Credible offensive capabilities are key to deterrence.
Mazanec & Thayer 15 – Director in GAO’s Defense Capabilities and Management team; Professor, Faculty of Political Science, University of Iceland
Brian M. Mazanec, Bradley A. Thayer, “Deterring Cyber Warfare: Bolstering Strategic Stability in Cyberspace,” Palgrave McMillan, 2015,
Deterrence-in-kind: developing offensive cyber capabilities
In addition to a declaratory policy, developing credible options for deterrence-in-kind, for example, offensive cyber capabilities, will be key to bolstering credibility of such a policy as some actors will not believe the United States would respond to a cyber attack with anything but cyber weapons. Peter Singer and Allan Friedman identified this deterrence-in-kind as well as the prospect of mixed ‘cyber- and real-world retaliatory force’ as one avenue to pursue to bolster the deterrence of cyber attacks.13 US Cyber Command’s ambitious plan to field over 100 cyber teams by late 2015 is a positive step in this direction.14 Evidence leaked in August 2013 that the United States conducted 231 offensive cyber operations in 2011 also helps demonstrate advanced cyber capability.15 These developments could help ensure any clear US threat of retaliatory cyber attack in response to a major cyber attack was credible, in spite of the challenges of weapon and target unpredictability. Some analysts, such as Franz-Stefan Gady, have pointed out that a ‘systematic public display of nation states’ cyber-war capabilities ... . can have a greater deterrence effect’ on some actors because they will better understand adversary capabilities and signaling through behaviors and actions.16