19. Capitalism is sustainable
Foss et al. 22 (Nicolai J. Foss , Peter G. Klein, and Samuele Murtinu, Foss has a works at the Copenhagen business school, Klein works for Baylor, and many more qualified authors, September 2022, accessed on 6-18-2022, Scandinavian Journal of Management, "The economy doesn’t need a reset, and neither does management theory", https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0956522122000215)
What these critics are describing here is not capitalism but “cronyism” (Rubin, 2016). As Klein et al. (2021) argue, confusing capitalism and cronyism is a long-standing mistake. Classic proponents of the free-enterprise system such as Schumpeter (1942)¸ Mises (1922), or Friedman (1962) describe capitalism as a mode of social organization which entails that (1) productive resources are (mostly) privately owned, (2) markets are used to allocate resources, products and services, (3) individuals and groups are (mostly) free to engage in economic activity without centralized control or interference from the state, and (4) institutions exist that enable (1) to (3), notably by making sure that property rights to resources are precisely delineated and enforced, which enables investments and make the costs of exchange relatively low (for qualifications, reservations, etc., see ). These are the “primitives” of capitalism as a system. Other oft-mentioned aspects (whether positive, negative, or purely descriptive), such as free movements of goods, capital, and labor across borders, are derived from these. Critics of capitalism take for granted that capitalism is responsible for rampant pollution, increasing inequality, concentration of industries, and so on, but rarely engage in systematic, empirically grounded, comparative institutional analysis. Both theory and a careful study of the historical record suggest that non-capitalist systems experience these problems to a far greater degree than capitalist systems. For example, in a market economy, well-defined property rights can keep pollution and other sustainability issues under control (Rothbard, 1982); in contrast, the worst known cases of industrial pollution occurred in the twentieth century in the non-capitalist countries behind the Iron Curtain. Freedom of contract will secure dynamism and social mobility and thus counteract tendencies to concentration of industries and capital and increasing inequality (Dean and Geloso, 2021, Nikolaev and Bennett, 2016, Bennett & Nikolaev, 2016). Socialist economies, and capitalist economies characterized by a substantial degree of government intervention, experience stagnation and social strife. The basic vision outlined by the above thinkers has been remarkably correct when applied to the economic history of the last two hundred years. Whenever capitalist principles have been applied they have tended to bring prosperity, education, improvements in health, and equality of opportunity (Leeson, 2010). The wealth generated by the operation of free markets provide the resources needed to deal with many environmental issues. Defining property rights to hitherto unowned resources, that is, pollution rights and making these tradeable has become an instrument of allocating such rights to their highest-valued uses and stimulate innovation in technologies that reduce CO2 emissions. Free markets and borders that are open to the movement of products and services enable the diffusion of such technologies. In short, free markets have increasingly been instrumental in dealing with ecological challenges. Among the various socio-economic systems, it is clear that “capitalism comes closest to meeting the conditions of efficiency and maximum well-being, even if no capitalist economies meet these conditions perfectly” ().