Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The narrative is a partisan ruse.

Dunlap 17 Former Major General Charles J. Dunlap, a Duke Law Professor with a focus on security and civil-military relations after retiring from the Air Force. [Let’s Temper the Rhetoric About Civil-Military Relations, Dec 15, 2017, https://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/lets-temper-rhetoric-about-civil-military-relations]//BPS

Let’s pose the issue a little differently. Are “dire” fears about the military profession as a whole really supported by a study that shows that despite today’s extraordinarily divisive political environment, two-thirds of West Point cadets and National Defense University colonels had nonetheless not observed or shared any insulting, rude, or disdainful comments about elected leaders? The reality is that however regrettable such commentary may be, it’s occurred within the ranks throughout our history (and especially during the Revolution and the Civil War)…yet the Republic has not suffered “dire” consequences. In truth, in a democracy that treasures free speech, there is a limit to the wisdom of trying to suppress every untoward remark that someone in uniform might make about an elected leader. This may be one reason why Article 88 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (which criminalizes “contemptuous language” by officers about certain elected officials) is so limited, and why the Manual for Courts-Martial counsels that “if not personally contemptuous, adverse criticism of one of the officials or legislatures named in the article in the course of a political discussion, even though emphatically expressed, may not be charged as a violation of the article.” Do we have issues that bear watching about civil-military relations? Absolutely! As I explained at the Army War College Strategy conference recently, I believe that technology---particularly social media, big data, and even neuroscience---could operate to change not only how military leaders relate to their subordinates and the public, but also to change society itself. The “civil” of civil-military relations may evolve into an entity that is markedly different from today, and this could---and probably will---impact civil-military relations. But all that is quite different from the perils Matt sees. To be crystal clear, we certainly do have work to do, but excitedly proclaiming that we are on the cusp of “dire consequences” unhelpfully overstates and, even worse, obfuscates the real issues. In fact, over-hyping issues in civil-military relations plays into partisan politics. How? Consider that journalist Ross Douthat observed in the New York Times recently that the US won a great victory over ISIS, but “nobody seemed to notice.” Douthat cites a number of reasons for the lack of attention, but most interesting is this: But this is also a press failure, a case where the media is not adequately reporting an important success because it does not fit into the narrative of Trumpian disaster in which our journalistic entities are all invested. In other words, conjuring up impending apocalypse in civil-military relations can become another weapon which, whether intended or not, may be used by critics invested in the “narrative of Trumpian disaster” to try to delegitimize an area in which the Administration has enjoyed, as Douhet points out, some undeniable success: national security. Addressing the perennial challenges of civil-military relations isn’t facilitated when they get wrapped up with political narratives about specific individuals.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.