of feminism have fared in relation to and in competition with conventional theories of international politics. Such studies clearly privilege IR’s boundaries but also tend to work with a very parsimonious definition of feminism.15 Our approach works with a more expansive and malleable understand- ing of the practices and possibilities of feminism. Hence, it is not our intention to measure how far feminism has succeeded in the context of the discipline’s conventional epistemological, methodological and political boundaries,16 or to prove in some kind of neo-scientific way that IR has ‘got it wrong’, but rather to investigate some implications of the discursive representation and production of feminism within the discipline. We argue that one of the dominant motifs or signatures of feminism within IR is one of decline and demise particularly in relation to feminism’s theoretical and methodological potential.17 These apparent tired limits of feminism within IR mirror a quandary facing feminist scholarship more generally.18 Manifestations of this quandary include a certain lassitude inflecting narratives about gender weaved through feminism parsimoniously represented,19 accompanied by a sense that feminism is becoming increasingly obsolete.20 As noted above, we investigate this quandary in order to think more deeply, if tangentially through feminism, about the limitations and accompanying violence that marks the academic production of knowledge,21 as well as to ponder feminism’s own performative function in this regard. Feminist scholars have consistently focused on the knowledge that authoritative accounts of the world accredited by academic institutions generates; and as an historically hyper-masculinised discipline, IR has always been a significant empirical site to investigate, not least its role in discursively reproducing gender and related power structures, regimes and practices.23 In this overly ‘manly [inter- national] moment,’24 it therefore remains important to reflect on the gendered power that pervades the construction and performance of scholarly investigations.25 This entails continuing to scrutinise the discursive production of feminism in the context of its representation within the disciplinary boundaries of the academic study of international politics, especially as this is an arena which has embarked on a re-energised (re)turn toward hegemonic certainty.26 In our investigation of this we have chosen to focus our inquiry on demonstrating how, in the production of feminist narratives of militarisation through IR, we can glimpse traces of how ‘organizational practices play a central role in recreating and entrenching gender hierarchies, gender symbols and gender identities.’ To carry this enquiry forward we therefore offer a doubly layered and interlocking reading of the general discursive production of feminism within IR, as exemplified in stories of militarisation. We work with the paradox of feminism’s apparent failure within IR given that, at this historical juncture, the nexus of feminism and global politics calls for harder work to mitigate the harms produced through gender and that feminist work is globally abundant.28 The idea that feminism has apparently failed in regard to its own normative ambitions given that global gendered inequality remains endemic calls for careful reflection.29 Though all certainly do not ascribe to the belief that the task of feminist scholars in IR is to accurately map gender relations in order to prescribe solutions to gender(ed) violence, the idea that this is the purpose of feminist work – however diffusely articulated – is nonetheless widespread.30 And clearly feminist scholars/activists have not shied away from this remit; indeed quite the opposite, as they/we have seemingly eagerly grasped apparent opportunities to alter unjust gendered struc- tures and practices. Such normative projects have indeed been perceived to be the hallmark and raison d’être of much feminist activity.31 Correspondingly, feminist scholars have traditionally been expected to respond to the task of ‘doing some- thing’, hopefully practical and tangible, about the disadvantages which have ensued from cultural constructions of gender.32 Indeed, in our view it is increasingly politically and pedagogically required by what we call the burgeoning ‘gender industry,’ for feminist scholars to strive towards providing effective knowledge to this end, including, for example, the formulation of policy, especially policies for gender mainstreaming, or through the delivery of academic programmes in universities or to meet institutional research auditing and funding requirements.