Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NC3s are disconnected from the Internet.

Futter ’16 [Andrew; 2016; International Politics Professor at the University of Leicester; “War Games Redux? Cyberthreats, US–Russian Strategic Stability, and New Challenges for Nuclear Security and Arms Control,” European Security 25(2), p. 171-172]

It is of course highly unlikely that either the USA or Russia has plans – or perhaps more importantly, the desire – to fully undermine the other’s nuclear command and control systems as a precursor to some type of disarming first strike, but the perception that nuclear forces and associated systems could be vulnerable or compromised is persuasive. Or as Hayes (2015) puts it, “The risks of cyber disablement entering into our nuclear forces are real”. While the growing possibility of “cyber disablement” should not be overstated (notions of a “cyber-Pearl Harbor” (Panetta 2012) or “cyber 9–11” (Charles 2013) have done little to help understand the nature of the challenge), cyberthreats are nevertheless an increasingly important component of the contemporary US–Russia strategic context. This is particularly the case when they are combined with other emerging military-technical developments and programmes. The net result, especially given the current downturn in US–Russian strategic relations, and the way cyber is exacerbating the impact of other problematic strategic dynamics, is that is seems highly unlikely that either the USA or Russia will make the requisite moves to de-alert nuclear forces that the new cyber challenges appear to necessitate, or for that matter to (re)embrace the “deep nuclear cuts” agenda any time soon.

Assessing the options for arms control and enhancing mutual security

Given the new challenges presented by cyber to both US and Russian nuclear forces and to US–Russia strategic stability, it is important to consider what might be done to help mitigate and guard against these threats, and thereby help minimise the risks of unintentional launches, miscalculation, and accidents, and perhaps create the conditions for greater stability, de-alerting, and further nuclear cuts. While there is unlikely to be a panacea or “magic bullet” that will reduce the risk of cyberattacks on US and Russian nuclear forces to zero – be they designed to launch nuclear weapons or compromise the systems that support them – there are a number of options that might be considered and pursued in order to address these different types of threats and vulnerabilities. None, of these however, will be easy.

The most obvious and immediate priority for both the USA and Russia is working (potentially together) to harden and better protect nuclear systems against possible cyberattack, intrusion, or cyber-induced accidents. In fact, in October 2013 it was announced that Russian nuclear command and control networks would be protected against cyber incursion and attacks by “special units” of the Strategic Missile Forces (Russia Today 2014). Other measures will include better network defences and firewalls, more sophisticated cryptographic codes, upgraded and better protected communications systems (including cables), extra redundancy, and better training and screening for the practitioners that operate these systems (see Ullman 2015). However, and while comprehensive reviews are underway to assess the vulnerabilities of current US and Russian nuclear systems to cyberattacks, it may well be that US and Russian C2 infrastructure becomes more vulnerable to cyber as it is modernised and old analogue systems are replaced with increasingly hi-tech digital platforms. As a result, and while nuclear weapons and command and control infrastructure are likely to be the best protected of all computer systems, and “air gapped”14 from the wider Internet – this does not mean they are invulnerable or will continue to be secure in the future, particularly as systems are modernised or become more complex (Fritz 2009). Or as Peggy Morse, ICBM systems director at Boeing, put it, “while its old it’s very secure” (quoted in Reed 2012).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.