CMR collapse is academic garbage.
Dunlap 17 Former Major General Charles J. Dunlap, a Duke Law Professor with a focus on security and civil-military relations after retiring from the Air Force. [Let’s Temper the Rhetoric About Civil-Military Relations, Dec 15, 2017, https://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/lets-temper-rhetoric-about-civil-military-relations]//BPS
The military is hardly as homogenous in its views as many narratives would have you believe. According to a poll from last fall, it is true that the military in general is more supportive of the commander-in-chief than the general public, but the officer corps is rather similar to the public in its opinion of the commander in chief. Furthermore, my bet is that some critics would be surprised to know that members of the military (30 percent) label white nationalists as posing a significant danger, “more than many international hot spots, like Syria (27 percent), Pakistan (25 percent), Afghanistan (22 percent) and Iraq (17 percent).” Regardless, there is nothing inherently evil or unprofessional about belonging to a political party. Personally, I’ve always been a registered independent, but I never questioned someone’s professionalism simply because in their private life chose to identify with a political party on voter rolls. In fact, one could easily argue that it is healthy for a democracy when the members of its armed forces to remain connected in a lawful way to political discourse. Of course, maintaining the appearance of non-partisanship can be complicated when, for example, a non-military spouse becomes active in partisan politics, but that is an issue not confined to the military, but to other professions in American society (see e.g., here and here). In any event, nobody should assume that simply because someone has not registered with a party or, for that matter, voted, that they have no opinion about political issues, to include partisan ones. Likewise, are we to assume that simply because someone registers a party membership they will, ipso facto, be partisan in the execution of their professional duties? That certainly is not what I’ve observed, and not just among military professionals. Judges are only one example of professional who may hold distinctly partisan views, but who nevertheless regularly set them aside (hopefully) and conduct themselves impartially in the courtroom and in their formal opinions. Military professionals in particular are routinely called upon to compartmentalize their personal views when performing their official duties so as to insulate themselves from inappropriate decision-making. For example, Roman Catholics comprise the largest faith group in the military, but they are required to operate in an environment where key tenets of their religion---such as opposition to gay marriage and abortion---cannot be allowed to compromise their official actions. Additionally, military leaders in combat especially must mentally sequester their personal feelings, such as their affection for their troops if that affection could compromise the paramount responsibility to the security of the nation as a whole. This is because the warfighting mission necessitates leaders sending them into situations where it is inevitable some will be killed or injured. When leaders find they are not able to handle the unavoidable sacrifice of their troops in order to protect the country, the best realize it’s time to leave the profession. This is precisely what happened to then Marine major Nate Fick. As he recorded his reason for leaving the Marine Corps in his magnificent memoir, One Bullet Away: The Making of a Marine Officer, Fick said: “Great Marine commanders, like all great warriors, are able to kill that which they love most---their men. It’s a fundamental law of warfare. Twice I had cheated it. I couldn’t tempt fate again.” Setting aside one’s political druthers is a vastly less demanding decision than the one Fick wrestled with, and most military professionals do so instinctively. An illustration: I deployed for Operation Desert Fox which was in the midst of Congressional efforts to impeach Bill Clinton. Despite the uncertainty of Clinton’s future, as well as his unpopularity in the military, the orders he gave to send servicemembers into harms’ way were obeyed without question (even as some say the operation was concocted to distract attention from the impeachment scandal). Claiming a “crisis” in civil-military relations as the title to Matt’s essay suggests is a perennial favorite among academics and pundits. Almost 25 years ago Dick Kohn virtually founded the “crisis” school of civil military relations with his eponymous essay Out of Control: The Crisis in Civil-Military Relations. The intellectual problem? The crisis never materialized. Instead, we’ve seen a military that has, despite all sorts of pressures through administrations of both parties, remained dutifully adherent to the Constitution.