Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Err neg---all of their evidence comes from the position that civilian deaths are unacceptable, but all we actually need to win is that it doesn’t cause extinction

Matthew Kroenig 17 {Matthew Kroenig is an associate professor in the Department of Government and School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University and a senior fellow in the Brent Scowcroft Center on International Security at the Atlantic Council. Summer 2017. “The Limits of Damage Limitation.” https://muse-jhu-edu.proxy.lib.umich.edu/article/667398}//JM

In “Should the United States Reject MAD?” Charles Glaser and Steve Fetter argue that the United States should forgo a damage-limitation capability against China’s strategic forces.1 To arrive at this conclusion, however, they underestimate the advantages of a [End Page 199] damage-limitation strategy and do not even consider more feasible and desirable policy options for a strategic equilibrium with China. When these steps are corrected, it becomes clear that the United States should not forgo this capability. Rather, it should preserve its damage-limitation capability and quantitative nuclear superiority over China, while accepting the inevitability of China’s possession of an assured nuclear retaliatory capability. Glaser and Fetter begin by making the conceptual mistake of searching for an arbitrary threshold for meaningful damage limitation. In doing so, they underestimate the value of limiting damage in the event of nuclear war. Glaser and Fetter are correct that completely denying China’s nuclear deterrent is increasingly difficult if not impossible as China expands and modernizes its arsenal, but this is an unnecessarily high bar. Damage limitation is better conceived of as a continuous, not a binary, variable. There is no magical threshold beyond which the ability to limit damage in a nuclear war ceases to matter. Any U.S. president would want to protect as much of the country as possible in the event of a nuclear exchange, and any damage-limitation capability (even far below the threshold set by Glaser and Fetter) would therefore be valuable. To argue otherwise, one would have to argue that saving millions of American lives is unimportant or politically irrelevant, which is an untenable position.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.