Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO OCO doctrine solves zero-day vulnerabilities---intel sharing improves warfighting outcomes, while disclosure enables allied to protect vulnerable networks from attacks

Fiddler 15. Marilyn Fiddler - Marshall Scholar, Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Oxford; Summer, 2015; “Regulating the Zero-Day Vulnerability Trade:A Preliminary Analysis”; I/S: A Journal of Law and Policy for the Information Society, 11, 405. https://www.academia.edu/37789953/Regulating_the_Zero-Day_Vulnerability_Trade_A_Preliminary_Analysis //BY

2. Analysis of NATO as an Institution for Zero-Day Trade Discussions

NATO is an influential body, and, if it addressed trade in zero-days, its policies would have global importance. NATO has been relatively successful in addressing new collective defense challenges, so it may have the institutional flexibility to take on zero-days. NATO membership maps well with participants in the zero-day market, including countries with notable buyers and sellers. Additionally, because NATO is a collective defense organization for allies, conceptions of the underlying security problem and opinions about approach may be more aligned than among states not engaged in collective defense. Given the difficulties of other forms of international cooperation, achieving consensus among allies might be strategically attractive.

NATO has developed a focus on cyber defense, and zero-days are relevant to that agenda. Not only could trade in zero-days facilitate attacks against NATO networks, but the stockpiling behavior of member states also leaves other members vulnerable. Key NATO members, such as the United States and United Kingdom, are purchasers of zero-days.  NATO's commitment to cyber defense has resulted in the development of a cyber policy- and decision-making structure and processes that could also be used to address the zero-day issue without significant alteration.

Despite this institutional base, NATO would have to experience a policy shift before addressing zero-days. Zero-days are inherently  [*479]  exploitable: although they have significant implications for cyber defense, they are also closely tied with offensive capabilities of member states and the potential for NATO offensive capabilities. NATO, as an organization, is currently not positioned to discuss offensive cyber issues and has demonstrated wariness of an expanded cyber mandate. Still, as demonstrated by Libya and Russia's actions in Crimea, cyber is an increasing reality of security threats facing NATO. NATO must address cyber capabilities, not just passive cyber defense. Zero-days, as a technology that overlaps both categories, could be a useful place to start this shift.

If this shift occurred, NATO could use its existing structure to foster guidelines for addressing zero-days. The Cyber Defense Management Board (CDMB), which implemented the 2011 Action Plan, could be a starting place for discussions about zero-day policy. NATO could do this in several ways, including using CDMB to increase transparency and information sharing about zero-day issues within member states.

For instance, NATO could establish zero-day a threat-sharing program, in which governments share information about the nature of the zero-day threats they face. This kind of program would probably be least resisted by member states, but NATO could go further. NATO could institute a group disclosure program: when one member stockpiles a vulnerability, it could also disclose the vulnerability to a NATO clearinghouse. NATO members could then protect themselves against that vulnerability or make use of it. NATO could also push for harmonized purchasing policies, perhaps agreeing that NATO members will only purchase or stockpile certain vulnerabilities from certain countries or suppliers.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.