Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

17. Anti-growth movements fail---crackdown, and movements fail specifically in the modern era

Toney, 13, Simon Toney, University of Sydney, Department of Government and International Relations, Anti-Capitalism: A Beginner’s Guide, The perils of ‘movementism’, pg. 142-144, -FT

Many of these marches, protests and initiatives were very successful on their own terms. This is to say that they provided a focal point for activists who might not have had wider contact with concerned citizens or groups who shared some if not all of their aims and objectives. The protests were mobilising occasions. They enabled people to learn and share experiences in an intense environment which heightened the sense of a great deal being at stake. They also seemed to matter in tangible as well as intangible ways. Elites certainly gave the impression that they were concerned about these protests, and this served to reinforce the feeling that the stakes were high. Huge numbers of police and military personnel were used to protect conference centres, hotels and the participants themselves from the protesters. The protests tapped into popular sentiment and in their own ways affected the climate of opinion, such that elites had to be responsive to the concerns articulated by the protesters. So for a while it seemed that protests and demonstrations were an effective way of bringing activists together and influencing the actions and policies of global elites. Here, quite tangibly, was ‘the movement’. However, even within the movement there were those who expressed scepticism about such an emphasis being given to what had become a mobile carnival of protests and demonstrations - or ‘serial protesting’ as Naomi Klein aptly put it. Alex Callinicos, to take one notable example, offered a critique of what he termed ‘movementism’, which he equated to the belief that protests and demonstrations would displace the need for more durable forms of organisation, for the development of a programme and ultimately for capturing power from elites as KA opposed to merely influencing them in the direction of more just or equitable policies. He predicted, presciently as it turned out, that once the initial wave of energy and enthusiasm for protests had begun to wane, the shortcomings of this approach would be revealed and that in its stead would be left recrimination and few victories. What Callinicos neglects in his argument is that one of the reasons why activists focused on protests and demonstrations is because ‘party building’ seemed such a tired formula. Protests were the antidote to the Leninist ‘cure’ as far as many disaffiliated activists were concerned. On the other hand, it is certainly true that much of the momentum went out of summit protests over the course of the first decade of the twenty-first century. This was so for several reasons, which it is worth recounting to get a sense of the changing context in which anti-capitalist initiatives took place. Firstly, what became obvious was the mounting cost to individuals and groups of taking part in major demonstrations. As part of the War on Terror unleashed in the wake of the 9/11 al-Qaeda attacks, most states had invested significantly in intelligence services, counter-terrorism initiatives, surveillance capacity and police and army training to combat threats to ‘civil security’. This was justified by reference to the threat of attack from religious extremists. But ‘threat’ is an elastic term that can be used to encompass a range of ‘extremists’ who seem to represent a threat to law and order. Many of these techniques were now deployed against those engaged in anti-capitalist protests and demonstrations. It became familiar for protesters in, for example, the UK to be confronted by a squad of police officers - the Forward Intelligence Team (FIT) - brandishing cameras to record the faces of all those engaged in a protest. Such overt displays of policing are designed to fulfil two functions. Firstly, they demonstrate to the public that protests are considered by authorities on the same continuum as more violent or terroristic activities. Secondly, they are designed to intimidate participants. Making protestors the subject of overt surveillance is a Draconian reminder of who is in charge’. The idea is to ramp up the personal cost of being engaged in such activities, deterring ordinary people who may wish to demonstrate their displeasure at government policy or the actions of global elites. This leaves behind a rump of more militant activists who can more easily be monitored and controlled.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.