Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Democracy solves nothing.

Renske Doorenspleet 19, Political Science and International Studies Professor at Warwick University, “Democracy and Interstate War,” Chapter 3 of Rethinking the Value of Democracy: A Comparative Perspective, Stras

There is actually more evidence for the idea that the liberal norms lead to more (not less!) violence. Bear Braumoeller (1997), for example, argued that liberal norms of conflict resolution vary because liberalism takes many forms. By examining survey results from the newly independent states of the former Soviet Union, he showed that liberalism in that region bears a stronger resemblance to nineteenth-century liberal nationalism than to the sort of universalist, Wilsonian liberalism described by democratic peace theorists. As a result, liberals in the region are more, not less, aggressive than non-liberals. Carol Fair and her colleagues (Fair et al. 2014) came to similar conclusions. They conducted surveys in Pakistan (with 6000 respondents) and found that strong supporters of democratic values are actually not less but more supportive of militant groups. Moreover, it seems that individuals’ attitudes towards war are shaped by core beliefs about revenge, which vary across countries. Democracies with a strong tradition to support ideas of revenge24 are significantly more likely to initiate conflicts (Stein 2015). We cannot state that people in democracies are not belligerent. These results challenge the conventional wisdom about the roots of militancy and the existence of universal democratic norms, which would encourage peace.

Some scholars have argued that not the liberal democratic norms, but market-oriented development creates the norms and values that explain the democratic peace (see, e.g., Mousseau 2000). When opportunities to come to a deal in the market are widespread, as in market-oriented developed countries, a culture of contracting emerges that encourages shared respect for individualism, negotiations, compromise, respect for the law and equality before the law. Constrained by voters, democratically elected leaders in market-oriented developed countries abide by these norms. In contrast, voters in democracies without developed market economies, and the leaders in nondemocracies, have other norms and values that encourage conflict.

Hence, there is not only a lack of statistical studies, but also most findings do not support the ideas of the so-called democratic norms argument. Moreover, it is not clear why the pacifist attitude of citizens is ‘only evident in cases of democratic adversary’, while this is not the case when there are conflicts with nondemocracies, colonial expansion or third-party interventions (Gates et al. 1996: 5–6). Finally, this kind of argument tends to be tautological, stating that ‘relations between democratic states are peaceful because they are informed by a common perception that democracies are peaceful’ (Gates et al. 1996: 5–6).25

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.