Their countermeasures are hypothetical and easily overcome
Austin Long et al. 17 {Dr. Austin Long is a Senior Political Scientist at the RAND Corporation and non-resident Senior Fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute. 1/7/2017. “The Limits of Damage Limitation.” https://search.lib.umich.edu/articles?query=The+Limits+of+Damage+Limitation}//JM
Glaser and Fetter conclude their analysis without extending the measure-countermeasure competition very far. In so doing, they fall prey to the “fallacy of the last move,” as though there were no counters to the countermeasures they propose.2 For instance, China can employ decoy mobile missile complexes, but countering decoys is routine in long-term military competitions.3
In the case of surveillance of mobile missiles, U.S. space-based radar (SBR) or other [End Page 193] wide-area surveillance could be used to cue other sensors, such as those using multi- or hyperspectral imaging. These sensors could then detect subtle differences between a decoy missile complex and an actual missile complex. Stealth is likewise no panacea; it too is subject to countermeasures. Of course, responses on both sides can continue. But without more detailed analysis, it is difficult to say whether the United States or China will win the measure-countermeasure battle over a protracted period of time.
Likewise, Glaser and Fetter’s argument that China can deploy its mobile ICBMs in mountainous areas to limit SBR line of sight ignores SBR’s overhead perspective.4 Further, the road networks in valleys between mountains that could block radar coverage are often limited and steep. This would canalize mobile ICBMs operating in these areas and impose significant operational penalties. The countermeasure in this case might cost more in an operational sense than it would benefit the mobile missile force; for example, a brake failure on a descending transporter erector launcher (TEL) would be a disaster, and a very slow climb would make a located TEL a sitting duck.
Moreover, Chinese use of underground facilities and tunnels to conceal TELs might end up being perversely helpful to U.S. planners. The United States has dedicated enormous resources to intelligence capabilities intended to detect and map underground facilities.5 If U.S. intelligence is able to detect the entrances or exits to such facilities, then they would become highly vulnerable to attack.
Additionally, Glaser and Fetter acknowledge but do not assess two other systems that we have argued elsewhere could be used to hunt mobile missiles: stealthy penetrating unmanned aerial vehicles and unattended ground sensors.6 Admittedly, classification makes it difficult to fully evaluate these systems; nevertheless, they could contribute greatly to tracking mobile missiles. Both of these technologies are amplified by efforts to automate and rapidly integrate the data they provide for mobile missile hunting.7
The difficulties in obtaining survivable C2 that bedeviled the superpowers during the Cold War belie Glaser and Fetter’s somewhat blithe assessment of Chinese C2.8 C2 problems may be even more challenging today, as mobile command posts (even those in the air) can be tracked and targeted with the same sensors that track mobile missiles. In addition, non-kinetic options for disrupting C2 have proliferated over the past four decades. Even during the Cold War, the United States had apparently developed [End Page 194] electronic warfare techniques to disable Soviet strategic C2 systems.9 Today, the possibility for offensive cyber operations against such systems is believed to be substantially greater.10
OPERATIONAL AND TECHNICAL DIFFICULTIES: WARTIME ENDURANCE
Survivable second-strike forces must endure through all phases of a conflict. Yet Glaser and Fetter give short shrift to the potentially low wartime endurance of Chinese forces.
Glaser and Fetter assert that strict radio communications procedures and use of land-lines will suffice to keep Chinese mobile ICBMs secure. These countermeasures are difficult to sustain over time, however, and all are subject to potential attacker responses. Mobile operations will likely impose demands for frequent communications when coordinating movement, halts, fueling, and rest breaks between the TEL and multiple support vehicles. It is also likely, given Cold War experience and current Chinese practices, that Chinese mobile ICBMs would communicate their status to higher headquarters at least sporadically.11 Unlike ballistic missile submarines, mobile missile patrols travel in open territory. Road conditions, weather, crew health, and other factors could negatively affect such patrols, which are also potentially vulnerable to attack from special operations units or other ground forces.
In the face of these possibilities, sustained communications silence will become increasingly difficult over time. If communications are radio frequency, they are vulnerable to interception by U.S. signals intelligence sensors. Low probability of intercept transmissions will reduce but not eliminate that vulnerability for frequently communicating and difficult to duplicate TELs, which can be the target of barrage attack if imprecisely located. The use of dedicated military landlines would greatly restrict patrol areas while increasing mobile missile vulnerabilities if those lines were detected. Commercial landlines would impose fewer operational restrictions, but could be more easily penetrated. The United States was able to tap Soviet undersea naval communications in the Cold War; if motivated, it could likely tap Chinese commercial phone lines before a conflict begins.12
In addition, Glaser and Fetter argue that China could jam or attack SBR satellites during wartime. This is by far the most compelling of their countermeasure arguments. In wartime, though, jammers can potentially be targeted, and the fact that an area is being protected by jamming could cue other sensors to the likely mobile ICBM patrol area. Anti-satellite systems can likewise be targeted. Wartime is likely to produce first-strike advantages in the surveillance-countersurveillance competition, which will not benefit the party that has to move from a vulnerable to a less vulnerable posture. [End Page 195]
Furthermore, as Glaser and Fetter point out, “[F]or its DF-31As to survive, China must be able to launch them from unprepared sites.” Glaser and Fetter’s assumption, however, that China will be able to rely on “the Global Positioning System and other modern positioning and navigation services” is a dubious wartime proposition (p. 66). It seems more likely that Chinese mobile ICBMs will fire only from sites that have been pre-surveyed and geolocated in peacetime. Given the DF-31A’s weight and maneuverability challenges, this will impose even more limitations on China’s wartime operations.
POLITICAL AND ORGANIZATIONAL DIFFICULTIES
Even if the Chinese prove capable of technically demanding wartime operations, history suggests that they may face political and organizational challenges in preparing their forces during peacetime. This is especially true in the area of nuclear C2. All states face a sharp trade-off between negative control (assurances against unauthorized use) and positive control (assurances for authorized use) over their nuclear weapons. This trade-off produces strong incentives not to pursue the pre-delegation and launch-on-warning measures that Glaser and Fetter assume China will implement. These incentives may be particularly strong in authoritarian states, where the threat of internal unrest to nuclear forces, strains in civil-military relations, and worries about political succession may all bias decisions toward prioritizing negative control over survivable nuclear C2.
This pattern was demonstrated in the only other comparable case: the Cold War Soviet Union.13 Moscow’s civilian leadership abhorred pre-delegation. The Soviets also prioritized negative control in their launch procedures, which required no less than three members of the high command to authorize weapons release and two generals to generate portions of the launch code. As Glaser and Fetter themselves point out, China presently appears to favor negative control over an invulnerable posture for its mobile ICBMs in peacetime (pp. 72–73).
In sum, Glaser and Fetter omit from their analysis technical, organizational, and political factors favorable to U.S. damage-limiting capabilities. Yet damage limitation could be inadvisable even if technically plausible. We now turn to the political utility of damage limitation.