Zero-days key to cyber warfighting
Cushing ’14 [Seychelle; November 28; M.A. Political Science from Simon Fraser University; “Leveraging Information as Power: America’s Pursuit of Cyber Security,” http://summit.sfu.ca/item/14703]
The Internet has made information seeking easier given its lax security structure that privileges offense over defence. Where the US once relied on its own ingenuity to support its national security innovations, it can now also purchase the necessary tools keep up with its peer competitors in cyberspace. Buying zero days in the vulnerabilities market thus serves a dual purpose: it takes away potential attack tools from its adversaries while building America’s own cyber arsenal. The problem, however, is that zero days may not work when you need them. Unlike nuclear or conventional weapons, there is no guarantee that an acquired zero-day can remain dormant yet functional. As a result, the US must consistently discover and collect zero-days to maintain a deployable cyber arsenal. America, despite its cyber superiority, cannot credibly threaten to use crushing cyber power to defeat its adversaries without revealing part of its capabilities. Compounding this problem is the fact that a cyber attack alone, while disruptive, is survivable at this time. America is thus experiencing a shift in its security strategy, albeit incrementally. What previously worked in the physical domain does not necessarily translate into successful primacy in the electronic domain. Although Cold War models of deterrence by denial and retribution may help frame the cyber problem, these models will eventually need to give way to new thinking about security in cyberspace. Deterrence, despite its Cold War successes, is not enough to stop your adversaries from attacking you in cyberspace. Instead, resiliency to absorb a cyber attack will carry America further in securing a net security advantage. While absorbing attacks seems counterintuitive, it is a short term risk that will garner important information. Resiliency then is as much about learning about your adversaries, their capabilities, and targets, and it is about comparatively measuring your own vulnerabilities and strengths in cyber offense and defence. The more information America can acquire, the better equipped it will be to face the cyber threat. Preparations for kinetic conflict are likely to begin in cyberspace as states collect vast information about their adversaries. Tapping into the millions of gigabytes of data that passes through the Internet is necessary to help America build a better picture of its adversaries’ actions and intent, including “the readiness of foreign militaries.”250 America, despite its cyber sophistication, cannot undertake such a task alone.251 Instead, the United States strategically shares information and capabilities with its partners to influence the intelligence priorities of the Five Eyes.252 Sharing initially puts the United States in a vulnerable position – exclusive control over a part of its cyber capabilities are conceded to its partners. From a vulnerable position, American cyber power can nevertheless influence conditions necessary to execute innovative, albeit high risk, intelligence operations. Information gathered from cyber can both reflect the strengths and weaknesses of America’s (and by extension, its adversaries’) offensive and defensive capabilities both within and outside cyberspace. Amassing an informational advantage to use against its adversaries will enable the US to enhance its security posture. Information, as the new realm of cyber security illustrates, is still a growing foundation of power. Leveraging information in cyberspace is key to producing a long-term net gain in security. In seeking a cyber advantage, the United States must endure short-term cyber insecurity. Tipping the security seesaw may not produce immediate advantages but instead, can be understood as a step towards long-term security. Consistently working to tip the seesaw towards advantage, while managing the associated vulnerabilities, helps produce a long-term advantage. The US’ ability to enhance its cyber posture while managing the associated vulnerabilities ultimately produces a net gain in national security.